One of the pivotal reads of my life, and one which I’ve mentioned a couple of times recently in guest posts, was my first encounter at the age of 19 with the Gormenghast books by Mervyn Peake. I devoured them over a dull Christmas, and became totally absorbed in the strange and wonderful world the author had created. They had such an effect on me that I later ended up becoming involved with the running of the Mervyn Peake Society for some years, and I’ve always thought that Peake’s polymath talents have been underappreciated. Painter, illustrator, poet, playwright and author, he really was a multi-talented man.
Over the years I’ve returned to the books several times, and they would most definitely be on my desert island list. However, writing about them brought them back into my mind and I’ve been circling a re-read. A chance stumble upon a lovely, readable omnibus edition in a charity shop clinched it – now was the time to make a return journey to Gormenghast castle and its inhabitants. I actually read the book over a week where both myself and OH were unwell with some nasty undefined bug that was doing the rounds, and it’s a tribute to Peake’s genius that I was completely absorbed – I spent the week *living* through the events in Gormenghast once more. I’ll confess up front that I’m not going to be able to give an objective, coherent review – I’m too close to the book, it means too much to me and so I’ll just try to capture some impressions and thoughts.
The action is set in the castle of Gormenghast, home to the ancient family of Groan, and opens with the birth of an heir, Titus, to Lord Sepulchrave, the 76th earl, and his wife Gertrude. This is a world ruled by the iron hand of ritual; every day defined by a prescribed set of actions that Sepulchrave and the denizens have to undertake, under the hand of the ancient and bad-tempered master of ritual, Sourdust. In rapid succession we meet all the main characters: Flay, stick-like and monosyllabic manservant to Lord Sepulchrave; Fuchsia, 15-year-old daughter of the house of Groan; Dr. Bernard Prunesquallor and his sister Irma, not quite part of the higher echelons but above the servants; Nannie Slagg, ancient nurse to the children of Groan; Swelter, the monumentally huge chef; and Steerpike, the high-shouldered, sly kitchen lad who comes to play a pivotal part in the story.
Those are just a few of the characters in this rich and wonderful book, all vividly alive, in fact larger than life; but there are many more who pass through its pages. To be honest, the castle itself, a rambling, sprawling, undefined structure with architectural oddities and marvels all over it, is very much a character itself. And as the castle’s denizens reacts to the birth of Titus, Steerpike makes an escape from the kitchens and into the upper life of the Groans; Flay and Swelter clash in a way that will eventually seal their fates; Fuchsia responds badly to the changes coming in the castle; and the story follows the events of the first year of Titus’s life which will bring dramatic events to a cataclysmic head. More I am not going to say, because if you’ve never read Peake you have the biggest treat in the world awaiting you.
To attempt to give a summary of the plot would be impossible in a blog post, and also I want to avoid any kind of spoiler; so instead I’ll just focus on a few of the strands which gave me the most pleasure. Of course, watching Steerpike’s inexorable rise through the ranks, as he twists every situation to his own advantage, is fascinating – like watching a poisonous animal in action; the development of Prunesquallor, who initially appears to be all hysteria and puff but gradually reveals himself to have a hidden intelligence and subtle understanding of what’s going on around him, is wonderful to see; and the late-flowering relationship between Fuchsia and her father Sepulchrave is particularly poignant and heartbreaking. The Flay-Swelter rivalry and conflict is gripping, and has you on the edge of your seat at several points; and the manipulation of the Groan twins Cora and Clarice is clever and vicious. As for the melancholy Sepulchrave and his library – let’s not go there…..
The library appeared to spread outwards from him as from a core. His dejection infected the air about him and diffused his illness upon every side. All things in the long room absorbed his melancholia. The shadowing galleries brooded with slow anguish; the books receding into the deep corners, tier upon tier, seemed each a separate tragic note in a monumental fugue of volumes.
Even though I know this story better than I had remembered, the joy of revisiting it was immense. The first time reading it I was stunned by the writing and the characterisation, reading obsessively to follow the story. However, on re-reads you can wallow in the wonder of the prose and the sheer brilliance of the imagery. Wherever Gormenghast is meant to be (in my mind it sits apart in some kind of parallel world!), it is truly alive in its own right and it’s a creation of genius. “Titus Groan” contains vivid and wonderful writing, the prose of an artist bringing to life his creation with word paintings. The pictures it creates, of corridors and roofscapes, attics and kitchens, faded ceremonial rooms and bedrooms full of ivy, birds and white cats, are unique and stamped in my brain. Peake’s writing summons a chiaroscuro world where light and dark are in constant contrast and although the book contains a scattering of his pen and ink drawings of characters, you don’t need them – the writing provides the pictures for you.
