It’s always a joy to find that one of our club weeks is a year which contains some Agatha Christie titles (and she had such a long writing career that it’s often the case!). I’m a lifelong lover of her books, and so frankly any excuse for a revisit suits me. 1976 is a particularly poignant year, however, as Christie had sadly died in the January; and so the posthumous release of “Sleeping Murder: Miss Marple’s Final Case” was something of an occasion. I still have my original paperback, bought at the time, and picking it up was a bit of a trip into the past.
“Sleeping Murder”, like “Curtain: Poirot’s Last Case” which had been released shortly before Christie’s death, had actually been written some decades before publication. During World War 2, because of the precariousness of life, Christie had written the last stories of her two great detectives in case she didn’t make it through the conflict. In the end, of course, she did, so the two stories were kept on standby until the 1970s. This potentially throws up some contradictions, but Miss Marple’s final outing is a joy from start to finish.
The book opens with a young woman, Gwenda Reed, arriving in the UK from her home of New Zealand in search of a house. Recently married to Giles, who will follow her soon, she’s excited to be making a new life in a new country. Chance (or fate?) leads her to a house called Hillside which feels instantly as if it will be home. Having bought the house and moved in, Gwenda begins to get her home ready for her husband’s arrival. However, as she explores Hillside, she has a number of uncanny experiences where she appears to know things about the house of which she can’t possibly be aware. Making her escape to London for a break, she stays with the novelist Raymond West and his wife; and it is on a visit to the theatre that some words from a play trigger a vision of a murder from the past. Is it real or imaginary? Fortunately, West’s Aunt Jane is on hand to help investigate and find a solution – although her advice from the start is to “let sleeping murder lie”, as a number of revelations could spell danger…
‘You are two very nice and charming young people (if you will allow me to say so). You are newly married and are happy together. Don’t, I beg of you, start to uncover things that may – well, that may – how shall I put it? – that might upset and distress you.’
Gwenda stared at her. ‘You’re thinking of something special – of something – what is it you’re hinting at?’
‘Not hinting, dear. Just advising you (because I’ve lived a long time and I know how very upsetting human nature can be) to let well alone. That’s my advice: let well alone.’
More I will not say because too much revealing of this plot in advance would really spoil the reading of it! Christie is an author who never disappoints me, and although her later works didn’t quite reach the high standard of her early ones, I always enjoy them. However, “Sleeping…” *is* in fact an early work as it was written during the 1940s, and the plotting and atmosphere is excellent. The book features one of my favourite Christie tropes, that of the investigation of a murder in the past which just won’t go away; and the extra element of mystery behind Gwenda’s background as well as her almost supernatural reaction to a house she’s never seen before add little frissons of terror at times – Christie really could add those little spooky touches so well.
As for the murder and the solution, I had a faint glimmering of who the killer was as I read on through the book, and I suspect this is a memory of previous revisits rather than any great detecting abilities on my behalf. “Sleeping Murder” has a complex and often dark plot, with hints of some most unpleasant undercurrents, and a really nasty killer. The denouement is very satisfying, Miss Marple a wonderful sleuth as always, and the book features little cameos of St. Mary Mead and Jane Marple’s friends, all of which rounds things off nicely. There *is* an oddity in that one short paragraph or two which open a chapter were later re-used in a Tommy and Tuppence mystery; this was much later in Christie’s writing career and so it may be that she just liked the piece and re-used it, or it may be that she had forgotten. It plays no real part in the Marple story, but is pivotal to the T&T mystery so in the end it really doesn’t matter!
So, a wonderful start to the #1976Club reading week! I raced through “Sleeping Murder” with much enjoyment and happiness – Golden Age crime is always my comfort reading, and Christie always a treat. “Sleeping Murder” was a fine way for Miss Marple to bow out; clever, sometimes chilling, eminently readable and a great reminder that you should never take older women for granted… Let’s hope the rest of 1976’s books are this good! 😀
Oct 11, 2021 @ 08:53:00
I last read this one a few years ago and remember that for most of the book, Christie had me thinking on the wrong track though it remember eventually who it was that’d done it.
Oct 11, 2021 @ 11:32:26
She’s so clever at that! I only had an inkling because I’d read it before!!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 08:54:13
This is a favourite from my childhood. I didn’t realise it was always intended as the last case, as Curtain clearly was. I don’t remember enough about it to know if there was anything that would mark it out as such?
