My first book post for December may well be setting a trend for the month; it’s another lovely British Library Crime Classic, and as I hinted in my end of November post, I suspect there might be a number of them making an appearance on the blog before the new year! My love of Golden Age crime should be well known, and so I’m always pleased when a BLCC pops through the door; and they make the perfect palate cleaner when I’m not sure what to read next. Today’s book is another one of their marvellous anthologies and it really is a treat! Entitled “Final Acts”, it collects together a wonderful selection of short stories centred around theatres and it’s definitely one of the most entertaining of their collections I’ve read!
Edited by Martin Edwards, the book gathers together fourteen stories which are a particularly strong and distinctive selection of mysteries, from more obscure names like Barry Perowne and Roy Vickers, to the queens of the era like Dorothy L. Sayers and Ngaio Marsh. Some names have been rescued from neglect by the BLCC releases (Anthony Wynne, Christianna Brand), whilst others definitely deserve to be revisited (Marguerite Steen, Brandon Fleming). Somehow, Golden Age crime and theatres seem to work so well together – creepiness, the slight sinister nature of backstage, seedy characters hanging around, disguises and complex alibis and all manner of devious murders and motives; all of these elements fit brilliantly into the mystery genre and there’s plenty of this on show in “Final Acts”.
I’ve read a number of BLCC anthologies and I have to say that I think this is one of the best, if not *the* best. I usually struggle with not wanting to pick out favourites, although this is collection where I feel you could actually write about every story individually. However I *will* focus on some standouts…
“The Affair at the Semiramis Hotel” by A.E.W. Mason reintroduced me to an author who I hadn’t read since my twenties; Mason was very highly regarded in his time, I believe, and I loved his “The House of the Arrow” back in the day. His regular detective was Hanaud, and on the basis of this story I’m really not sure why he’s fallen out of favour nowadays. Anyway, “Semiramis” is a wonderful story, nudging close to novella length, in which Hanaud investigates a strange affair involving jewel theft, drugs, romance, murder and singing. It’s a heady mix which creates an excellent and atmospheric story, and I must confess I’m feeling drawn to seek out some of those Hanaud novels for a revisit.
Another highlight was “In View of the Audience” by Marguerite Steen, which was quite unforgettable. George Brewster catches a train by the skin of his teeth; but it turns out to be the wrong one… As he curses, and waits for the next stop where he can get a connection, he enters into conversation with his fellow passenger, Henry Morpeth, a strange little man who it turns out has just bought a derelict theatre in the sticks. As Brewster becomes drawn into Morpeth’s story, events take a sinister turn, building to a really dark climax. More I will not say, but it’s a brilliant and suspenseful story, cleverly done and very memorable…
Sayers is, of course, a magnificent writer and she’s one of my all-time favourites – I could read the Wimsey books over and over (in fact, I have…) “Blood Sacrifice” doesn’t feature her main detective, but is a standalone story, and another very dark one. As is aways the case with Sayers, there is a depth to the story as she explores the emotions of John Scales, an author whose play has been a huge success but at the cost of his morals, as it has been toned down and smoothed out to make it acceptable to the masses. Scales is tormented by this, knowing his reputation has been made as a playwright, but not on the work he would like to do; and the blame is put down to actor-manager Garrick Drury who caught Scales in a contract which allowed the changes to be made. However, Scales will find his morals tested when met with an event where he could influence events one way or the other – which choice will he make, and does he *really* have the power to influence things that strongly? A wonderfully clever and thought-provoking story by Sayers as always.

Arriving at the Theatre in the 1950s (Terrace, CC BY-SA 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0>, via Wikimedia Commons)
“After the Event” by Christianna Brand is another clever one. Backstage rivalries are a wonderful motive, and feature in a number of the stories; and here this element features strongly, with a particular acting family being in effect held to ransome by a married-in member. The alibis hinge on a number of things including timings and make-up, and also the loyalty of the various members of the troupe; and the solution is a very interesting one. Also a delight in this story is her series detective, Inspector Cockrill who sees through everything to get to the truth!
Then there’s “I Can Find My Way Out” by Ngaio Marsh, which was another treat. Featuring her regular detective, Roderick Alleyn, this features a very devious murder, and things are complicated by a young friend of the Alleyns turning up backstage and impersonating not only the great detective, but also someone who might cause concern to the company. Luckily Alleyn is on hand to get to the truth of what is a very clever murder, and this was a really satisfying story.
Well, those are a few of the highlights, but I have to say that I found this collection wonderfully varied and not a dud amongst the stories. As I mentioned, the stage setting (of whatever kind – and there is plenty of variety) works so well for GA crime and the range here was excellent. “Final Acts” was a thoroughly enjoyable read from the opening overture to the final curtain; there was an entertainingly diverse selection of plot and characterisation, some cracking mysteries and a marvellous sense of atmosphere. The theatre settings were wonderfully conjured and realistic, and this is the perfect book to lose yourself in if you want some GA Crime escapism during the darker evenings. Loved it!
Dec 02, 2022 @ 07:51:23
Love that black and white shot. So evocative!
Dec 02, 2022 @ 10:47:44
I thought so too. I do often wish I could time-travel!!