As Fuchsia climbed into the winding darkness her body was impregnated and made faint by a qualm as of green April. Her heart beat painfully.
This is a love that equals in its power the love of man for woman and reaches inwards as deeply. It is the love of man or of a woman for their world. For the world of their centre where their lives burn genuinely and with a free flame… The love of the painted standing alone and staring, staring at the great coloured surface he is making. Standing with him in the room the rearing canvas stares back with tentative shapes halted in their growth, moving in a new rhythm from floor to ceiling… The window gapes as he inhales his world. His world: a rented room, and turpentine. He moves towards his half-born. he is in love. … the painted mutters, ‘I am me’ on his lone raft of floorboards, so… dark Fuchsia (says) on her twisting staircase, ‘I am home’.
(Fuchsia’s love for her secret attic)
And revisiting these characters, with all their quirks and individual traits, was a wonderful experience. From Prunesquallor’s hyena laugh to Irma’s obsession with her long white neck; Steerpike’s cold mechanical calculation to Swelter’s almost sensual greed and hatred; Fuchsia’s petulance and need for affection to Sepulchrave’s melancholia and love of his books; all the characters leap off the page, alive and vivid, and they’re ones you don’t forget. The wonderful Flay is one of my favourites, but each strange but compelling character is necessary to the story. I’ve pondered in the past about a sub-strand of the plot, involving Keda; one of the Bright Carvers, people who live outside the walls of the castle, she’s brought in as a wet-nurse for Titus, and her life and fate is related alongside that of the castle. The passion she and her people feel is in direct contrast to the sterility of the dying line inside the castle, and I think is a necessary counterpoint to that story.
What I had either forgotten or perhaps never appreciated is quite how Dickensian Peake’s writing is. His wonderful use of names, of course, echoes the great Victorian writer, and he demonstrates the same kind of dry wit at times. The sprawling world of Gormenghast in many ways echoes Dickens’ London, and the use of evil, melodrama and dark themes was common to both writers.
I accept that “Titus Groan” and Peake’s writing will not be for everyone. The events and characters are often grotesque, the subject matter grim and the sense of ennui and destruction noticeable. The books were influenced by Peake’s experiences as a child living in Tientsin, but also by his life experiences. As a war artist, he was one of the first civilians to see inside Belsen and witness the prisoners dying as their liberators arrived; therefore it’s hard not to read significance into something as simple as Steerpike’s kitchen uniform having a striped jacket… (“Titus Groan” was published in 1946). The book contains darkness, yes, but a necessary darkness; it’s also shot through with brilliance and often great beauty.
I did wonder, after all these years and several reads, what I would feel approaching the Gormenghast books again. Although I’ll never be able to recreate the thrill of that first read, this re-read stunned me in many places with the brilliance of the writing and plotting, completely involved me emotionally and left me drained at the end. It’s one of those books, a select few, that you inhabit rather than just read. The main problem I have now is in restraining myself from simply picking up the next book and carrying on with the re-read – I want to give myself time to recover a little, but the temptation is immense!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 07:31:24
What a lovely review. Rereading was clearly the right decision for you, and I’m tempted to take my own old omnibus edition down from the shelf now.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 09:31:43
Thanks Jane! Yes, this was the perfect time and I’m so glad I read Titus Groan now. I feel myself being drawn to pick up Gormenghast pretty soon, too!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 07:41:03
I’m sorry to say that these books have never really appealed to me in spite of their stellar reputation. Nevertheless, I do appreciate the appeal of revisiting some old favourites every now and again. It sounds like it was the right decision for you. Lovely post.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 09:31:08
Thanks Jacqui! Yes, the books are not for everyone. I loved my revisit though – and the timing was just perfect!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 08:33:04
Gormenghast has never appealed to me personally although I did buy the books for my son after a friend said they had been the books that cemented in him a lifelong love of reading. That said, your compelling review has tempted me to give them a whirl, especially as I’m fairly certain that the set I bought my son is at this very moment collecting dust in the attic!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 09:30:34
I’d certainly give them a try if you have a set – they may appeal, they may not, but they’re certainly a rich and visual treat if you love them.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 08:46:02
Wow, an impassioned response. Sadly, I can’t say my own matched yours. I started the first book some years ago & couldn’t get on with it. Listened to a radio dramatisation some time later – same result. A marmite book, perhaps
Feb 17, 2017 @ 09:29:59
Definitely marmite, I agree – which is why I said the books won’t be for all, but fortunately for me I love them (and marmite!!)
