The Cheltenham Square Murder – John Bude
One of the most successful publishing stories of recent years is that of the British Library Crime Classics imprint. The early titles appeared in 2012, although the series really took off in 2014 when the books began appearing in striking and beautiful covers featuring vintage images. With introductions by crime writer and guru Martin Edwards, the imprint reprints lost British crime classics from the 20th century and the books seem to have been enthusiastically received, not only by crime aficionados, but also by the general public.
One of the stars of the range is John Bude; I’ve read three of his novels so far (reviews here, here and here), and it’s something of a mystery as to why this prolific and talented author fell out of favour. His stories always feature a specific location and I was really keen to read the latest reissue, “The Cheltenham Square Murder” (first published in 1937) as I lived in the Spa Town in my teens! Superintendent Meredith, Bude’s protagonist, is still based in Sussex (as he was in the last Bude I read) but is spending time with his friend, the author Aldous Barnet. The latter is staying in his sister’s house in Cheltenham, while the lady is away – No. 8 Regency Square, to be precise. As Barnet and Meredith are collaborating on a book, this seems the ideal time to visit – but this turns out to be no holiday for Meredith as shortly after his arrival one of the residents of the square is murdered in a most unusual way – by an arrow fired through an open window and straight into his head!
Regency Square is tenanted by an interesting bunch of characters, all marked out on a neat map at the front of the book (I do *love* a crime novel with a map in it!) There is Miss Boon, a single lady with a booming voice and a collection of dogs; the Wests, who have a troubled marriage; Rev. Matthews and his sister; another young couple, the Fitzgeralds, who are plagued by their neighbour, Captain Cotton, whom nobody likes. Then there is Mr. Buller, a slightly shady character, the spinster Misses Watts, Dr. Pratt (handily placed for when there are dead bodies to be inspected) and in the poshest house Sir William Whitcomb. And of course there are neighbourly conflicts, a rivalry about the felling of an elm tree in the square, problems with Miss Boon’s dogs and all the little irritations you’d expect in a closely packed residential area.
Fortunately for the residents, Meredith is on hand when the murder is discovered and even more fortunately the local inspector, Long, had heard of Meredith and is very keen on collaborating with him in solving the mystery. So the two sleuths set to investigating, and it seems as though there will be a limited field of enquiry as about half of the square’s residents are members of a local archery club. But there are alibis, and initially lack of motives. Although the detectives have their suspicions there’s no obvious, clear-cut answer. And then a second murder takes place which muddies the waters even more. Will Meredith and Long succeed in tracking down the killer, or is the Regency Square killer just too clever for them?
I’ve loved all the Bude books I’ve read so far (I really must catch up with “Death on the Riviera”, the only BL reissue of his I’ve not read); and this book is no exception. In fact, I may have liked it the most of them all, but that could be because of a certain familiarity with the location! I did enjoy the mentions of the local landmarks like the Promenade and the Pittville Pump Room and the Rotunda, and I recall being very fond of Agatha Christie’s “The ABC Murders” because the first killing took place in Andover (where I grew up). However, putting that aside, this is a deeply enjoyable read – classic crime at its best. The murder is very clever, the twists expertly placed and although I had a slight glimmer of the solution, it was only slight and I hadn’t worked out most of the mystery. Bude is an engaging writer, and Meredith a well-rounded character; the latter is a straightforward policeman, thorough in his detecting but with flashes of brilliance, and Barnet and Long make excellent foils. I was particularly fond of Long, with his slightly countrified accent and down to earth attitude, and even he was allowed a fair share of the detecting, as well as providing a certain amount of levity in places – Bude’s happy to slip in a little wry humour now and then (as in this wonderful description of a boarding house sitting room and the landlady):
“This way, sir,” said Mrs. Black, deferentially piloting the Superintendent into the room with the aspidistra and bay-window, a room which smelt of soot, camphor and hair-rugs. Meredith was waved into a rigid, springless armchair draped with a large antimacassar. Mrs. Black edged herself primly onto a black horse-hair sofa, carefully avoiding the silk-covered cushions which adorned it.
I’ve deliberately been vague about the specifics of the murders and plots, because so much of the enjoyment here comes from each development and revelation as it comes – and I would hate to spoil this for anyone who’s going to read it (and I think you all should if you love classic crime). Really, I can’t fault this book; it was exactly what it sets out to be, a wonderful Golden Age police procedural in a lovely setting and with an engrossing and enjoyable mystery. If the BL series had done nothing else but bring John Bude’s work back into print, it would deserve plaudits; as it is, Bude is one of many successes of the British Library Crime Classics series; they make perfect comfort reading in a nasty world, and I really can’t wait to read another!
JacquiWine
Aug 31, 2016 @ 07:26:02
I read a couple of Bude’s mysteries earlier this year but neglected to write them up largely due to lack of time. Both were most enjoyable, particularly the Cornish Coast one. I’ll have to look out for this as I recall Inspector Meredith from the Sussex Downs Murder. Lovely review as ever, Karen.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Aug 31, 2016 @ 07:44:09
Thanks Jacqui! These really are perfect comfort reading – thank goodness for the BL bringing them back into print!
