As is probably fairly clear, I’m a huge fan of the British Library Crime Classics; they turn up regularly on the Ramblings and are always a reliable, and enjoyable, read. However, I’ve also covered a number of the BL’s other wonderful series, the Women Writers books; this series reprints neglected women authors from the 20th century and there is such a great range of titles (with which I really must catch up…) Last year, BL released a Christmas collection of short stories, the first such anthology in the series, and it was a real treat. So I was very glad to learn that the publisher would be issuing another collection for 2023, and was happy to receive a review copy. The book is called “Stories for Winter and Nights by the Fire” and it was a delight from start to finish.
“Stories…” contains fourteen short works, and a look at the names on the cover gives a hint of the quality that’s going to be within. Angela Carter and Katherine Mansfield are going to be an instant draw for me, but the contents list reveals more potential treasures from Edith Wharton, Elizabeth Bowen, Elizabeth Taylor and Sylvia Townsend Warner, to name but a few. All of these are writers who’ve featured on the Ramblings before, but what interested me particular about this collection was the many names new to me, or relatively recent discoveries – I’ll comment more on that as I respond to the individual tales.
So let’s deal with the names I know first of all! The book opens with “The Reckoning” by Edith Wharton, and this is a sharp and beautifully written story about a modern couple espousing ideals for relationships which are far from traditional and have gained them a following amongst the smart set. However, one party may find themself hoist with their own petard… “A Cup of Tea” by Katharine Mansfield is equally spiky, with a society woman amusing herself with charitable behaviour, until her carefully constructed life is threatened by the presence of another. Sylvia Townsend Warner’s “The Cold” is as well observed as all of her short fictions are, and explores a world late in WW2 when the traditional structures of society are becoming unravelled and the stability of a home can be threatened by the servant problem! It’s a lightly-pitched story which actually has interesting depths.
Elizabeth Bowen is a favourite of mine, and I rate her short works very highly; so I was very pleased to see her included here, and her story, “Ann Lee”, is a strange and fascinating one about a woman who runs a hat shop – entirely on her terms. A slightly odd male visitor disconcerts two lady customers, who really don’t know what to make of his presence there! Then there’s Elizabeth Taylor’s “The Thames Spread Out”; I’m a huge fan of her writing, having read all of her novels, but her short stories are still waiting for me, and on the basis of this I have treats to come. Here, she tells of a woman stranded in her house because of the floods, reflecting on her life there which revolves around the visits of her married lover. Trapped inside, she considers the possibility of many kinds of freedom. And the final story in the book, “The Smile of Winter” by Angela Carter, is one I’ve read before; it comes from her collection “Fireworks“, a group of works drawing on her time in Japan, and it is of course as wonderful as all of her writing.
There is a special quality about a December sunset. The ruffles of red-gold gradually untightening, the congested mauve islands on a transparent sea of green, the ultimate luminous primrose dissolving into violet powder and then the cold, biting night, lit up by strange patches of colour that have somehow been forgotten in the sky. (Elizabeth Bibesco)
Of course, one of the treats of an anthology like this is reading authors new to you, and there were plenty of those here! Mary Angela Dickens is a relation of the great Charles, and her story “My Fellow Travellers” is a suitably spooky one for this time of year. “The Woman Who Was So Tired” by Elizabeth Banks was a real stand-out for me; set in the early 20th century, we see a woman journalist struggling to hold her own in the profession and keep her head above water. I was particularly interested to see a story by Elizabeth Bibesco, a name I’ve known for decades but never read; and her “A Motor” was a brilliantly economic and effective work exploring two different reactions to a car outside a particular house.
“The Snowstorm” by Violet M. MacDonald again explored slightly spooky territory, relating as it does an odd encounter between two strangers. Kate Roberts’ “November Fair/Ffair Gaeaf” (translated from the Welsh by Joseph P. Clancy) captures the attendees at a winter fair, with their observations on how times have changed and with several lives taking unexpected turns during the day. I’ve included Elizabeth Berridge‘s story here as I’ve only just discovered her writing, and I think she’s marvellous. “The Prisoner” is a poignant post-WW2 tale of the encounter, and tentative friendship, between an English woman and a German POW. It’s beautifully written, really evocative and surprisingly powerful. Francis Bellerby is another new name to me, and her “The Cut Finger” gives us a child’s eye view of a bleak winter holiday where life will change beyond recognition. It’s again moving and very evocative. In contrast, “My Life with R.H. Macy” by Shirley Jackson is a lighter (autofictional?) work which tells of the narrator’s attempts to work at the great American store, but how all understanding of what she should be doing is undermined by numbers!
I have to say that “Stories…” is a particularly strong collection with not a dud work in there; and I realise I’ve broken my usual rule with short story anthologies, and said something about every story!! The range is impressive, from spooky tales to humorous ones, poignant stories to more uplifting ones; and each catches an element of the winter season, a time when we can be in darker emotional places depending on our attitudes to the seasons – it really is an exemplary anthology!
As always, the book comes with commentary from Simon Thomas, the series consultant, and this time it’s in the form of an introduction where he gives an overview of the authors and their stories. I have to commend Simon and the BL team on this one (I guess series editor Alison Moss could well be responsible for the story selection); it’s a wonderful collection which offers riches to the reader, whether they know any of the writers’ work or not. It’s the perfect book to hunker down with, next to the fire, during these dull and cold evenings, and I can highly recommend it – an excellent read!