Feb 17, 2017 @ 09:12:29
Oh God, I loved those books (well, the last one a bit less), and it’s so long since I read them! I was completely obsessed by Peake in my teens; I’ve gone off most of his poetry rather now, but his prose and art are wonderful. Your lovely review has brought it all back! I must reread them, if only because I had a certain perverse liking for Steerpike and I wonder whether I would still have that.
I agree about the link with Dickens and I don’t think it’s too far-fetched at all to think of Belsen – I’m pretty sure I read somewhere that Peake had a nervous breakdown after witnessing the camp’s liberation. But I can’t provide a source for that. You’d be more likely to know than me!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 09:29:26
I think with Titus Alone you almost need to leave a bit of space and read it slightly separately from the rest – it *is* very different, and very much more obviously informed by his Belsen experiences. Yes, he did have a breakdown – some feel he never really recovered. I had a perverse liking for Steerpike (still do) and I certainly think the books stand up to re-reading.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 10:01:57
Lovely review, Karen. Your courageous to revisit an old favourite and write about it. I’m always so reluctant. I have this on my piles and you make me think I should finally read it. If only I was keener on hefty books.
I had no idea he witnessed the liberation. That must have marked him. I love “house charcaters” so that will be an additional treat, I’m sure.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 12:29:14
It’s a big book, but one I found very easy to read (but then it wasn’t my first time!) Revisiting old book loves is always risky but this one just seems to get better and better!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 10:32:07
Confession time: I’ve never read these books. I think I may have leafed through them at some point and feared they might not appeal, but you might tempt me to give them a go.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 12:28:23
They’re not for everyone, I accept that. But do have a go if you can, just in case they’re a series of books you fall in love with!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 12:18:09
A glorious, GLORIOUS review of a wonderful book. You conjured, instantly, the feeling I had when I read it, like you, I think, late teens, very early twenties. It is WELL overdue for a re-read – one I’ve understandably been afraid to make, in case that earlier-in-my-life power is not repeated – but you have demonstrated that other pleasures await. I think my heart might break with some of it.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 12:27:49
Thank you, Lady F! Yes, it stands re-reading – I’ve revisited it several times since my first visit, and I get different joys each time. My heart breaks at several points in the story, though….
Feb 17, 2017 @ 13:18:05
I bought Titus Groan at a library sale when I was a teenager, but I never got around to reading it until 2001. The cover, with its Gothic castle, sold me. When I did read it, I loved it, but, again, I have but haven’t read the other two in the trilogy. My husband and I once shared our home with 9 cats (and an Irish Wolfhound). As friends were leaving one night after dinner, the cats circling around my feet, my French friend mentioned that I reminded her of Countess Gertrude with her sea of white cats, although ours weren’t all white. My mouth dropped open because I was sure I’d found the only other person in the world who knew Titus Groan! By the way, I hated the TV production many years ago. Too Tim Burtonesque.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 17:06:30
The TV production didn’t work although it was a brave try. Peake’s own illustrations and the visual word pictures he paints are so strong that I don’t think anything can approach it. I personally feel it’s best to read the first two books fairly close together and then leave a gap before Titus Alone – the latter is a powerful work but can be a bit of a shock if you go straight into it after the first two.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 15:15:13
One of the great British novels of the 20th century. Very interesting to hear your early history with it.
It’s obviously not for readers who claim that they can’t visualize, or those who value a novel by how quickly they turn the pages. It’s a book to be read image by image.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 16:58:34
I couldn’t agree more, and I wish his talents were more widely appreciated. I still have a head full of images the book created!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 16:17:32
I read these books for the first time in my thirties, and I wished I had encountered them earlier. The content isn’t exactly fantasy – nothing happens that is physically impossible, and nor are we asked to visualise imaginary creatures- but it all seems to be happening, as you say, in some strange parallel universe. To sustain something such as this vervso long a span is a remarkable feat of the imagination.
I was particularly taken by the quality of Peake’s prose. Peake was, if course, an artist, so it’s perhaps not surprising that his imagination was primarily visual – in every scene, it’s the visual details that come first. This may have made for cumbersome prose were it not that Peake had a marvellous ear for the rhythms of English prose. As a consequence of his focus on visual description, the narrative frequently lacks pace, but this is one of those works where the momentum is generated by mass rather than by velocity.
