Motherland by Jo McMillan
When I was growing up in my teens, suddenly out of the blue a letter arrived for me from the German Democratic Republic. I was intrigued (owing to my growing love of things Russian) and also vaguely alarmed – who was this person writing to me out of nowhere, how had they got my address and what did they want? It turned out to be (apparently!) from a girl called Astrid who wanted a penfriend; I never could quite work out where she got my address from (maybe one of those teen magazines where you put your name into a penfriend finding section had crept through the Iron Curtain) but we did exchange letters. Astrid also send parcels, of East German sweets and postcards, which always arrived quite battered, as if they’d been examined on the way…
The sweets and letters are long gone, but I still have the postcards she sent of her home town Gera, together with many of the GDR and its landmarks; and so with this memory in mind, I was obviously going to be attracted to Jo McMillan’s new novel, “Motherland”. Set in 1970s Tamworth, it tells the story of a small outpost of the GDR which exists there; teenage Jess and her mother Eleanor, committed Socialists from a long line, sellers of The Morning Star and The Only Communists in The Town!
Jess and Eleanor are firm in their beliefs, never questioning the party line, hawking their newspaper to indifferent (at best) or downright hostile locals, and trying to bring about a world revolution in a small Midlands town – so you get the ideal that things are doomed from the start…. Into their lives comes Actually Existing Socialism; Eleanor is a teacher, and the two are sent off to the real GDR to take a summer school their, the first time they’ve come into contact with the real Socialist world. Here they meet a varied number of characters, including most importantly Peter and his daughter Martina. The two one-parent families (both missing parents are dead) bond straight away – Peter and Eleanor are obviously very mutually attracted, and Jess and Martina seem to be finding a missing sibling.
However, this being the GDR, with all the Cold War complexities, things are never going to be straightforward. Despite repeated visits to the GDR, it beings to seem as if Peter and Eleanor will never manage to become the perfect Socialist couple; things deteriorate in Tamworth as the natives get hostile when world events provoke them; Jess’s school life goes downhill, and she joins a very odd Young Socialist group; and the many contacts from the GDR remain nebulous. It’s often hard to tell friend from foe, and as Jess starts to mature we start to wonder if her views will continue to coincide with her mother’s, or will her experiences of Actually Existing Socialism change them?
As you might have guessed, I really loved “Motherland”. McMillan’s writing is excellent; she captures brilliantly the voice of Jess, naive and committed at the start of the book, knowing and more questioning by the end. Although there’s perhaps a certain irony in places in her portrayal of the various members of the counter-culture groups, she never belittles their belief and their faith in their cause, even if there’s a certain Tooting Popular Front quality to some of their actions (anyone else remember “Citizen Smith” with fondness?) McMillan is also very strong on the mother-daughter relationship; this can be a slippery one, particularly when a girl reaches her teens, and she cleverly portrays the way the roles of mother and daughter often switch between the two protagonists. These are real women, dealing with domesticity, intolerant schools, moustaches and coping on their own.
I glanced over my shoulder, and my mum had turned into somebody else: a middle-aged woman in an Oxfam anorak, her zigzag parting grey, her face puffed with tiredness. A woman who, every week regardless, found energy she hadn’t got to shout big slogans at a very small town.
What’s also clever, and also rather chilling, is what’s often *not* said. Negotiating the political landscape of the GDR is not easy, with its unspoken rules, hidden alliances and codes of conduct. The shadowy world of spies and agents seems very far away from the women’s simple belief in equality and peace. Politics very often gets in the way of life, to an extent that Eleanor may be able to accept but that Jess most likely will not. Jess cannot always instantly read the adult code, but by the end of the book she is very clear-eyed about things and has subtly moved on to make her own life away from her mother. The ending is sad, somehow inevitable and perhaps a little ambiguous.
“Motherland” works on a number of levels: as a portrait of left-wing life in the last part of the 20th century; as a snapshot of life behind the Iron Curtain; as a hint that perhaps we shouldn’t force our views on our children, but should allow them to make their own way in the world; and as moving portrait of female familial relationships. The book had a particularly personal resonance with me because of my own experiences as standing out as one of the few people in *my* small town with leftward leanings (though I was never as brave and committed as Jess and Eleanor!) “Motherland” is McMillan’s debut, and it’s an excellent one – highly recommended!
(Many thanks to publishers John Murray and Bookbridgr for the review copy – much appreciated!)
