Recent months have seen me enjoying a number of wonderful re-reads, returning to pivotal books in my life which I haven’t been back to for ages! This was kick-started by the Narniathon, and having revisited all of C.S. Lewis’s wonderful stories, I also re-read The Lord of the Rings and the second book in Mervyn Peake’s Gormenghast sequence. So I guess it was kind of inevitable that when Annabel announced she was hosting a readalong of Susan Cooper’s “The Dark is Rising” series of books that I would want to join in. As I mentioned before, I’ve intended to go back to these a number of times in the recent past, as there are regular readalongs hosted on Twitter; however, this time it’s for real, and as the books are spaced out one a month I shan’t get overwhelmed and pressurised and will enjoy the event!
Unlike the other books I mentioned above, I first read the Cooper books in my early twenties; I was very into exploring the Arthurian legends at the time, and so they were a natural fit as they draw on that mythology. But I haven’t been back to them in a very long time, so I did wonder how I would find them! The first book in the series is “Over Sea, Under Stone” and it introduces us to the Drew family: the children Simon, Jane and Barney, plus their mother Ellen and father Dick. The family is visiting Trewissick in Cornwall to stay with Great Uncle Merry at The Grey House. Merry is not an actual relation, more of a long-term family friend, but he and the dog Rufus will join the children in their adventures.
The West Country is, of course, always connected with Logres, the ancient realm of King Arthur, and young Barney is steeped in the stories and legends of that time. However, the children are initially attracted by more prosaic matters, in the form of a shining yacht in the harbour, owned by the smooth Mr Withers and his sister. However, when exploring the secret rooms and attics of the Grey House, Barney stumbles across an ancient document with some kind of map or diagram on it. The children instantly think of treasure, and try to make sense of their find.
…You have heard me talk of Logres. It was the old name for this country, thousands of years ago; in the old days when the struggle between good and evil was more bitter and open than it is now. That struggle goes on all around us all the time, like two armies fighting. And sometimes one of them seems to be winning and sometimes the other, but neither has ever triumphed altogether. Nor ever will … for there is something of each in every man.
However, it soon becomes clear that other forces are after the map, and events take a dramatic turn. There are burglary attempts on the house; the Drews are invited on a trip aboard the yacht; Jane has an uncomfortable encounter with a local vicar; and Great-Uncle Merry turns out to have more power than the children might have expected. There are explorations in the dark around strange standing stones; and the children don’t know who they can trust: from the vicar to the Withers pair to the housekeeper Mrs. Palk, everyone seems to be acting suspiciously. What is actually at stake here, and can the children find it before the forces of evil??
Well – what struck me on this revisit (as with Lewis, actually) is how well children’s books were written during the mid-20th century!! “Over Sea…” is gripping from start to finish, with a wonderfully exciting and imaginative plot, atmospheric descriptions and settings, and a real sense of menace from the baddies. Cooper is brilliant at ramping up the tension as the story reaches its climax, and even though I knew the plot and that good would prevail, I found myself on tenterhooks, mentally shouting warnings to the Drews! There’s a really exciting set-piece involving cave exploration which made my claustrophobia kick in, and a lovely linguistic twist at the end. As for the children, well they’re real, believable children with flaws and tempers, and the narrative very cleverly lets them operate in acceptable paramenters: there are times when the adults *won’t* let them go out, their worries can be dismissed because they’re youngsters, and they have to be creative to get the chance to investigate and find the truth.
Looking back, I can see why I loved this series of books; they weave an exciting children’s story into a mythological setting with ups and downs and tension and triumphs and it all works wonderfully well. You get a real sense of the oldness of the landscape, of the fact that things could be lost in the distant past and still be there to be found if you know where to look, and it’s all presented in a beautiful seaside setting. As an opener to a series that I recall will become darker, it’s a real winner, and I’m so glad Annabel’s set up this reading event because this was the perfect time to revisit the books. A marvellous start to #TDiRS22, and the only problem I had was that I was desperate to pick up the second book and carry on reading – but I *will* pace myself!!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 08:24:59
I loved these as a child, too, being obsessed with all things Arthurian. Lovely that you’re enjoying them all over again.