Incidentally, I have an edition of Treasure Island illustrated by Peake, and many of his illustrations (especially the one of Blind Pew) really are the stuff of nightmares.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 16:57:56
Yes, I think Peake’s prose and all his other artforms are intertwined – he wrote as a painter paints and his the descriptions in his books are so vivid they live with you. His paintings and illustrations are stunning – if you want nightmares, have a look at those for The Rime of the Ancient Mariner!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 16:32:58
I admit I have never fancied reading Gormenhghast – not sure it’s really for me. However your enthusiasm for it infectious. I hope you and OH are fully recovered now. Glad your re-reading was so positive.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 16:54:40
No, not for everyone I admit – but just right for me at the moment! Yes, we’re pretty much back to health, though sadly having to deal with effects of poor mother-in-law who passed away recently aged 95. So I didn’t really have much of a half term break….
Feb 17, 2017 @ 17:04:13
Very sorry to hear about your mother-in-law. We broke up today – been a long half term.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 17:07:43
Thanks Ali. Gosh, that was a long half term – have a lovely break!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 17:20:17
I recall reading this in my teens and being totally confused by the experience. I didnt really understand what I was reading but knew I wanted to read it – in other words I enjoyed the bafflement.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 17:24:48
🙂 Sometimes a book doesn’t completely make sense first time round – but the reading experience can still be fabulous!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 20:14:46
I loved the first two books, Titus Groan and Gormenghast but was hugely disappointed with Titus Alone. As soon as I finished them I decided I’d want to read them again and I keep wondering if that time is approaching. I may like Titus Alone better the second time around. I read them in my early thirties and as much as I loved them then I do wish I’d read them earlier.
My favourite quote, which reminds me of Beckett’s prose, is:
Have you read Titus Awakes and/or Boy in Darkness?
Feb 17, 2017 @ 20:42:39
Titus Groan is a shock on first reading, because it’s so different to the first two and I wasn’t quite reading for that. I’ve appreciated it more on re-reading and I do tend to try to leave a gap between Gormenghast and it. Love that quote – Peake’s prose is just marvellous. I’ve read Boy in Darkness at least once, though a long time ago, and I remember it as being most odd. As for Titus Awakes, I own a copy but I’m a little scared of reading it. I loved Maeve Gilmore – was fortunate enough to meet her once not long before her death – but I fear the book won’t necessarily sit well with the others. Let’s face it, it won’t be a Mervyn book so maybe it’s better left alone.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 20:49:28
I remember reading this, probably in my teens – I still have some memory of it which suggests it made an impression, though I didn’t go on to read the trilogy. It is brave to read an old favourite – something I haven’t done in a while – just in case the magic isn’t there any more.
Feb 17, 2017 @ 21:38:24
I hoped I’d be on safe ground with this re-read, as I *have* re-read it before – but I hadn’t expected quite such a strong emotional response!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 20:56:28
I’ve always felt a mild sense of guilt about abandoning Ghormenghast, and felt that maybe it was just bad timing and I should try it again some time, but amongst the comments here I see faces I know and trust who had the same experience… and yet you loved it, enough to re-read it.
Strange things, books, eh?
Feb 17, 2017 @ 21:37:45
Well, if Peake wasn’t for you, he wasn’t for you. That’s the joy of reading and the interest in reading other people’s blogs – there are books I can’t *get* even though others love them!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 21:04:45
I first read the Gormenghast books as a teenager too and fell in love with Mervyn Peake’s wonderfully descriptive writing (although as others have mentioned, I liked Titus Alone less than the first two). It’s been years since my last re-read and I’ve been thinking for a while that it’s time to read them again!
Feb 17, 2017 @ 21:36:58
Sounds like the time could definitely be right, then! They’re books I’ve found have stood the test of time and don’t suffer at all on a re-read!
Feb 18, 2017 @ 17:06:11
I think I was about 18 when I read Gormenghast, although my mum had recommended the books for years before (like I was going to listen then!). I absolutely adored them, especially the first. I’ve been wanting to re-read them for ages – but never quite got around to it (ditto reading Mr Pye – I can remember the TV adapation with Derek Jacobi clearly).
Feb 18, 2017 @ 17:12:37
Well, there’s no time like the present for a re-read! And yes, Mr Pye is worth a revisit – I thought the Derek Jacobi adaptation was much more successful than the attempts at the Gormenghast books!!