Tredynas Days
Jul 10, 2015 @ 10:13:03
Sounds intriguing. I went to Romania in the early 70s with my girlfriend, who had a penfriend there – discovered later we travelled illegally in the country. Intriguing experience; like you, I was fascinated by this other world of state control and collective farms. This novel sounds interesting – thanks for the review.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 10, 2015 @ 10:25:23
Life behind the Iron Curtain fascinates me – I love to read travel books from that era where people snuck behind it! This is a great novel and really captures the feel of the era quite brilliantly.
winstonsdad
Jul 10, 2015 @ 10:34:56
My wife is from Tamworth wonder if she would enjoy this one .The contrast between east and west then was huge
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 10, 2015 @ 10:52:31
There’s quite a bit about Tamworth in it – but it’s a great read anyway! 🙂
colorpencil2014
Jul 10, 2015 @ 13:47:25
What I great review of a book I love too. But isn’t it intriguing that the Cold War has indeed become a part of our youth? My sons ask questions and love to hear about our thoughts, fears and ideas. Are quite proud I was part of Ban the Bomb demonstrations (well there was this nice boy, inviting me to come…) and there are all these incredible tv series like “the Game” and “the Assets” Is it our nostalgia or the new generations fascination that spurs all this Cold War interest? have a lovely weekend, Johanna
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 10, 2015 @ 15:32:46
I think it’s a combination of many things, and the fact that the enemy was so visible and easily defined perhaps makes us yearn for a more straightforward life….
Liz Dexter
Jul 10, 2015 @ 15:58:57
Oh this sounds BRILLIANT, straight on the wish list with it!
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 10, 2015 @ 19:25:27
🙂 It *is* good – and I’m notoriously fussy about new books!
madamebibilophile
Jul 10, 2015 @ 19:23:27
This sounds great! And as the proud owner of a Freedom for Tooting t-shirt (it’s where I went to school) I know just what to wear while I’m reading it 🙂
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 10, 2015 @ 19:25:01
🙂 Excellent! It’s a great read – hope you enjoy it!
heavenali
Jul 10, 2015 @ 23:34:54
Motherland sounds absolutely brilliant no wonder you were drawn to it.
I also had pen friends, mine Austrian and French and we write to each other for that long.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 11, 2015 @ 07:57:17
It’s a fabulous book – I really loved it! My mother (82) still has a letter from her teenage penfriend – I think he was possibly German and spoke perfect English!
Christine Harding
Jul 11, 2015 @ 08:12:24
This sounds fascinating – especially as I live in Tamworth, though I didn’t move here until the very end of the 70s. But I was brought up in Surrey, in a true-blue Tory stronghold, where my parents were among the handful of Labour supporters, so the idea of this book really resonates with me.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 11, 2015 @ 08:22:16
It’s an excellent read, and she really does conjure up the feel of the era – I think you’d like it!
Christine Harding
Jul 11, 2015 @ 09:27:14
I’ve just discovered she actually visited Tamworth earlier this week and gave a talk in the Town Hall – and I missed it! That’s what happens when you don’t read the local paper.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 11, 2015 @ 09:36:35
Oh nooooo – that would have been brilliant! :s
Kat
Jul 12, 2015 @ 04:27:48
Another remarkable find! Have never heard of this author, but life behind the Iron Curtain is fascinating.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 12, 2015 @ 08:42:14
I hadn’t heard of McMillan either until the book turned up on Bookbridgr – but I’m very impressed and I’m wondering what she’ll write next!
Luci
Aug 22, 2015 @ 16:51:53
I’m just starting reading at the moment. I’d already come across it and found a copy when my mum told me that the author was her former student, mum has a mention in the acknowledgements.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Aug 22, 2015 @ 17:24:19
Wow! That’s really exciting Luci! I do hope you enjoy it – I thought it was great! And that’s very cool about your mum 🙂
elkiedee
Jul 23, 2019 @ 18:20:42
I’ve also since discovered that she’s the ex-girlfriend of a friend who lived and worked in Coventry for a while as a young man – I found this out after he admitted to being a bit nervous of having a character based on him or something, and I’m not sure whether any of the characters were!
kaggsysbookishramblings
Jul 23, 2019 @ 20:53:40
Wow – it’s a small world, isn’t it? It must be a bit nerve-wracking if someone you were involved with is writing fiction – you never quite know how you’ll end up being portrayed… ;D
Book review – Jo McMillan – “Motherland” | Adventures in reading, running and working from home
Jun 06, 2021 @ 08:38:20