Aug 26, 2022 @ 12:33:45
They really do stand up to a revisit – such wonderful storytelling! Makes me think I should dig out whatever I have left in the way of Arthurian books…
Aug 26, 2022 @ 09:20:28
I have never read these and I have no idea why as they would have been a perfect fit for Ma as a child. I think they were published just as I was beginning to read adult books. I keep hearing about them so maybe I need to finally read them 😀
Aug 26, 2022 @ 12:33:05
Oddly I can’t imagine why I missed them as a child either, but at least I did catch up with them in my early 20s! And they do stand up to re-reading as an adult so I hope you can give them a try! 😀
Aug 26, 2022 @ 09:57:21
I’ve never been to Mevagissey, the presumed original of Cooper’s seaside town, but I found it evoked all those familiar, almost timeless, seaside holidays I’ve had and – in a case of Nature imitating Art – still do, since we’re coming to an end of a break in Aberdyfi, coincidentally a setting in the final two books which I’ve yet to read! Place is definitely an extra character in these tales, as I think you’ve suggested. Enjoyed this review, thanks!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 12:31:20
Thanks Chris! I loved revisiting this, and I’m so looking forward to the following books. And it did really bring back those seaside holidays of my youth – as you say, that kind of thing is timeless!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 11:03:23
Yay! Thank you so much for joining in. This opener in the sequence was indeed a perfect summer read and evocation of place plus a teaser for the darker fare to come. I love your old Puffins too.
Aug 26, 2022 @ 12:30:16
I really enjoyed this re-read Annabel, so I’m very glad you set up this event! Such a good series – and I’m glad I still have my original Penguins!!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 12:08:24
Some of those series for young people really were absolutely fantastic, and I’m glad you’re revisiting this one. I admit I didn’t grow up with these novels, but I agree that some of those ‘legend’ series were really very well done. And young people like gripping stories just as much as adults do!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 12:29:35
I’m certainly rediscovering just how good some of those books were, Margot! And they’ve stood the test of time very well – especially as a still find them so exciting to read as a mature adult!!!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 13:46:02
I agree about the sense of tension increasing dramatically – the bad characters are really scary!
I have not reread the entire series in order since childhood so this group read will be entertaining.
I originally bought the Puffin paperback on a family vacation to Bermuda. I am annoyed it is missing from my shelves, although I have all the others (including some autographed copies).
Constance
Aug 26, 2022 @ 16:25:55
Yes, it really is a tense read at times – you want to scream out warnings to the characters! Such a wonderfully written book, and I’m enjoying the revisit so far. I’m sorry your Puffin is missing, though I envy your autographed copies!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 14:55:57
Ooh nice! I so need to revisit Arthur, first. Do you know, some of the Broceliande forest has burnt this year!!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 14:58:06
That’s awful news about Broceliande – which part?
Aug 26, 2022 @ 16:22:25
All these fires are awful….😳😳
Aug 26, 2022 @ 17:28:15
near Paimpont. see here for instance https://www.connexionfrance.com/article/French-news/Fire-in-Brittany-s-mythical-King-Arthur-forest-has-been-halted
Aug 26, 2022 @ 17:37:37
Ah, Paimpont is said to be the remaining heart of the ancient forest. That’s a real shame if even a fair proportion has been saved.
Aug 26, 2022 @ 16:24:34
Arthur’s always worth a revisit. And that’s such sad news about the forest – the reports of the fires raging over the world have been terrible this summer… 😦
Aug 26, 2022 @ 14:57:39
#Snap!
“There’s a really exciting set-piece involving cave exploration which made my claustrophobia kick in.” I have never forgotten that scene, and I won’t be surprised if the recurring nightmare revisits tonight! It comes to me on and off even now, decades after I read that book in my twenties too, when I was doing a Post Grad course in children’s lit and chose to do Arthurian legends.
(I forgive you, of course.)
Aug 26, 2022 @ 16:23:48
Oops, sorry. But yes, caves and I really don’t get on – I find that Robert Macfarlane’s books (much as I love them) tend to have that effect as he does love to go down a narrow cave, or somewhere tiny and underground…
Books do affect us, though, don’t they? I still remembered parts of this even after decades…
Aug 27, 2022 @ 01:00:31
It a superb example of what a great writer she was.
Aug 27, 2022 @ 15:13:05
😊 She was!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 15:45:35
Aww, I have a box set that I bought in my 20s, but I wish that I had your lovely Puffins (many of my childhood favourites were in these editions and they’ve held up beautifully through the years, even after many rereads).