Dec 02, 2022 @ 09:35:36
Quite a feat to create an anthology where all the stories are good quality. I did read a BLCC anthology recently where I felt some were included just to make the book a reasonable length!
A theatrical setting does lend itself well to some wonderful atmospherics and of course you always get those larger than life characters
Dec 02, 2022 @ 10:46:36
It’s a really consistent collection and I enjoyed every one. Sometimes there are ones that don’t hit the spot, but all of these did. And yes, the settings (in all their variety) are just wonderful – loved it!
Dec 02, 2022 @ 11:08:58
I’ve enjoyed these collections in the past and this one sounds brilliant. I love mysteries set in theatres.
Dec 02, 2022 @ 11:40:29
It’s a particularly good collection and the settings are just wonderful – perfect for mysteries!!
Dec 02, 2022 @ 11:11:09
The theatre is the perfect setting for a mystery and this sounds like a great collection. I’m familiar with some of those authors but not with others – I’m pleased to hear all of the stories are of consistently high quality!
Dec 02, 2022 @ 11:40:01
It’s an ideal location for mysteries and there are some wonderful stories here – I highly recommend this one!
Dec 02, 2022 @ 11:33:11
It’s great to hear that you think this is up there with the best of the BLCC anthologies as they can be a little uneven in quality from time to time. Dorothy L. Sayers, Ngaio Mash and Christianna Brand – that’s quite a tempting line-up, plus the theatrical theme definitely appeals. It sounds if the stories capture the drama and atmosphere of theatre very well, so I look forward to dipping in – luckily there’s a copy on my pile just waiting to be read!
Dec 02, 2022 @ 11:38:14
It’s a really successful one in my view, Jacqui – the stories are varied, despite their common theme, and I enjoyed every one. The known names are great, but there are some real successes from the lesser known authors too. Look forward to your thoughts on it!
Dec 02, 2022 @ 11:56:47
Sounds intriguing. Collections can be patchy, and it’s not often one likes all the stories
Dec 02, 2022 @ 15:29:41
They can, but I didn’t find a dud in this one!
Dec 02, 2022 @ 11:59:38
I love that title for a group of theatrical stories! And the theatre is such a great context for a crime story, isn’t it? The BL has done some fine collections, and non better, in my opinion, than when Martin Edwards is curating. Little wonder you liked this one so well.
Dec 02, 2022 @ 15:29:25
It’s a wonderful title and a really strong collection. The settings are perfect and I enjoyed the lot, which is a real achievement!
Dec 02, 2022 @ 13:51:38
You hint at some really tasty morsels here, Karen, the Steen, the Brand… Very tempted indeed.
Dec 02, 2022 @ 15:28:51
It’s a particularly strong collection!!
Dec 02, 2022 @ 17:06:58
From your descriptions of the stories, it seems like a very strong collection. Has gone immediately on my wishlist.
Dec 02, 2022 @ 20:11:49
It *is* a good one – hope you enjoy it! 😀
Dec 02, 2022 @ 20:18:25
I have this one to read. I may dig it out to dip into. I do love a good short story collection.
Dec 02, 2022 @ 20:23:01
Oh do! I thought it was a particularly good selection, and really varied!
Dec 03, 2022 @ 00:24:05
I’m definitely on board with this trend! You’re right, the combination of theatre and mystery are wonderful together, even in some more recently written books it’s fun. This does sound like a terrific collection and I will put it on the ‘waiting for BL books to make it across the pond’ list!
Dec 03, 2022 @ 19:46:10
It’s a great theme for a collection, and this is certainly one of the strongest I’ve read from the BL. Definitely worth looking out for! 😀
Dec 03, 2022 @ 10:37:40
I have such a pile of unread BLCC books, more than I will ever read to be honest. However does look and sound great, so it’s one I really hope I can get to. The theatre is such a fantastic setting for a mystery. I read a theatre mystery by Ngaio Marsh several years ago and remember it as being one of my favourites.
Dec 03, 2022 @ 19:45:28
I’m not quite keeping up with them either, but it’s lovely to have them to hand when I want a relaxing read. This one was a particularly enjoyable collection, I felt – and the settings were marvellous!!
Dec 04, 2022 @ 13:08:10
Ooh, I love theatrical mysteries! There is something about a world in which people are never quite what they are appearing to be that makes such stories particularly satisfying. Short stories are not always my cup of tea but this sounds like a solid selection.
Dec 04, 2022 @ 17:23:47
It *is* a particularly strong collection I think, and quite a few of the stories are longer ones which is nice. Plus the settings are just marvellous – loved it!!
Dec 06, 2022 @ 18:34:10
I’m also planning for GA escapism this month! This sounds so tempting – GA mysteries and the theatre, an irresistible combination!
Dec 06, 2022 @ 19:55:21
It’s a really wonderful collection, and has so put me in the mood for more GA crime – which is what I’m in the middle of reading right now! 😀
Dec 08, 2022 @ 06:51:11
This sounds like a great volume, and a brilliant cover, too.
Dec 08, 2022 @ 11:26:28
It’s a really strong and enjoyable selection, Liz – and yes, so pretty!!