When Chris over at Calmgrove canvassed for interest in a readalong of the Narnia books, back in the middle of the year, I was instantly interested; C.S. Lewis‘s books were crucial to me when I was growing up, and I read them over and over again. I still have my fragile old Puffin paperbacks and although I haven’t looked at them in decades, I do feel that I know them backwards. I wondered how I would find them now, as an old bat rather than a young stripling, so I shall try to stick to the schedule and re-read one a month – which shouldn’t be too much of a hardship!
Happily, the reading order is publication order, of which I am very much in favour – after all, that’s how Lewis wrote them and the order in which the story developed, so that just seems right to me. The first book in the series is of course the most famous, “The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe”, and even those who haven’t read the whole sequence probably know of this one.
The book opens simply with the lines “Once there were four children whose names were Peter, Susan, Edmund, and Lucy.” They will be our protagonists throughout, and as the story begins they’ve been sent away to the country during WW2 for their own safety. Billeted in a big rambling house with an old professor and his housekeeper, there’s plenty to do outside to occupy the children. However, bad weather sends them off exploring the house and it’s in a room empty of everything but a wardrobe where the adventures begin. Lucy, the youngest, discovers as she hides in the wardrobe that it leads to another land, called Narnia, where it’s always winter but never Christmas. Here she meets a faun, Mr. Tumnus and has tea with him. There are all manner of talking animals and trees, and eventually Mr. Tumnus reveals the land is ruled by a White Witch who has an interest in human children… Lucy makes it back to her own world, but no-one believes she’s been gone; but things do not end there, and all four children will enter Narnia, encounter Aslan the lion king and fight battles they never imagined…
A great crowd of people were standing all round the Stone Table and though the moon was shining many of them carried torches which burned with evil-looking red flames and black smoke. But such people! Ogres with monstrous teeth, and wolves, and bull-headed men; spirits of evil trees and poisonous plants; and other creatures whom I won’t describe because if I did the grown-ups would probably not let you read this book – Cruels and Hags and Incubuses, Wraiths, Horrors, Efreets, Sprites, Orknies, Wooses, and Ettins. In fact here were all those who were on the Witch’s side and whom the Wolf had summoned at her command. And right in the middle, standing by the Table, was the Witch herself.
The story captivates from the start, and reading it as an adult I can see why. Much of this I put down to Lewis’s wonderful writing style; he was obviously a born storyteller. Conversational, descriptive, addressing the reader directly, any child picking this up would be sucked straight into the story – and I certainly was, both as a youngster and now! The story itself is totally absorbing – its creatures marvellous inventions, its setting completely realised, and the concept of a portal into another world through a wardrobe is just inspired. The action is stirring, the good characters lovable and the evil ones quite chilling. It’s a fully convincing world, and I know I would have liked to step into it when I was young.
Obviously reading the book now I see the underlying moral concepts, and these *are* interesting. Lewis’s Christianity is visible though it never takes over the story; rather ideas of good and evil are demonstrated, and certain characters learn lessons about what’s right and wrong. The bad guys are brilliantly portrayed, and really scary – and appear quite strikingly in one of Pauline Baynes’ excellent illustrations.
The latter, in fact, deserve special mention of their own as they must have formed the visual image of Narnia for a multitude of children as well as myself. The drawings are perfect, as far as I’m concerned, and I’ve never wanted to see anyone else’s interpretation. As I re-read “Lion…” I realised quite how important those drawings had been to my perceptions of Narnia, augmenting Lewis’s wonderfully chatty prose – they really are stunning!
So they lived in great joy and if ever they remembered their life in this world it was only as one remembers a dream.
I re-read “Lion…” in pretty much one sitting and found myself completely engrossed, despite knowing the story so well. Even though I remembered what was to come, the tension was still there when characters were in peril, and I found myself immersed emotionally in the telling of the tale. I come back to Lewis’s writing here, because I really can’t praise it enough – I have a love of language and good writing, and maybe some of that stems from my childhood reading of the Narnia books.
Well, I could go on but there’s no point slingling more superlatives about; and I’m sure that Chris will have a really interesting post coming out looking at the underlying symbolism and imagery in the books, and the themes. Me, I’m just happy I had the excuse of reacquainting myself with this wonderful storyteller; and as I remember the rest of the books less well than this one, I’m really looking forward to the rest of the readalong! 😀
Dec 30, 2021 @ 08:06:35
How I loved these as a child! And when I reread them with my boys about 8-10 years ago, I realised they work really well for reading out loud. Lucy and Jill were my favourite characters in fiction for a long, long time.
Dec 30, 2021 @ 15:59:19
Me too – they were the perfect escapism. And I can image they would be wonderful to read out loud, as Lewis has such a lovely conversational style!
Dec 30, 2021 @ 08:56:30
I have never read them but have always thought I should. They were not part of my childhood. Enjoy.🐧😁
Dec 30, 2021 @ 15:58:47
I think they’re definitely worth reading, despite not having read them as a child – they still charm me as an adult!
Dec 30, 2021 @ 12:10:10
I love the idea of going back to books like that, and digesting them as an adult! I think it really shows not just the books’ lasting power, but also how you’ve grown and how your thinking has changed. What a great idea for a read-along!
Dec 30, 2021 @ 15:58:04
I always feel there’s a slight risk with a re-read of a book you’ve loved in the past, so I was very happy this one held up. His books certainly retain their charm for me, and it’s a tribute to his writing that he held my attention as an adult!
Dec 30, 2021 @ 12:40:57
That cover brings back such happy memories!
