One Fine Day by Mollie Panter-Downes
A blindingly obvious fact to any reader of the Ramblings is that there is simply no rhyme nor reason to my reading. I’m like a straw in the wind; easily deflected from my course, subject to all sorts of influences, and my bookish whims are terrible. More often than not, I can’t actually recall what it was that pointed me in the direction of a particular volume; however, with “One Fine Day”, things are a little more clear!
The book was on my wish list as it was published by Virago. However, my copy is a lovely old hardback I picked up in the Bloomsbury Oxfam a while back (thanks to Simon, who pointed it out to me). It’s very appealing, with an embossed signature on the cover and a picture of Mollie inside. But it had sat on my shelves for over a year, till Caroline reviewed it recently and I thought that I really should pick it up.
Mollie Panter-Downes’ name is familiar to all lovers of a certain type of 20th century literature: as a columnist for the New Yorker, she was particularly noted for her column “Letter from London”, which was published during WW2 and later collected in the volume “London War Notes” – a much desired title which has just been reissued by Persephone (hurrah!). She wrote many short stories (also published by Persephone) but only a few novels – including “One Fine Day”.
The time is 1946 and the place a small English village by the coast, with the very archetypal name of Wealding. Our protagonists are Laura and Stephen Marshall, plus their 10-year-old daughter Victoria, and the action ostensibly takes place over the course of one hot summer post-War day. Stephen goes off to his commute by train to London; Victoria catches the bus to school in the local town; and Laura wrestles with the household chores, searches for Stuffy the lost family dog, and contemplates life and the future. Because this book is about so much more than just a day in the life of an English village…
As the day unfolds, we learn from Laura’s musings all about the post-War landscape in England; the losses that have taken place; the rationing which is still going on; and the struggles that the middle classes are going through. Quite brilliantly, and in beautiful prose, the book lays bare the incredible losses which have been caused by WW2, and also the seismic shift in class relations which has taken place. Laura is born of a class which had everything done for them (and her hideous mother still reflects this) – maids and nannies and cooks meant that she had beautiful, aristocratic hands and never had to cope with the complexities of shopping, washing, cooking and cleaning. But now the people who would have been servants in the old days have been freed by the way they had lived in the War, no longer a lower class working for others, but working in factories; and having tasted freedom they have no wish to go back to the old ways.
“Like young horses intoxicated with the feel of their freedom, Ethel and Violet had disappeared squealing into the big bright world where you knew where you were, where you could go to the flicks regular, and where you worked to the sound of dance music pouring out continuously, sweet and thick and insipid as condensed milk dripping through a hole in a tin.”
So Laura and many other formerly upper-middle class families are struggling; big old houses are being sold off to the National Trust; there is very little help for Laura and Stephen in the house and garden; and while the old families symbolically die off, the vital, energetic working class families expand.
Throughout the day, while her thoughts range back and forth, we learn about Laura’s past and her struggles and how she’s got to this point in her life. Although she is almost at the end of her tether, with the strain on her marriage obvious, a chance encounter with a gypsy in the wood, while searching for Stuffy, sends her to the top of Barrow Down; and as she surveys the landscape in front of her, Laura comes to the conclusion that none of the superficial issues she’s dealing with are important. The Romans have come and gone, the Germans have come and gone, and although humans are transient the land will endure. In this aspect, the book is a love-letter to the English countryside and it captures magnificently the still of a hot summer’s day by the coast.
I can’t praise Panter-Downes’ book enough. Caroline drew a comparison with “A Month in the Country”, and I see exactly what she means; in their portraits of the English countryside, and in their elegiac qualities, evoking a lost world, they have similarities. Panter-Downes’ prose is remarkable; delicious and poetic, with a rhythm all of its own, often taking on the dialect of whoever it’s related to, it’s quite entrancing and draws you right into its world.
The end of the book is an uplifting one: Laura clears her mind on the Downs, putting life into perspective and realising that what matters is her family and her future. Meanwhile, Stephen gets a chance to bond a little with the daughter who is something of a stranger (owing to the time away fighting). There is a feeling that the Marshalls will survive along with England, and whatever the post-War structure is, people will adjust.
