If you pop into the Ramblings on any kind of a regular basis, you’ll be well aware of my love of crime writing. Nowadays, it tends to be mainly geared towards Golden Age mysteries, but in the past I’ve read many more contemporary works as well as a good number of spy-type works. Today’s book, a recent release from V&Q Books, falls firmly into the latter category; it’s an entertaining yarn set in modern day Ukraine with a surreal twist! The title is “Odesa at Dawn” written by Sally McGrane, an American-born author based in Germany but who’s lived in Odesa – and it’s clear she knows and loves the city!
Set in a time before the current conflict, the story follows an ex-CIA man, Max Rushmore, who’s sent to Odesa on a routine assignment. Max is a somewhat hapless character, and things soon start to go awry for him; the severed hand of the local governor is found in a vat of sunflower oil; Max comes upon a detached toe with the same markings as the hand; and needless to say, he sets off to investigate.
The city of Odesa is in a volatile state, with conflict between the governor and the mayor; the local mafia and the criminal underbelly of the place are all out to get what they can via the many corrupt officials; and there are of course tensions with neighbouring Russia which threaten to bubble up to the surface (and, of course, we all know how that’s going…) Will Max get to the bottom of things without being damaged (at the very least…)? Will his wife accept that he won’t be back in the USA in time for an important meeting she has lined up to start on a very different, and much more respectable career, or will she throw her hat into the ring? What is going on beneath the city? And what on earth are all the cats of Odesa up to??? Well, you’ll have to read the book yourself to find out!
As you might have gathered, there’s a lot going on in “Odesa…” and it makes for gripping and entertaining reading. The plot is a complex one which weaves in the history of its setting, blending the past and future of the city beautifully. McGane uses her extensive knowledge of Odesa to draw in the influences of previous residents like Babel and Gogol, and the former’s fictional gangster, Benya Krik. The place seems to exert a magnetic influence on those who’ve lived there or were born there, and all manner of characters are involved in the action, from the local poet Fishman who blogs about life in the city, to Sima the beautiful pastry-chef, who is adored from afar by Mr. Smiley…
Ah yes – the cats! As well as the real life-criminal element, there is an underground mafia which exists in the world of cats, and Mr. Smiley is one of the bigshots! He and his feline team observe the action, unsuspected by humans, and shed an interesting light on the nefarious activities of the humans. They have an important role in the resolution of the plot, and I would have rather liked to see more of them!
Although the bumbling investigator Max is ostensibly the main character, the star of the book is, of course, Odesa itself. McGane paints a wonderful portrait of the city, one which, as Lizzy has noted in her review, is not always flattering. I personally find the book even more appealing because of that nuanced portrayal; although often humorous and entertaining, there are points where the narrative goes to darker places, exploring the horrors of the past; the Jewish characters in particular have suffered much. The are reflections on a kind of mortality that applies to cities as well as people, as it’s noted that Odesa is sinking into the sand in many places. No doubt the labyrinth of catacombs which exists under the city, and which provides thrilling and surreal escapades in the book, have something to do with this…
“Odesa at Dawn” was a wonderful read, from the opening pages where we first meet Mr. Smiley to the dramatic ending on stormy high seas. McGane’s love for Odesa shines through from start to finish, and as well as providing an entertaining and often dramatic read, she’s also painted a marvellous picture of the city. Babel’s translator, Boris Dralyuk, has advised readers to “come for the story, but don’t forget to take in the sights,” and he’s not wrong – highly recommended!
Sep 23, 2022 @ 08:36:22
That cat on the cover is quite disconcerting!
Sep 23, 2022 @ 11:28:08
It is – but the cats are an important part of the book so not to be ignored!!
Sep 23, 2022 @ 11:29:10
As in life…
Sep 23, 2022 @ 11:46:58
Yes! 🤣😸
Sep 23, 2022 @ 12:16:31
I love the quote you use as the title of your post! And the book does sound like a really interesting look at Odessa (which I confess I don’t know – never been there). It also sounds like an effective blend of espionage and murder investigation. That’s not easy to pull off, so I’m glad you thought this one worked.