Aug 26, 2022 @ 16:21:01
I do love a vintage Puffin! And yes – these are still in surprisingly good condition considering their age!!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 16:44:42
I haven’t read anything by Susan Cooper! This does sound excellent and I think I’ll give it a go (gasp!) It reminded me (and your saying how well written children’s books were) of a reading scheme my daughter had when she was about 8/9 called Tim and Tobias. It was from the ’60’s/’70’s and was in a whole different ball park to Biff and Chip (although they are fun). Tense, quite scary, not an adult in sight, brilliant!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 16:52:56
Definitely one worth seeking out – really tense in places too! As for Tim and Tobias, at least one of my children read them at school and they were much more substantial than Biff and Chip (who turned up for a later child if I recall). I do love that era of children’s writing when the books were intelligently written and didn’t pander…
Aug 26, 2022 @ 17:26:01
Lovely post, Karen. Fantasy isn’t my genre, but your enthusiasm for this series really shines through! The series still sells relatively well, as far as I know. At least, we’ve had it in the bookshop from time to time, so it’s good to know that it still stands up 50 or so years down the line. You might be aware of this already, but if not….I’m pretty sure there’s a Susan Cooper TDiR episode in the Backlisted podcast archive somewhere. 🙂
Aug 26, 2022 @ 17:55:16
Thanks Jacqui! I’m glad the series still sells, and I suspect that has much to do with Robert Macfarlane championing it. As for Backlisted, there’s an episode for everything usually, isn’t there? I’m still catching up with the older ones, though I will probably save that one until I’ve finished the re-read!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 18:02:27
Funnily enough, Robert Macfarlane was one of the guests on the episode in question, along with Jackie Morris., Good idea to leave it till you’ve finished the series, although I think its mostly about book two. 🙂
Aug 26, 2022 @ 18:43:59
LOL, that doesn’t surprise me! But I’ll wait until I’ve re-read them all!!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 17:52:56
I haven’t read this series before and though I was hoping very much to join in the readathon, I seem to have a little t much on my plate at the moment. These sound wonderful, especially that it tells an enjoyable adventure story but with the mythological background coming through well too.
Aug 26, 2022 @ 17:55:46
It’s a wonderful sequence, so do read the books if you get the chance. There are many layers to them!
Aug 26, 2022 @ 18:12:16
It sounds it. Let me see if I can make the time, I’ll try and catch up and join in next month.
Aug 26, 2022 @ 18:43:24
I hope you can! They’re slimmish books most of them so easy to squeeze in!!
Aug 28, 2022 @ 12:22:20
I went ahead and ordered the books from a second hand shop online. Now to try and get the first two read in time!
Aug 28, 2022 @ 14:44:44
Excellent! I do hope you like the series – they’re not too long!
Aug 27, 2022 @ 15:38:46
Great review. Mine will post tomorrow. It’s not my favorite of the series but I do appreciate the atmospheric writing. I’m glad Cooper reconsidered her first intention and did go back to these characters!
Aug 27, 2022 @ 19:58:39
Thank you! I can’t remember huge amounts about the books, but am very much looking forward to getting on with the next one! 😀
Aug 28, 2022 @ 08:23:59
I’m not familiar with this series of books. I do contemplate reading the Lord of the Rings again. Really enjoyed those years ago.
Aug 28, 2022 @ 14:45:05
Some books really do benefit from a re-read, epecially after a bit of a gap!!
Aug 28, 2022 @ 19:21:25
I’m sure I had the very Puffin copies pictured above – and glad to hear that they can sustain a re-read (I thought they would).
Aug 28, 2022 @ 19:24:13
They’re lovely old editions, and yes – so far, very much holding my attention!!
Aug 29, 2022 @ 02:00:47
This is great and makes me want to read these again! I too read these for the first time as an adult and found them utterly captivating and unputdownable. I’ve read ‘The Dark Is Rising’ several times.
Aug 29, 2022 @ 10:27:53
Thanks Lori! Very much looking forward to getting to the next book!
Aug 29, 2022 @ 11:47:11
Still playing catch up with blogs. I have never read Susan Cooper, along with all those others I haven’t ever read. I uses to love the King Arthur legend when I was a child though so I would have probably liked these back then. Happy re-reading.
Aug 29, 2022 @ 13:50:44
I think you would have liked these, Ali! Odd that I didn’t come across them as a child, but I’m glad I eventually did!!
Aug 29, 2022 @ 21:10:38
I read these as a child and then re-read them in my 20s and with Matthew over Christmas and New Year 2012. I love the Arthurian myth and realistic children in all of them. I love your copies, too: I had a single-volume one but I remember those. I hope your Silver on the Tree doesn’t have the Mari Llwyd on the front, though, I can’t quite see in your picture and I’m going to have to brace myself for that when December comes around!
Aug 30, 2022 @ 11:38:01
They’re certainly books you can revisit at any age, I think. and I’m very fond of my editions, though I think you may have to peek through your fingers when it’s time for Silver on the Tree!!!
Aug 30, 2022 @ 18:28:14
I read *nearly* every book in the fantasy section of my library growing up, but somehow this one slipped past me… It sounds like it might be worth picking up as an adult, too!
Aug 30, 2022 @ 18:34:51
Definitely – I was early 20s when I first read it, and I’m a lot older now and still love it!!
Sep 28, 2022 @ 07:01:52