“One Fine Day” was a wonderful read; I’m not sure what I expected, but I don’t think it was such complexity and such wonderful writing. Now I just have to restrain myself from rushing off to order every book of hers from Persephone…. !
Caroline
Jul 15, 2015 @ 09:33:34
I’m so glad you liked it as much as I did. I too did expect a lovely book but not such a great one. It works on so many levels. It’s complex and lyrical.
Thank you for the link.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 21, 2015 @ 18:28:40
It’s much greater than you might think, isn’t it? Thanks for prompting me to read it.
Liz Dexter
Jul 15, 2015 @ 10:06:58
This sounds like an amazing read (although I hope she finds the dog, maybe you can let me know privately one of these days). I’ll be getting London War Notes soon, I hope, when it’s Persephone Time of the Year again.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 21, 2015 @ 18:16:09
There isn’t a dog issue… 🙂
winstonsdad
Jul 15, 2015 @ 11:54:40
Sounds like a good slice of England at that time in her book as I read down I said to myself this is persephone type book
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 21, 2015 @ 18:15:31
It is – really captures the time.
colorpencil2014
Jul 15, 2015 @ 12:38:27
Thia sounds like a good read..put it on my (too long) list. Love the photo. xo Johanna
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 21, 2015 @ 18:15:14
:))
Jane @ Beyond Eden Rock
Jul 15, 2015 @ 12:55:57
Well that’s it, you and Caroline between you have sent me to the Virago bookcase to pick up my copy.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 21, 2015 @ 18:14:55
🙂 Excellent!
Christine Harding
Jul 15, 2015 @ 14:27:13
Her short stories are wonderful – if you haven’t already read it, do get Good Evening, Mrs Craven. In lovely, understated prose she shows how WW2 affected those who didn’t fight.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 21, 2015 @ 18:11:31
I have the short stories on the wishlist… 🙂
JacquiWine
Jul 15, 2015 @ 18:32:33
Wonderful review, one that makes me want to read the book (always a good thing). As you may have seen, I’m in the midst of another round of #TBR20, so no book buying right now, but it’s on the wishlist!
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 21, 2015 @ 18:11:12
🙂 Thanks! I’d highly recommend it – hope you eventually track down a copy.
heavenali
Jul 15, 2015 @ 18:50:17
I can’t think why I have never read this, I don’t even have a copy (yet!). I loved her short stories published by Persephone.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 21, 2015 @ 18:10:39
I think you’d love this Ali, and it’s a Virago so you could add to your collection of greens…..
Anbolyn Potter (@anbolynp)
Jul 15, 2015 @ 19:27:30
I love this book so much! I’m glad to see others are reading and enjoying it too. Her short stories are absolutely wonderful as well.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 21, 2015 @ 18:09:41
It’s wonderful, and I’m really looking forward to reading more of her work.
lindylit
Jul 18, 2015 @ 06:22:27
Ill have to look out for this. I have the Persephone audiobook of her war stories in my car and I’m enjoying listening to them so this sounds perfect
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 21, 2015 @ 18:09:20
It’s excellent – beautifully written and so evocative.
Kat
Jul 19, 2015 @ 01:52:25
Lovely review! This was one of my favorite Viragos, but it’s been a while–a long while–and perhaps I should reread it. What a beautiful edition! I did read London War Notes: it, too, is great.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 21, 2015 @ 18:06:28
I’m *so* tempted by London War Notes – and I’ve just been given a £30 Amazon voucher…..
Get ready for the#1947 Club! | Kaggsy's Bookish Ramblings
Sep 11, 2016 @ 12:15:22
#1947 Club – Some of my previous reviews | Kaggsy's Bookish Ramblings
Oct 14, 2016 @ 06:17:38
The #1947Club is here! – Stuck in a Book
Oct 15, 2016 @ 22:21:51
The eternal conflict of love and art… #myhusbandsimon @BL_Publishing | Kaggsy's Bookish Ramblings
May 25, 2020 @ 06:26:00