Dec 30, 2021 @ 15:56:49
I know. I read it over and over as a child!
Dec 30, 2021 @ 14:26:39
Glad this was as magical for you now as back then. This wasn’t a childhood book for me, either but I can well imagine being captivated by it back then. I agree on Lewis storytelling, it really draws one right in.
Dec 30, 2021 @ 15:56:36
It was such a lovely read, and I was happy to be drawn back into the world of Narnia. His storytelling is just marvellous!
Dec 30, 2021 @ 17:36:47
Shockingly I only ever read the first book, but it really stayed with me for years. I will watch this read-a-long from the sidelines with interest. I know how loved these books are. Those old editions are so recognisable, probably from my school library or somewhere.
Dec 30, 2021 @ 19:34:04
I remember Lion very clearly, probably because my Offspring watched the TV adaptation a lot. The rest will be more of a rediscovery, which I’m looking forward to. I think these particular editions were around for a long time, and I do love the covers!
Dec 30, 2021 @ 18:38:47
Lovely post Kaggsy! I also have such fond memories of these books. I especially associate them with this time of year as I got them in my stocking. I wish I’d done the same as you and kept my editions, yours is such a treat to see.
Dec 30, 2021 @ 19:33:09
Thanks Madame B! Yes, wonderful to read around Christmas and I’m glad I kept my old copies – though I *would* like to know where The Last Battle is!!!
Dec 30, 2021 @ 18:39:36
I also loved these as a child, but haven’t returned to them since. I like the idea of trying it, though, with such a different perspective. Happy New Year!
Dec 30, 2021 @ 19:32:26
It’s certainly interesting going back to them after such a long gap, and as an adult – and I found myself appreciating Lewis’s style more than I would have before! Definitely worth a revisit, and Happy New Year to you too!
Dec 30, 2021 @ 19:14:29
I didn’t read the whole series until I was a teen with The Dawn Treader being the accepts that I read as a kid. Evening read the books as a teen I like them. I might has to read them again.
Dec 30, 2021 @ 19:31:10
They’re lovely books, and I’m looking forward to revisiting the rest! Do join in – one book a month is an easy target!!
Dec 31, 2021 @ 10:11:55
Thanks so much for joining in the readalong and for this sympathetic review. I too was impressed by Lewis’s narrative style this time, and am reminded by Diana Wynne Jones’s observations. She attended both Lewis’s and Tolkien’s lectures at Oxford, and while Tolkien was largely inaudible, mumbling towards the blackboard and only coming alive when declaiming Old English, Lewis gave a clear delivery and engaged his audience. That difference in approach is, I think, reflected to a large extent in their respective writings. I’ll respond to your other points on my own post now!
Dec 31, 2021 @ 11:57:44
Well, thanks for starting the Narniathon, as I doubt I would have re-engage with the books without it, and I’m so happy I did. That’s interesting but not unexpected re the difference between Tolkien and Lewis. Their different styles definitely reflect how I think of them, with Lewis being the more gregarious one. And as I mentioned (and you responded to my comment) his stengths as a storyteller shone through here and I found myself admiring him even more. Looking forward to next month’s read!
Dec 31, 2021 @ 14:13:59
Totally agree about the Baynes illustrations. She improved on them herself with some lovely color illustrations for a later edition of LWW which I also happily own. I don’t know if she did all the books. No other illustrators need apply as far as I’m concerned, and I’m not a fan of the later cover designs either – especially photographic ones, which seem totally “off” in portraying this magical world to me.
Thanks for your thoughts and I look forward to further adventures in narnia with you.
Jan 01, 2022 @ 15:05:14
Exactly – only Baynes will do for me. I can’t bear anyone else’s illustrations and she completely captures Narnia for me! Onwards and upwards to the next story!!
Dec 31, 2021 @ 18:53:28
How lovely that the books have held up for you! Hope you enjoy the rest of the series as well.
Jan 01, 2022 @ 14:57:46
I was pleased, I must say – I thought I might have moved on too much, but the books were so important to me as a child that this first one still touched me. Lovely!
Jan 01, 2022 @ 07:01:12
Jan 02, 2022 @ 18:06:42
I have those same editions, and yes, you’re completely right about the illustrations inside as well as the covers!
Jan 02, 2022 @ 20:38:22
I don’t think I could ever readthe books with any illustrations – Baynes just captures Narnia for me!
Jan 05, 2022 @ 08:45:58
Jan 05, 2022 @ 11:42:04
I also loved these books as a child and was tempted to re-read but I worried that all I would see as an adult was the Christian allegory and so spoil the memory!
Jan 05, 2022 @ 14:17:25
It’s always a risk, isn’t it, that a re-read will disappoint. Luckily, the allegory didn’t get in the way for me here!
Jan 19, 2022 @ 22:00:35
This is where I began as a young reader and this was definitely my favourites of the series, the most well-worn volume. (I never read The Last Battle until I was an adult, reluctant to see the series end and, likely, afraid of the cover illustrations when I was wee.) When I reread as an adult, I followed the other order. I think I remember reading somewhere that Lewis himself advised that order at some point? But maybe I’ve bought into some publishing preference instead! Heheh
Jan 20, 2022 @ 11:00:07
I do like to stick to the published order of books – my reasoning is that that’s how the original readers read them! And you can see how Lewis developed and built up his world, expanding it over the range of books. So I’m happy Chris has gone for this order!!
Mar 30, 2022 @ 07:01:12
Jul 22, 2022 @ 07:01:39
Aug 26, 2022 @ 07:00:37