Kazen @ Always Doing
Aug 31, 2016 @ 07:27:13
I’ve been watching these beautiful covers fly past on my feed for too long – your review has convinced me to jump in! Which of the Bude books would you recommend to start with?
kaggsysbookishramblings
Aug 31, 2016 @ 07:42:00
I always recommend starting at the beginning, so The Cornish Coast Murder would be the place!
Kazen @ Always Doing
Aug 31, 2016 @ 07:44:11
Excellent, thank you!
~runs off to the library~
Tredynas Days
Aug 31, 2016 @ 09:56:30
I confess I started the Cornish one and couldn’t finish it. Maybe I wasn’t in the right frame of mind, for I’m not averse to a good genre novel. My oldest friend lived in Cheltenham, so I know it quite well. Will have to give these another try at some point.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Aug 31, 2016 @ 11:26:14
Sometimes it’s right book, wrong time or maybe he’s just not an author for you. I like his books a lot – classic and enjoyable and just right when you need that comforting kind of read!
Liz Dexter
Aug 31, 2016 @ 10:56:10
I’m glad the series is doing well, it seems so nicely done and with really good quality. And sounds like an idea read for you, too. A map in a book is always good, whatever the genre!
kaggsysbookishramblings
Aug 31, 2016 @ 11:25:16
The production qualities *are* excellent and the books are such lovely objects in their own right. Yes, I do like a map or a plan in a book – I’m obviously someone who needs assistance with visualising things! 🙂
BookerTalk
Aug 31, 2016 @ 12:05:15
This one could restore my confidence in the british crime classics after the disaster I had with the Female Detective. it would be a good one to read if I manage to get to the Cheltenham literary festival next month
kaggsysbookishramblings
Aug 31, 2016 @ 15:22:01
Oh, please don’t judge the series by that one book! The ones I’ve read have been great – and this would definitely be ideal for the lit fest!
BookerTalk
Aug 31, 2016 @ 18:20:01
Ali sent me her copy of The Hog’s Head mystery so I think thats a sure fire winner – she was keen also that I didnt write off the whole series!
kaggsysbookishramblings
Aug 31, 2016 @ 18:33:21
Excellent! I have that one on the stacks too!
colorpencil2014
Aug 31, 2016 @ 13:56:50
Such a delicious review…the library did not have this book (shame, shame, I cry!) but I ordered the sussex downs murder immediately!
kaggsysbookishramblings
Aug 31, 2016 @ 15:21:19
Oh, I’m glad you were able to find one of Bude’s books – excellent stuff!
heavenali
Aug 31, 2016 @ 17:50:04
I came very close to buying this the other day but the shop was closing so didn’t have time to close the deal. It sounds great. I’ve read The Cornish Coast murder and the Lake District murder. I will be indulging in a lot of comfort reads during September.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Aug 31, 2016 @ 18:04:22
It’s a good one! And yes, comfort reading for us next month – that’ll be essential! 🙂
Resh Susan @ The Book Satchel
Aug 31, 2016 @ 18:12:52
Great review. I have not read any mysteries of Bude. But he seems to be a favourite .
kaggsysbookishramblings
Aug 31, 2016 @ 18:33:55
Thanks! He’s one of the biggest successes of the BL series, in my view – I really enjoyed this.
Buried In Print
Aug 31, 2016 @ 19:29:25
Thanks for being so vague about all the important-est discoveries! So much more fun to fall into them on one’s own way.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Aug 31, 2016 @ 20:57:12
I really didn’t want to give any hints because so much of the fun is in reading this book and watching the various developments with no knowledge of what’s to come.
Jonathan
Aug 31, 2016 @ 20:31:33
I probably shouldn’t mention this, for fear of retaliation, but the thought of reading a crime novel rarely appeals to me. I nearly read an Agatha Christie a few years back but soon recovered my senses. Oh, and I don’t like cats either…but please….don’t tell anyone!…
kaggsysbookishramblings
Aug 31, 2016 @ 20:56:17
:))) Well, we’re all different – it would be a boring world if we weren’t. I’ll let you off because I’m not overfond of cats myself (except Behemoth).
madamebibilophile
Sep 01, 2016 @ 07:07:07
Sounds great fun! I’ve really enjoyed the Budes I’ve read, so I’ll have to hunt this down. I do like this BL series 🙂
kaggsysbookishramblings
Sep 01, 2016 @ 10:42:55
Me too – they’re such lovely books and always a good read. I liked this Bude a lot – perhaps best of all of the ones I’ve read so far!
Kat
Sep 03, 2016 @ 01:58:18
I’ve enjoyed the few I’ve read in this series. Aldous Burnet? Is he like Aldous Huxley? Well, prob not, from what you say. It’s always nice to read a book set in an area you know. The covers are so attractive!
kaggsysbookishramblings
Sep 03, 2016 @ 07:13:19
They’re such lovely looking books, and I love a comforting classic crime novel!
Coming up on on Monday – the #1937Club!!! | Kaggsy's Bookish Ramblings
Apr 12, 2024 @ 07:01:31