Feb 22, 2017 @ 16:26:53
Delighted to discover your fondness for this sequence as I added it to my list of must-reads several years ago and then lost track of why, recently finding myself lamenting its page count and thinking about quietly striking it from the list. Now I will replace the copy I’d passed along and make a point of it: thank you!
Feb 22, 2017 @ 16:27:57
PS Just wanted to add that I particularly loved the idea that the castle is a character in its own right!
Feb 22, 2017 @ 16:28:28
It certainly seems to be an organic, living and breathing entity in its own right!
Feb 22, 2017 @ 16:28:57
It’s long but I never found it hard to read – in fact I sailed through it! Hope you enjoy it! 🙂
Mar 01, 2017 @ 06:32:43
Your Monthly Links – Zen Mischief
Mar 01, 2017 @ 12:36:07
Mar 03, 2017 @ 18:53:17
Mar 13, 2017 @ 11:07:27
I can’t wait to read these! Every book is, to a lesser or greater extent, a different world, but books such as these feel like a parallel reality.
Mar 13, 2017 @ 11:45:18
The Gormenghast books are particularly special to me – such a wonderful revisit!
Jun 16, 2017 @ 11:59:53
A great review!. I read the three books in 2009 and, since this moment, my readings are not the same. In a few cases I remember all what I read from a book. That´s happen with the two first Titus books. I love how you defined it: “It’s one of those books, a select few, that you inhabit rather than just read”. I feel the same. The problem that I have had is: what can I read after Peake? Everything I’ve read doesn´t reached the same level in my soul: great readings like “The magus” (Fowles), Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell (S. Clarke), Possession (Byatt), One hundred years of solitude (García Márquez), for example, but… I don´t feel the same, don´t inhabit them… What are your readings similar to Titus Books to inhabit them?
Jun 16, 2017 @ 13:58:01
Thank you! Yes, these certainly are books that stay with you. As for others that I lived through, well they’re not always similar in type at all to Peake’s. It depends what kind of reading mood you’re in I suppose. I read The Lord of the Rings trilogy over and over at one point and really inhabited that. More recently, Georges Perec’s Life: A User’s Manual was all encompassing. And I’ve had periods when a particular author was the thing that took over my life – Colette, Virginia Woolf, French existentialists – when you’ve lived as long as I have, there are lots!
Jul 06, 2017 @ 16:05:09
Thank you very much for your quick answer… For your comments, I would recommend you any book by Angela Carter… She´s fantastic! and I love her writings too!
Jul 06, 2017 @ 16:14:16
No probs! I have read a little Carter, although not enough! I did meet her once, though, at a film screening and talk she did and I have the signed book to prove it! :))
Jul 06, 2017 @ 16:21:34
really? :):)
“Night at circus” … It´s different… as different is Peake … There are books that haunt and catch that certain sense of wonder that I like so much
Jul 06, 2017 @ 17:37:17
Yes – Georges Perec is doing a lot of that for me at the moment!
Jul 06, 2017 @ 16:34:15
I wanted to share with you an interesting link:
http://lithub.com/on-the-13-words-that-made-me-a-writer/
Jul 06, 2017 @ 17:36:56
Thank you!
Dec 28, 2017 @ 18:13:06
Excellent overview! I only recently found out about these books and read Titus Groan. I’m very intrigued and will try to read one installment per year, as well as search for other Peake works in used bookstores.
https://leviathanbound.wordpress.com/2017/12/28/titus-groan/
Dec 29, 2017 @ 16:43:24
I have a long history with Peake and his work and I just love everything he produced. You have treats in store, but I would personally recommend leaving a gap between Gormenghast and Titus Alone, as there is such a shift in focus that it can be hard to adjust if you read them closely, one after the other (as I did, first time round…)
Dec 29, 2017 @ 16:48:43
Thanks for the recommendations! I started Titus Groan on October 1 this fall, and tried to read about a chapter a day. I finished at the end of November. I think I will do the same for each book in the series. They just seem like fall books. So I’ll have a full year between each reading session.
Dec 29, 2017 @ 16:50:32
That should work well then! Happy reading! 🙂
Your Monthly Links | Zen Mischief
Jun 07, 2018 @ 17:58:34
May 02, 2022 @ 07:01:15
Jul 06, 2022 @ 07:00:24
Jul 22, 2022 @ 07:01:43
Dec 31, 2022 @ 07:00:29