It’s been noticeable over recent months how much joy I’ve been getting out of revisiting old favourite books of mine from many years ago. There has, of course, been the Narniathon, which was a real treat; I hadn’t read these books for decades and had almost forgotten how much I love them. Then there was “The Lord of the Rings”; I’d meant to go back to these for some time, but the prompting of the #1954 Club had me re-reading all three, which was a profound and emotional experience. These two sequences of books were pivotal to me in my younger years and are still lodged in my heart. There’s one more sequence which is just as dear to me, if not more so, and that’s the “Gormenghast” books by Mervyn Peake. I’ve written before about how much these books mean to me, and I did in fact spend some time in helping run the Mervyn Peake Society. I revisited the first book, “Titus Groan”, back in 2017 when I stumbled across a nice-looking omnibus edition, and it was a wonderful experience. Somehow, I’ve never picked up the second, “Gormenghast”, since then although it’s been calling to me strongly. But a nudge from a recent, wonderful episode of the Backlisted podcast was all I needed, and I spent a week at the end of June hiding from the horrors of our world in the marvellous creation which is Mervyn Peake’s Gormenghast castle – and it was pure heaven.
“Titus Groan” opened with the birth of the titular figure, who is the 77th Earl of Gormenghast, and ended when he was one year old. That book encompassed much change in the castle, including deaths of family members and others, conflict and banishment, and the inexorable rise of the kitchen boy, Steerpike, intent on making his way to a position of power. It was a rich and wonderful book, conjuring a marvellous array of scenes and characters, all vividly portrayed in Peake’s incredible prose. “Gormenghast” takes up the story when Titus has reached the age of seven and covers a longer, ten year, period; during this time, Titus will come of age, lose his boyhood and grow into young adulthood; and Gormenghast itself will be changed forever.
It’s hard to go into plot specifics because not only is the story rich and complex, I also would hate to spoil the joy of anyone reading these books for the first time. However, I’ll pick out some standout elements for me! Firstly, Titus goes to school with the ‘ordinary’ boys of the castle, and the creation of the school and its Professors is just masterly; a ragged and assorted bunch, with the most wonderful names (Perch-Prism, Cutflower (“La!”), Opus Fluke), they provide the story with much humour, something which is not necessarily always associated with Peake’s work.
It was as though Cutflower was so glad to be alive that he had never lived. Every moment was vivid, a coloured thing, a trill or a crackle of words in the air. Who could imagine, while Cutflower was around, that there were such vulgar monsters as death, birth, love, art and pain around the corner? It was too embarrassing to contemplate. If Cutflower knew of them he kept it secret. Over their gaping and sepulchral deeps he skimmed now here, now there, in his private canoe, changing his course with a flick of his paddle when death’s black whale, or the red squid of passions, lifted for a moment its body from the brine.
Bellgrove, the headmaster, is a memorable and often moving character, and his association with the bony Irma Prunesquallor (sister of the castle’s doctor) is full of mirth and pathos. In fact, the Prunesquallors generally are a delight, with ‘Dr. Prune’ showing himself to have much more intelligence and backbone than you might expect as events move on; he’s a character I grew to love as the story progressed.
Then there are Titus and his sister Fuchsia, who move closer together and find a warm sibling connection through the book. Their mother Gertrude, Countess Groan, comes to the fore, and an old friend reappears. I won’t say who the latter is, but his presence in the book and final fate were incredibly moving. But of course, running through the story is the presence of the evil Steerpike, determined to take control, whether it means he has to seduce Fuchsia, take over as Master of Lore or kill anyone in his way. The action builds gradually to a dramatic climax in the midst of a biblical flood where Titus will show his mettle; but will he manage to quash the rebellion in his own spirit?
Revisiting “Gormenghast” was the most wonderful experience, and I spent a week sunk in the book, having the joy of re-encountering old friends and reliving the story, as well as reminding myself just what a completely individual author Mervyn Peake was. He’s a writer who breaks all the rules which would be taught in courses nowadays; paragraphs can be two pages or twenty; he flits from viewpoint to viewpoint; he writes luxuriant and involved descriptions that some idiot taking a writing course would tell you to remove. Oddly, I found myself thinking of Dostoevsky, who I once described as writing in scenes or set pieces, and Peake’s books can be very much like that in places. However, because he breaks all the rules, his books are truly glorious and unique pieces of art which stand alone to my mind – there really *is* nothing like them.
What struck me the most this time round, perhaps (and thanks to Andy Miller on the Backlisted podcast for picking up on this) was the painterly, visual quality of his writing; his chapters are often those set pieces, conjuring a section of his created world, and his words summon vivid images of the vast Gormenghast castle, with its endless corridors and stairs and roofs, in almost an Escher-like fashion, which are unmappable and never end. I have to say that I prefer things undefined when it comes to Gormenghast, and I love the fact that it sprawls on forever and that even those who live in it don’t know its complete extent – even Steerpike, who’s roamed and mapped it widely, can get lost. Gormenghast is a book which conjures endless vistas in the mind and they stay with you; although I was astonished to find on this read (and I’ve read the book a *lot*) that there were scenes I had forgotten! Because the writing and the imagery is so vivid, I find I *live* the book alongside the characters; this is something you inhabit rather than just read. Whilst I was making my way happily through it, the world of Gormenghast was much more real than my own.
