October’s book in the “Dark is Rising” sequence sees the series reaching its midpoint, with a slim but powerful read which focuses on the feminine. Susan Cooper had, by this time, an established plan for the five books of the series, and book three was “Greenwitch”. Set once again in Trewissick, the story brings the Drews back to Cornwall for a short visit, after the Grail they found has been stolen from the British Museum. However, this time Great Uncle Merry has contrived to bring along Will Stanton, his fellow Old One who was the focus of the second book “The Dark is Rising”. Can this group work together to fight another attack from the Dark?
“Greenwitch” looks to be the shortest of the books, but it doesn’t lack in impact. The focus is squarely on Jane Drew, as this is the time of year of the building of the Greenwitch; an ancient custom carried out by the women of Trewissick to bring good luck for the fishing and harvesting. Jane, as the closest female to Merry, is allowed to attend the ceremony where the Greenwitch is constructed from leaves and branches, then cast into the sea. She’s allowed a wish, and it’s one which may have unexpected consequences…
Fighting against the forces of good this time is a man of the Dark who appears as an artist, producing brilliant, violent and threatening paintings. He’s a malevolent presence throughout the book, threatening the Greenwitch, the children and the Light. Yet it is Jane and her link with the Greenwitch itself who will prove crucial to the battle.
So this the book where Cooper weaves together the strands established in the first two works, bringing together the Drews and Will Stanton (which was, of course, necessary for the progression of the sequence); and once the initial (and inevitable) resentment of the Drews is overcome, the two sides work together to fight the Dark. Interestingly, we now see, too, the differences between those involved; there is a line drawn between the Drews and the Old Ones, with the former only knowing as much as they need to help in the battle. You suspect that this is as much for their own protection as anything else…
As well as the characters we know, Captain Toms (owner of the Grey House from the first book) makes his entrance, with Rufus the dog reappearing. I thought I remembered little of the book, but as I read much came back to me – the construction of the Greenwitch, the artist from the Dark with his wild paintings and of course the landscape around Trewissick. And once again, this is a book with many, many layers.
Interestingly, I felt that art was actually at the heart of the story; whether the skill of the women in creating their totem, or that of those involved in the more traditional arts, there was a strong contrast between the art of Light and Dark; with, perhaps, the folk art of the women standing apart from that of the male characters. Barney is developing strong skills as an artist; he can appreciate the expertise of the Dark’s artist while hating what it produces and stands for. However, while those two male artists are opposed, the women just get on with what they’ve always done.
Once again, this is a marvellous piece of storytelling, brilliantly capturing a looming sense of danger; Cooper’s skill at superimposing the supernatural world over the everyday one, and allowing them to co-exist, blurring the lines between the real and the magic, is unsurpassed. There are sequences which occur out of normal time which are stunningly written and hypnotic. The sense of traditions, the oldness of the land and things outside the realms of Light and Dark, is quite fascinating, and again Cooper creates a world in which old legends are still alive, paganism is a vital force and both still have relevance today.
Under the sunset sky the sea was glass-smooth. Long slow rollers from the Atlantic, rippling like muscles beneath the skin, made the only sign of the great invisible strength of the ocean in all the tranquil evening. Quietly the fishing-boats moved out, a broad fishtail wake spreading behind each one; the engines chugged softly through the still air. Jane stood at the end of Kemare Head, on the crest of a granite outfall that tumbled its rocks two hundred feet to the sea, and she watched them go. Toy boats, they seemed from there: the scatter of a fishing fleet that every week, every month, every year for endless years had been going out after the pilchard or the mackerel before dusk, and staying at the chase until dawn. Every year there were fewer of them, but still every year they went.
Running through the book, too, is the importance of empathy and compassion – traditionally considered feminine values but I think essential in all human beings. It is Jane’s compassion which brings about the result of the quest and without that I don’t think the Light would have done so well…
I don’t know quite what I was expecting when I started “Greenwitch” but it was actually a much more powerful read than I anticipated; perhaps, after “The Dark is Rising”, I thought that all the other books might be less impactful. But this is an immersive, engrossing read, beautifully written and with so many interesting threads; another triumph from Susan Cooper, and I frankly can’t wait to see where things go next!!
