There really *is* no accounting for reading moods, is there?? On the morning of World Book Day, I was trying to choose my next read and vascillating wildly, faced with any number of books. After rejecting most of the obvious choices in front of me, as well as all of the ones I had leftover from #ReadIndies and all of the possibles I’d featured on the Ramblings, I spotted a small hardback I’d picked up in 2020 and ignored ever since. It was “The Lost Writings” by Franz Kafka (translated by Michael Hofmann), and it turned out to be the perfect choice!
Kafka is, of course, notorious for never actually having finished a book; and he instructed his friend and executor Max Brod to destroy all his works. Fortunately for us, Brod didn’t; however, he *did* tidy up Kafka’s writings for publication, and it’s only in recent years that scholars have begun to put together more definitive versions – but that’s a different story. Anyway, Kafka left behind him a huge amount of short pieces and fragments, which were collected into two volumes of the completed works in German. Some of these have been previously translated, but this volume brings together a selection of works including some which have not made it into English before; and it really does make fascinating reading.
The pieces range in length from a paragraph to several pages, and rarely have a title. Each is notably ‘Kafkaesque’ in theme, featuring characters in odd situations, dealing with strange surroundings or negotiating dream-like terrain. That feeling of claustrophobia, of often being faced with places or people or circumstances beyond our control is present in these short works, and although you have no idea who is narrating them, they’re quite hypnotic to read.
A delicate matter, this tiptoeing across a crumbling board set down as a bridge, nothing underfoot, having to scrape together with your feet the ground you are treading on, walking on nothing but your reflection down in the water below, holding the world together with your feet, your hands cramping at the air to survive this ordeal.
Inevitably, many of the works don’t have a conclusion, ending in a series of ellipses, and that can be tantalising to the reader (“A coffin had been made ready”, a 2 page tale, particularly springs to mind); however, I personally don’t have an issue with fragments or unfinished works (both Edwin Drood and Sanditon are big favourites). There were so many resonances I sensed, in particular (and perhaps unexpectedly) with Italo Calvino – the fragment with the first line of “The city resembles the sun, all its light is concentrated into one dazzling central circle…” particularly struck me as Calvino-esque! Definitely, if you give yourself up to these pieces and allow yourself to be sucked into Kafka’s worlds, the rewards are great; these strange little tales with their surreal settings and characters stay with you and I loved the book!
The collection has been compiled by Reiner Stach, who’s apparently responsible for a highly regarded biography of Kafka (I may have to seek that out…); he provides a fascinating afterword concerning the history of Kafka’s writing; and the translations by Michael Hofmann sound to my ear like other Kafka works I’ve read. “The Lost Writings” are vivid, quirky, individual and strange, the kind of short works which haunt you; highly recommended by me, and another title I would have squeezed into #ReadIndies if I’d had more time. As it is, I’m very glad I got the urge to read this now; and I may now have to search out the recent definitive versions of his well-known works… ;D
Mar 14, 2023 @ 07:43:32
That’s a wonderful share. I am going to get this book.
Mar 14, 2023 @ 10:42:36
It’s a fascinating read – hope you enjoy it!
Mar 14, 2023 @ 11:07:36
What an interesting read this must have been! Kafka had such a skill at drawing the reader in with only a few sentences, so I’m not surprised that you found yourself drawn in even by those short bits. And it sounds as though this collection offers an interesting perspective on his writing, too.
Mar 14, 2023 @ 11:38:05
It really was, Margot – an aspect of Kafka I wasn’t aware of, and these fragments worked so well, despite the extreme shortness of some of them. A fascinating book all round!
Mar 14, 2023 @ 11:49:10
It just so happens that I’m using an audio book of The Castle to drift off to sleep and it works surprisingly well because *chuckle* I know it doesn’t have an ending that I need to stay awake for.
Mar 14, 2023 @ 15:17:52
LOL, good point! 🤣🤣
Mar 14, 2023 @ 12:46:53
This sounds great but I can’t read Kafka anymore, reminds me too much of my old job!
Mar 14, 2023 @ 15:17:30
Oh no!!!
Mar 14, 2023 @ 13:57:05
Always listen to the books, they know when they should be read! 😀 I think I might find this book fascinating and frustrating in about equal measure, wondering what Kafka might have done with the fragments as wonderful as they are. What especially catches my interest though, are the new definitive versions of his work. Thank you for the tip-off!
Mar 14, 2023 @ 15:17:20
Yeah, you’re right – I do think books have their time! And I mostly was happy to just dip into the fragments and take them as what they are! As for the definitive versions, it was only the release of the full version of the diaries which really made me pay attention to those – I really do want to explore further!!
Mar 15, 2023 @ 10:23:53
How funny that you picked it up on a whim! A great cover and sounds like a good read, although I’m not sure I would cope with so much unfinished stuff!
Mar 15, 2023 @ 11:06:03
It was a happy whim because it was just the right book at the right time! And as I knew in advance it was going to be fragmented it was fine!
Mar 15, 2023 @ 11:19:52
It looks beautiful, what a lovely cover. Chiming in to agree with previous comments on how glad to hear this book had the perfect time and place for you.
Mar 15, 2023 @ 15:01:34
I’m a great believer in books finding their right time with you, and this one certainly did with me!!
Mar 15, 2023 @ 16:04:07
This sounds very *you*, Karen, a fascinating collection of pieces. I’m a bit like Bii in that I probably couldn’t go back to Kafka now as he’s associated with an earlier period of life that I’d rather not revisit. Absolutely essential for Kafka completists, though!
Mar 15, 2023 @ 16:15:14
Yes, definitely a me book! And although I read Kafka in my 20s, I don’t have any difficult associations so am happy to revisit. A really fascinating book!
Mar 15, 2023 @ 19:20:01
This does sound really wonderful. One of my favourite novels is Wives and Daughters, so I also don’t have a problem with a lack of ending 😀
Mar 16, 2023 @ 11:01:06
LOL, the work that exists in these cases can still be wonderful, and certainly Kafka’s fragments are marvellous in their own right!
Mar 15, 2023 @ 19:42:17
Fantastic stuff. 🙂 I too don’t mind unfinished works (Charlotte Brontë’s three or four novel fragments are fascinating) but then start wanting desperately to complete them with plausible endings!
Mar 16, 2023 @ 11:00:17
Well, there’s nothing to stop you doing so, though you’d have quite a big job on your hands with Kafka!!! 🤣🤣
Mar 16, 2023 @ 12:07:42
This does sound interesting . Kafka is someone I haven’t yet read but I will get to him at some point.
Mar 16, 2023 @ 15:40:34
He’s a fascinating author – my bulk of my reading of him was in my teens and twenties, but I’d like to revisit his novels!
Mar 17, 2023 @ 17:27:01
I read some Kafka many moons ago. I probably didn’t fully appreciate him, though. This does sound like it was a fascinating read. Lost works are always enticing.
Mar 17, 2023 @ 20:10:14
I did too, back in my 20s, and I’m sure I didnt get a fraction out of him that I would now! This was a real treat, though, and has made me keen to revisit him!
Mar 17, 2023 @ 19:24:21
I’ve eyed this up a few times – you definitely make it sound worth reading. (In the meantime, I’ve been re-reading Kafka’s novels -always worth it).
Mar 17, 2023 @ 20:07:08
I enjoyed it very much Grant, and am very keen to revisit the novels!
Mar 22, 2023 @ 01:36:57
Oh cool, I was not aware of this book
Mar 22, 2023 @ 10:38:26
It’s great fun!