As I’ve said, I think Peake is unique; if I had to state any influence it would be Dickens with his love of the grotesque, whether in character or name, and his long, labyrinthine narratives. But the world Peake has created, with it crumbling castle, vivid and often bizarre characters, compelling and haunting narrative, and unforgettable story, is truly individual. Yes, it’s dark – there is real evil present, most particularly in Steerpike (and yet, somehow there is a conflict in the reader, in that although he has done vile things, he has challenged the stagnant status quo so that you still feel a sneaking sympathy for him). His rebellion against the system is different to Titus’s resistance to his inherited role, and yet they are flipsides of the same coin.
…he knew that there would be a difference; and that there could be no other place exactly like his home. It was this difference that he longed for. There would be other rivers; and others mountains; other forests and other skies.
I could go on and on about how brilliant these books are; they basically changed my life when I read them as a 19-year-old, and I will always love them. I accept they’re not for all, but it has been wonderful to see the outpouring of love for them online after the Backlisted episode. If you’ve not read them, I would encourage you to approach them with an open mind and give them a try; you might be surprised! As for me, I have a massive book hangover, and although my impulse is to pick up “Titus Alone” and carry on with the sequence, I’m not going to; that book is very different to the other two and needs a gap before it. In the meantime, I shall let Gormenghast swill around in my head; I’ve seen the place described as a ‘state of mind’ and I totally get that! 😀
*****
I must add a little bit about editions at the end here. I re-read “Titus Groan” in this new omnibus edition which I picked up at a charity shop, thinking it would be easier to handle than my fragile old Penguins. I started to do the same with “Gormenghast”, but was soon discombobulated by several typos which should have been picked up in proofing.
I got my old edition out and not only were the typos not there, there were also variations in the setting of the book, missing asterisks that divided up some sections and the like. I instantly ditched the omnibus and it will go back to the charity shop, not least for the mistake of having “Gormenghast Trilogy” on the cover. I went back to my original editions and was happy with a 1978 version of “Gormenghast” – there’s a lot to be said for reading your original copies!
Jul 06, 2022 @ 07:34:26
A trilogy I’ve always been meaning to read but somehow never got round to doing so.
Jul 06, 2022 @ 10:45:09
They’re definitely worth some of your reading time!!
Jul 06, 2022 @ 16:29:10
Oh me too!
Jul 09, 2022 @ 11:09:14
Go for it!!!!!!
Jul 06, 2022 @ 09:04:16
Sounds wonderful, Karen! I have these books in the Folio Society edition, so I must really give it a go.
Jul 06, 2022 @ 10:44:57
Oh, do! They’re wonderfully immersive and a Folio edition is always good!
Jul 06, 2022 @ 09:09:48
How odd about the edition having so many errors – usually those come out of scanning the original pages and the character recognition being off but this sounds different.
Matthew read these a good while ago now and absolutely loved them – he has a greater tolerance for this kind of book than I do, having read several large Russians in his youth. We still somehow have two copies of it in the house … !
Jul 06, 2022 @ 10:44:20
I was surprised, I must admit – because the Penguin wasn’t that long ago (well, not in my terms anyway) but I guess Vintage either scanned or reset or something. Anyway, they’re wonderful books and I loved my revisit – such joy!
Jul 06, 2022 @ 09:33:47
Oh what an immersive and ecstatic review this is, I love it! Now here’s synchronicity: after sharing thoughts on Narnia with you over the months and inadvertently shadowing you on LOTR (I’ve just the appendices to read and comment on) I have serendipitously started Gormenghast, using the self-same Penguin edition as you read from!
I agree with its characterisation as a wander through an art gallery – at least as far as I’ve got – and am reminded so much of the fantastic prison vistas of Piranesi’s Carceri. It’s my first read and I’m savouring it in small chunks…
Jul 06, 2022 @ 10:43:19
Thank you! This is one of those books which is part of me, so it was always going to be a personal response to the re-read. So glad you’ve started reading this – and I’ll look forward to hearing your thoughts eventually. It’s definitely one to savour… 😊
Jul 06, 2022 @ 10:51:01
I think the Gormenghastly trilogy-in-one-volume version returned to Peake’s own writing, rather than reprinting Eyre & Spottiswood amendments, so there’s the further dilemma that it may be both truer and falser than the original, especially in Titus Alone, which was adapted from fragmentary drafts..
Jul 06, 2022 @ 11:15:46
That’s interesting – I may have to do comparisons of the two Titus Alones before considering donating the single volume… ;D
Jul 06, 2022 @ 11:17:48
How lovely that you’ve reread beloved books and still find them entrancing! Bit of a risky business fraught with the possibility of disappointment. I didn’t get beyond Titus Groan but I do remember being struck by Peake’s use of language and vivid imagery.
Jul 06, 2022 @ 15:44:04
It definitely is risky, but as I’ve re-read these several times I felt I was on reasonably safe ground. The writing is so individual and the imagery so strong – love it!