Oct 19, 2022 @ 07:20:55
This sounds such a powerful and complex read – she definitely didnโt talk down to younger readers! The cover too is very striking, even if itโs a bit random as to who is depicted!
Oct 19, 2022 @ 11:34:34
No, her books have surprising depth, really, and the quality of her writing is so good. But I do find the cover a little puzzling… ;D
Oct 19, 2022 @ 11:58:22
I love reading your reviews of this series. I will definitely get round to reading it very soon.
Oct 19, 2022 @ 15:43:18
Thank you! I do hope you enjoy them!
Oct 19, 2022 @ 12:10:21
That blend of fantasy and history sounds appealing! and it sounds as though there’s much more to this one than it might appear on the surface. Little wonder you liked it so well!
Oct 19, 2022 @ 15:43:06
Indeed I do Margot – such depth in a series aimed at younger readers is wonderful to find!
Oct 19, 2022 @ 12:18:37
Nice point about art being at the center of this story. There is the distortion of art used for evil, the creation of things of beauty and power but with ultimately selfish ends — and the element of compassion that has to come in order to redeem all human activity. Art and craft is actually quite a strong theme in the series, with the ancient craftsmanship of the Grail, Will’s father being a goldsmith, the beauty of the six Signs, as well as the tapestries in the hall, and now Barney’s gift coming out along with its shadow side in the painter from the Dark, and of course the Greenwitch that brings to mind Celtic knotwork, art that ties into the mystical forces of nature. How will this theme carry on? I am looking forward to our next installments.
Oct 19, 2022 @ 15:42:35
Yes absolutely – when you think about it there’s so much good creativity going on there, but she’s balanced enough to show how that can be perverted by evil. Fortunately for me I can’t remember the next two books at all, so it will all be a wonderful surprise!
Oct 19, 2022 @ 14:37:43
I really must start reading this series, excitement mixed with empathy and compassion sounds a winning combination
Oct 19, 2022 @ 15:41:27
It is, and the books are such engrossing reads too!
Oct 20, 2022 @ 10:19:02
Ooh this sounds great, such a shame I missed this series when I was a child. The themes are wonderfully complex and intricate.
Oct 20, 2022 @ 16:01:37
It’s a wonderful series, and I think you could definitely come to it first time as an adult too!
Oct 20, 2022 @ 17:04:05
Definitely the highlight of the series so far for me.
Oct 21, 2022 @ 11:18:19
It’s so good, isn’t it??
Oct 21, 2022 @ 13:50:24
A lovely review, Karen, exactly recapturing many of the feelings I took from my reread. You say”I felt that art was actually at the heart of the story” and I agree, a point I want to expand on in a post following my review. You also mention the focus on what quaintly used to be called the distaff side, but it’s a metaphor that is apt here: the women create white magic for the community through art while the male artist merely uses art to gain dominance power through a different magic.
I was so impressed by my first read and now am even more so, not just from a revisit but from other bloggers’ reviews too โ yours and Lory’s for example. Thank you.
Oct 21, 2022 @ 15:41:37
Thanks Chris! I don’t think I thought about the book in such depth last time but it has so many layers. And yes – the distaff side (as my OH has been known to say) – women do just get on with things, don’t they? ;D
Oct 23, 2022 @ 18:44:10
I absolutely love this one: the emphasis on Jane and the Greenwitch is very empowering for a girl to read, and I like the emphasis on compassion and working together, too.
Oct 23, 2022 @ 19:31:42
Definitely agree – loved the focus on the female, and also how the female magic stands apart. A great entry in the sequence.
Oct 24, 2022 @ 10:06:33
Nov 28, 2022 @ 07:01:17