Sep 23, 2022 @ 13:48:28
It seemed an apt quote at the moment, Margot. As for the book, it does pull together its various strands well, especially as it has to build in a touch of the fantastic with the cards. A really enjoyable read!
Sep 23, 2022 @ 13:21:21
This does sound wonderful! Odesa is such a fascinating city to read about and the perfect place for an unusual story. And the cats – might there be Master and Margarita and George Smiley references in there??
Sep 23, 2022 @ 13:46:03
It’s a great read and yes, Odesa itself is such an interesting place. As for the cats, I think the references are very deliberate – the author does of course mentioned Bulgakov, and Smiley definitely sounds like a nod to the masterspy!!
Sep 23, 2022 @ 18:30:06
This sounds excellent and your initial descriptions already had me thinking of Babel. Also a perfect fit for my cat page🙂😺
Sep 23, 2022 @ 20:13:23
Yes, the spirit of Babel is definitely there, as well as a fine selection of cats!
Sep 23, 2022 @ 18:36:33
I have skimmed your review, as I just finished reading it myself and will try to review it soon. I can see you enjoyed it too. Not my usual read at all but very entertaining.
Sep 23, 2022 @ 20:12:55
I did enjoy it, and I’ll look forward to your thoughts. It *is* very entertaining!
Sep 23, 2022 @ 21:51:22
I was looking at the cover and trying to work out what possible connection there could be between cats and murder and spies…. Mystery is now solved.
I chortled at the mention of the vat of sunflower oil – not quite as glamorous as the vat of Malmsey wine in which the poor Duke of Clarence met his end 🙂
Sep 24, 2022 @ 12:45:44
It’s a very clever mix, and the cats *are* essential to the plot… 😉 And yes – sunflower oil is a bit of a plebeian ending, but very Ukrainian!!
Sep 23, 2022 @ 23:47:17
I’ve wanted to read something set in Ukraine – but nothing as disturbing as what I see on the evening news. Maybe this is it, as it sounds like the serious parts are offset by the humor.
Sep 24, 2022 @ 12:40:50
I think this would be a good one – the threat from Russia is there in the background, but the narrative focuses firmly on Odesa, its history and its present, and the quirky humour does help, yes.
Sep 24, 2022 @ 09:20:26
Oooh, intriguing! You do sell these titles which have impressed you rather well. 🙂
Sep 24, 2022 @ 12:38:12
LOL, I do my best!!!
Sep 24, 2022 @ 09:24:13
Interesting review as ever, Karen. In fact, it strikes me that you’re ideally placed to spot those resonances with previous inhabitants of Odesa such as Gogol and Babel! V&Q seem to be carving out an interesting little niche for themselves as I recall you recommending one or two of their other releases in the past. It’s great to see.
Sep 24, 2022 @ 12:38:02
Thanks Jacqui! The references were certainly entertaining although I’m sure I didn’t pick up all of them. I’ve read a few V&Q books now and enjoyed them all – a very interesting publisher!
Sep 24, 2022 @ 10:08:24
This sounds thoroughly entertaining, though I’d be most keen to see how the cats are integrated into the rest of the story!
Sep 24, 2022 @ 12:37:00
The cats, as cats do, have their own agenda but she does weave them in very cleverly!
Sep 24, 2022 @ 10:40:39
This sounds excellent! Like you, my crime reading is mainly focussed on GA novels, but I do read some contemporary crime and this sounds very tempting, with the Odessa setting and surreal elements.
Sep 24, 2022 @ 12:36:36
It’s really good and not too gory so I was happy about that. And yes – the setting is wonderful and the cats unforgettable!
Sep 25, 2022 @ 14:30:26
Glad you enjoyed but sorry not for me. There is only so much of Ukraine that I can take in right now!
Sep 25, 2022 @ 16:39:15
Fair enough! Not every book is for everybody!