Oct 11, 2021 @ 11:32:04
It’s a great read, for sure! Christie wrote this for Miss Marple’s last case, and Curtain for Poirot, both during the war, so they were saved until the 1970s…
Oct 11, 2021 @ 09:14:35
Lovely! It’s always a pleasure to read your Agatha Christie reviews, and this ‘Club’ post did not disappoint! This novel sounds pretty dark for a Miss Marple, certainly not as cosy as some of the others in the series (although it’s been a while since I last read one of them). A good one for the run-up to Halloween, given the unsettling elements you’ve highlighted!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 11:09:14
Thanks Jacqui! Yes, this is quite a dark one and as I discussed with BookerTalk it could well be because of when she wrote it. There are quite a few shivery places and it’s definitely a good one to read at this time of year!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 09:21:32
I remember this one as being less “cosy” than many of her other books. Perhaps the atmosphere of war and the general feeling of doom was a factor
Oct 11, 2021 @ 10:27:22
Yes, there was a darkness and an edge to this one – maybe you’re right, she *was* writing in difficult circumstances!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 12:03:40
I really like those ‘past murders that won’t go away,’ too, KBR! And Christie did them very well. The misdirection in this one was really successful, too, and I thought she did the atmosphere effectively. It may not be her finest work, but it’s a good ‘un.
Oct 11, 2021 @ 15:33:04
She really was great at this type of mystery, wasn’t she? I like it a lot, even though it’s not always reckoned among her best.
Oct 11, 2021 @ 13:54:30
I’d forgotten this even existed and do not remember it. It will be a sad day when there is neither a Georgette Heyer or a Christie to read for the Club!
My sister and father were both huge fans of Michael Connelly’s Harry Bosch books for years before I bothered to check them out. I particularly like his investigation of cold cases, the murders from the past that everyone has given up on – but Harry says. “Everyone counts or nobody counts.”
Oct 11, 2021 @ 15:32:23
I know – I always rely on there being a Christie. I’ve not read any Connelly but I do love a cold case investigation!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 14:14:24
I often read a Christie novel for your club weeks, but I read Sleeping Murder just last year, so I’ve chosen something else this time instead. This is one of my favourite Marples so far – I loved the eerie atmosphere!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 14:50:00
It’s great, isn’t it? As you say, so eerie, and so cleverly done. I do love it when she does a historical mystery!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 17:40:00
Great start to the Club Kaggsy! I agree this is a darker Christie, and the killer is really horrible *shudder*
Oct 11, 2021 @ 19:03:46
Thanks Madame B! Yes, the murderer is quite chilling and his relationship to the victim really gives you the creeps!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 17:54:47
I have a lovely old hardback of this, and I was tempted to get it off the shelf. I do remember quite a bit about it though, as I also saw a TV adaptation of it too. It’s a cleverly plotted novel, and quite dark as others have said.
Oct 11, 2021 @ 19:03:06
It’s so tempting to just go for something that’s an old favourite and also you know you’re going to enjoy. It really is clever, and shows how she was quite able to take on darker topics!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 18:07:06
Re-reads are nearly always enjoyable. I probably won’t get the chance to contribute this time but I was thinking of a re-read of Selby’s The Demon. I remember likingit but not as much as his other books.
Oct 11, 2021 @ 19:02:16
They are – sometimes the comfort of reading an old favourite is just what you need. Sorry you can’t join in, but at least you might find a few interesting books being covered!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 18:49:57
Hurrah for Agatha! I haven’t read this since I was a teenager, but I remember it being one of my favourites – I was going to revisit for the club, but decided it would probably have enough readers this week 😀 I hadn’t heard about that re-used paragraph, how intriguing.
Oct 11, 2021 @ 19:00:52
I love Agatha – I can never have too much of her! It was such a treat, with all the best Marple-isms! The re-used paragraph is fascinating – I remember spotting it myself and then it was covered in the Charles Osborne book!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 19:09:49
I wanted to read this one but I haven’t read all of the Miss Marple books yet, so decided to wait. I have read Curtain, and thought it was very good, so I look forward to getting to this one someday.
Oct 11, 2021 @ 19:11:18
I get that – I’d love to read all the Christies in order from start to finish one day. I havent revisited Curtain for a long time so maybe I should pick it up soon!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 20:52:28
It’s been so long since I read this one. Fun to read about it again. That edition is pretty classic!
