As I’ve mentioned before on the Ramblings, I do love a good essay; and one of my favourite publishers of the form is Notting Hill Editions, an indie who produce the loveliest cloth bound hardbacks. One of their titles featured during #ReadIndies month, and they have a new book available which covers a subject I don’t normally explore much – that of fashion. The book is called “Fashion: A Manifesto” and it’s by Anouchka Grose; a psychoanalyst and clothes-lover, she takes a wide ranging look at our relationship with clothing over the years, and the result is a fascinating read which digs deep into the hold fashion can exert over us.
Fashion and clothing can, of course, be complex topics to deal with nowadays. As well as the fact that many trends, and the influence they have on young women in particular, can be deemed as dangerous if not toxic, there is also the environmental effect of fast fashion and the constant pressure to consume new clothing product. As Grose makes clear from the start, she’s very aware of these factors; and she takes a balanced look at how we use clothing and fashion to define ourselves.
Presumably it’s good to know at first glance who’s rich and who’s poor because then you will quickly know who to marry and who to exploit.
“Fashion…” is divided into chapters exploring particular aspects of the subject; from the definition and history of what fashion actually is, through the concept of fashion as art, the use of clothing to hide perceived bodily imperfections, the harm that clothing can cause to us, and even significant fashion trends like punk, Grose’s narrative is a fascinating one. She’s very aware of how clothing has been used in the past to pinpoint the wearer’s social position, and I was particularly interested in the history of how specific items were worn by the upper or ruling classes to mark them out as better than the rest. To a certain extent, that element of fashion has perhaps been diminished, although there is still the divide between those who can afford the expensive couture outfit and those who have to buy the knock-off version.
Of course, production methods have radically changed over the years, for good or for bad, which has democratised the wearing of certain items of clothing; however, this has caused the drastic environmental effects, and Grose doesn’t shy away from covering the horrors caused by mass production. She comes right up to date, discussing the idea of digital garments, but of course this doesn’t solve the problem of what we wear every day, and also uses up resources albeit in a different way.
I found her discussion of catwalk shows very pithy, too, as they’ve gradually moved over the years from presenting a particular style that consumers could aspire to over the following season to showcasing the most ridiculous and pointless displays of so-called outfits that few could (or would want to!) wear. That element of the fashion industry seems to me particularly profligate and I must confess to find myself torn between laughing and despairing at some of the concoctions the designers come up with. Mind you, the harsh and competitive environment in which the designers work sounds unbearable…
Perhaps, before long, we will get to a point where we no longer need a giant, greedy industry to force fashion on us via billboards, swanky store fronts, pop-up ads and so on. We will just produce it ourselves. Charity shops, resale websites and even our own wardrobes, contain more than enough vestimentary beauty and variation to last us well into the future.
I enjoyed very much Grose’s even-handed exploration of fashion’s past, present and future; she doen’t draw definitive and binding conclusions but instead creates fascinating discussion points to explore ongoing options for sustainable fashion. Certainly many of us are very aware of the dangers nowadays, and movements to recycle or upcycle have gained much traction. Personally, I’m past an age where fashion matters much to me, though I do like to reuse items from charity shops, and some of my Offspring make regular use of sites like Vinted. But then, I think I always had that mindset; I’m from the era that loved to style their own look from jumble sale or charity shop finds in the post-punk years, and mixing a skirt from the 1950s with a modern lace top and a thrifted jacket meant you could have a look all of your own! 😀
So “Fashion…” was a thoughtful, often thought-provoking read which certainly made me reconsider what I knew about the history of clothes, and also what we should be doing, going forward. We absolutely need to pay the proper price for what we buy, stop getting cheap garments produced in sweatshops and try hard to slow down our consumption, opting for preloved items or those manufactured by ethical and sustainable methods. Of course, that’s easier said than done – but this fascinating book certainly should point readers in the right direction to at least think about what they buy and try to make changes!
(Review copy kindly provided by the publishers, for which many thanks!)
Apr 21, 2023 @ 09:11:52
Interesting piece, Karen. It sent me back to a post of mine some years ago about novelist and academic John Harvey’s books on clothes and related issues (especially the colour black). Here’s a link in case you are inclined to look: https://tredynasdays.co.uk/2015/05/our-appearance-is-our-reality-john-harvey-clothes/
Apr 21, 2023 @ 14:45:45
Thanks Simon, I’ll check it out. It’s an interesting subject and nowadays has so many more issues around sustainability, body dysmorphia and the like – all very fascinating!