Jul 06, 2022 @ 12:08:25
That’s the thing about writing style, isn’t it? When you really see the story in your mind, it’s very hard not to be drawn in; a visual writing style can really invite the reader, can’t it? Add to that the rich family story, and I can see how you wanted a re-read of this one!
Jul 06, 2022 @ 15:43:19
Absolutely, Margot – the writing is so immersive that you just sink into that world. Love it!
Jul 06, 2022 @ 13:18:43
It’s been years since I read this book and your post has reminded me why I loved it so much! I must re-read it soon (after I re-read Titus Groan first, of course). I could never get into Titus Alone as it was so different from the other two books, but I should probably give that one another try as well.
Jul 06, 2022 @ 15:42:54
Oh, definitely re-read – I found it such a wonderful experience! I always try to leave a gap before Titus Alone, as it’s a very different book and works well in its own right if you can get the first two out of your head!
Jul 06, 2022 @ 14:43:01
Lovely review, your feelings for the books shine through! I’ve never read Peake and it does feel like a bit of a gap…
Jul 06, 2022 @ 15:41:21
Thanks Madame B – these are definitely desert island books! I highly recommend them, although I know they’re not for all…
Jul 06, 2022 @ 21:21:06
Re-reading old favourites is such a treat, I am currently re-reading Our Spoons Came From Woolworths. Gormenghast hasn’t ever appealed to me your probably not surprised to hear. It does sound like an incredible work though with such strong imagery.
Jul 07, 2022 @ 13:16:01
It is – I love a good re-read and don’t do it enough. This is probably not up your street but for me it’s something very special, so I was happy to revisit it!
Jul 06, 2022 @ 21:21:39
You’re probably not surprised I meant. 🙈
Jul 07, 2022 @ 13:15:25
LOL, yes!
Jul 06, 2022 @ 22:39:51
God I loved Titus Groan and Gormenghast when I read them! I had just finished uni, had no job, and had just broken up with a terrible boyfriend. My parents took me on holiday to North Yorkshire for a week and I did nothing but read Mervyn Peake, sulk, and hike. Conditions were perfect. The immensity of the castle is absolutely the draw for me; the way it feels genuinely like a little planet or moon, or a TARDIS, bigger on the inside (although obviously still pretty big on the outside). Titus Alone couldn’t hold my interest, I thought it all got too weird and the magic was lost when he left the castle, so I stopped there. But the first two – utterly brilliant. (Wonder if there’s an argument to be made for Peake-esque DNA in Susanna Clarke’s Piranesi…)
Jul 07, 2022 @ 13:15:17
I was in sulky teenager mode when I read them, over a Christmas I was spending with my family but really didn’t want to be there. Totally agree about the immensity of the castle – it really is wonderfully massive and unmapped! As for TA, it definitely is a shock to the system and I find it works better if you leave a gap between the first two and it. It’s very different but if you look at it as a book in its own right it has strengths…
Jul 07, 2022 @ 16:53:54
Glad to hear it’s worth returning to! And yes, there’s something about Peake that really does suit sulky teen-dom. The Gothic surrealness, perhaps!
Jul 08, 2022 @ 11:28:32
Definitely! I’m sure I wanted to be Fuchsia, and despite his awfulness I did love Steerpike!!
Jul 06, 2022 @ 23:12:54
There’s an exhibition of Maeve Gilmore’s work at Studio Voltaire in Clapham for another month. I haven’t been yet, but there’s an interesting review in the LRB.
Jul 07, 2022 @ 13:10:14
Yes, I saw that was on and have seen some coverage on Instagram – it looks excellent though alas I doubt I’ll be able to get down to see it… 😦
Jul 08, 2022 @ 03:03:18
Reading your review has certainly made me want to get to these as soon as I can manage. I’ve only read Peake’s poems as a child (and adult) but none of his prose yet. A gap I need to fill soon.
Jul 08, 2022 @ 11:27:10
Oh definitely! They’re so marvellous – I hope you like them!
Jul 08, 2022 @ 11:11:18
I loved Gormenghast too and your enthusiasm for the books reminds me how much. I usually hide away with T.H. Whyte or Ursula Le Guin when holidays come round, but you have reminded me that I must reread this too. It’s darker of course. Interesting that you mention escaping from the horrors of the world to read these books. Sometimes I feel that our modern day society is so dysfunctional we are going back there!
Jul 08, 2022 @ 11:26:12
I definitely recommend a re-read of these – absolutely lovely (in a dark way, of course!) And yes, it does seem that we’re whizzing backwards every day into more primitive times – very depressing…
Jul 10, 2022 @ 11:19:04
Of the series of you mention this is the one which I would entertain rereading (I loved the Narnia books as a child but don’t really feel a need to read again; Lord of the Rings has never appealed to me). Good to have your warning over which edition not to read!
Jul 10, 2022 @ 16:44:37
I’ve certainly loved my revisits to the Peakes and I’m ultimately happy to have gone back t my original editions!
Jul 22, 2022 @ 07:01:45
Aug 26, 2022 @ 07:00:43
Dec 31, 2022 @ 07:00:32