Oct 12, 2021 @ 10:13:48
It’s a great read – so clever and entertaining, with little shivers built in. I’m very fond of the covers from that era and fortunately many of my books are that kind of design!
Oct 11, 2021 @ 21:01:42
I remember this as well as her death. I was in high school then. Good post!
Oct 12, 2021 @ 10:08:21
Thank you! 😀
Oct 11, 2021 @ 23:40:21
I knew that ‘Curtain’ was written ahead of time for Poirot, but didn’t realize that the same had been done for Miss Marple. Christie was such a master of sleight-of-hand that the books are always a pleasure to re-read. Or to listen to Hugh Fraser reading them.
Oct 12, 2021 @ 10:06:57
There’s a good reason she was known as the Queen of Crime, isn’t there? Just love her – and Hugh Fraser was the perfect Hastings, too!
Oct 12, 2021 @ 10:51:49
I’m always a little scared to go back to Christie – I tried it with Dorothy Sayers and it was not a success! Interesting that she wrote the final stories in advance – just as Andrea Camilleri has done with Inspector Montalbano, published in English this month I think.
Oct 12, 2021 @ 12:22:01
I’ve re-read Christie over the years so I’m usually less worried about a revisit. A good idea to write your detective’s last story thought – I wish Ed McBain had done this with his 87th Precinct books!
Oct 12, 2021 @ 11:01:09
I’ve always wanted to read this but put it off because it is the last Marple book and I thought I should read all the rest first. However, since I’ve read the last Poirot book and not all of the others, I guess I could read this now. Funny about her stealing her own writing for two books! Obviously, if it was written by her to begin with it isn’t plagiarism! Anyway, many writers do this.
Oct 12, 2021 @ 12:21:13
It’s a great read, and it’s not *set* in Marple’s end times, so I think you could read it in any order. As for the shared paragraphs, they ended up in a quite late Tommy and Tuppence book and I think the feeling is she just forgot she’d used it in Sleeping which hadn’t been released yet. Her words, though, and up to her what she does with them!
Oct 12, 2021 @ 17:14:55
Just started this today! I read this many years ago and this seemed like the most perfect read for 1976 Club!
Oct 12, 2021 @ 18:38:40
It really is – so enjoyable and pure escapism!
Oct 12, 2021 @ 17:28:04
that cover! it’s so ’70’s and so un today’s Miss Marple, what a keepsake!
Oct 12, 2021 @ 18:37:52
It’s great, and I confess to not being a fan of modern Marple adaptations – I prefer the original (or Joan Hickson!)
Oct 12, 2021 @ 18:26:54
Love Agatha Christie! Perfect escapism especially during these difficult days! I am sure I have read it in the past but have forgotten. Re reading will make me remember. Thanks for the lovely review!
Oct 12, 2021 @ 18:37:23
Thank you! Yes, she’s always a reliable comfort read and I certainly need escapism at the moment!
Oct 12, 2021 @ 22:34:31
Great post! I also enjoyed the book
Oct 13, 2021 @ 11:51:56
Thank you! 😀
Oct 13, 2021 @ 06:22:28
I love Miss Marple and am planning to reread all her books in the coming months. It’s ages since I read them and right now don’t remember much which is a good thing:)
Oct 13, 2021 @ 11:50:34
Me too – Christie never lets me down and fortunately there are so many that I never usually remember whodunnit!
Oct 13, 2021 @ 09:06:12
Oh my God, you really make me want to read this novel, it sounds very captivating… I was looking for an easy and effective detective fiction to read soon. I think I have my title 🙂
Oct 13, 2021 @ 11:49:44
I’m a huge Christie fan so I recommend any of her books! Happy reading!
Oct 13, 2021 @ 11:54:15
That’s so interesting that she wrote the “last” stories so early just in case: I didn’t know that! A good start to the Week!
Oct 13, 2021 @ 11:54:46
I always like to start with a Christie! And yes, how sensible of her to plan ahead!
Oct 13, 2021 @ 19:32:56
There should be theme music for the introduction of the Christie Option for your Club events!
Oct 13, 2021 @ 19:33:43
Yes! The theme of either Hickson Marple or Suchet Poirot would suit me fine!
the 1976 Club | Pining for the West
Oct 14, 2021 @ 23:38:43
1976 Club: Review Round-Up – Stuck in a Book
Oct 19, 2021 @ 16:30:40
Dec 31, 2021 @ 07:01:33