Apr 21, 2023 @ 09:53:59
Fashion and its signaling is such an interesting topic to me—I’ve never considered myself particularly stylish, but I generally know what I like and what looks better or worse on me. Charity shops rarely work well for me (there’s usually not much in my size and what there is tends to be hideous; my boyfriend is more patient and has the skill of unearthing gems!) so I’ve taken to Vinted, which has been brilliant. Re. fashion writing, Genevieve Valentine’s Red Carpet Rundown pieces (much missed) used to be an amazing resource for parsing precisely what messages celebrity stylists were trying to send: https://www.genevievevalentine.com/category/red-carpet-rundown/
Apr 21, 2023 @ 14:37:37
It’s certainly an interesting look at the topic and a lot more in depth than I perhaps expected. I got on better with charity shops pre-children tbh, although I still do find the occasional gem which fits me! However, Vinted is definitely on my list of things to explore…
And thank you for the link – this sounds interesting and I’ll give it a look. If somebody can make sense of modern catwalks that will be quite an achievement! ;D
Apr 21, 2023 @ 12:10:02
Fashion and our psychology just go together so much! What an interesting way to look at who we are and why we dress as we do. I especially liked your comments about the catwalk. I can remember when, as you say, the catwalk featured clothes people might actually want to wear. Now? I couldn’t imagine ‘real’ people in anything you see on the catwalk. At any rate, this sounds fascinating!
Apr 21, 2023 @ 14:34:51
It was certainly an intriguing read, Margot, and I liked the various angles she took to explore fashion. As you say, the catwalks today bear very little relation to reality, to the point where I wonder why they do them!
Apr 21, 2023 @ 17:12:08
This sounds quite fascinating. I am not a particular follower of fashion but the industry is so influential in terms of cultural consciousness and impact on the environment that it’s hard to ignore. I have switched to sourcing all my ‘new’ clothes from thrift or resale sites like Vinted and it’s been a good experience. More fun and interesting and feels better for the environment too.
Apr 21, 2023 @ 20:31:26
It’s an interesting look at the whole subject, and we’ve certainly moved on a lot in our attitudes to sourcing clothing. I haven’t yet checked out Vinted (though I have used eBay) – I like to recycle and also look out things I wouldn’t necessarily find locally!
Apr 22, 2023 @ 01:25:04
An interesting topic touching on so many things, it’s a good thing that people are now more aware of the damage cheap and fast clothing causes. I admire those who develop their own style and don’t give a toss for what’s expected!
Apr 22, 2023 @ 14:52:45
Definitely – we certainly need to be moving to more sustainable models when it comes to sourcing clothing. I always tried to make my own style when I was younger, but nowadays that kind of thing is definitely less important…. ;D
Apr 22, 2023 @ 16:17:36
This sounds very interesting, and another lovely physical object of course! I have a book on my wishlist about Modest clothing which is becoming big business and I think could do well among non-religious people even though originally developed for fashion-conscious Muslim women.
Apr 22, 2023 @ 20:19:13
It really is interesting, Liz, though it doesn’t actually go deeply into feminist issues around fashion. And I’d not come across Modest clothing before, but having had a quick Google, that sounds very interesting,
Apr 22, 2023 @ 16:55:26
Can’t disagree with the ethical arguments here, and I share your distaste for the profligate aspects attached to the more outré designs some fashion houses parade without a hint of any awareness of how ridiculous they are.
Apr 22, 2023 @ 20:17:39
Absolutely – I have no idea what catwalk shows are trying to project nowadays, but they mostly just make me laugh…
Apr 25, 2023 @ 10:33:11
That’s a very attractive little book – which is appropriate given the subject. I have never been particularly interested in fashion (I think that would be obvious 😉) it’s a fascinating world, though, and I am often concerned by mass production and its impact on our planet.
Apr 25, 2023 @ 13:36:05
It’s very pretty and a fascinating read – even as someone who doesn’t follow fashion nowadays, I do have to purchase clothes, so it was interesting to read about sustainability and options to help the planet.
May 10, 2023 @ 07:01:32