I’m rather horrified to find that “I Burn Paris” by Bruno Jasienski (translated by Soren A. Gauger and Marcin Piekoszewski) has been languishing on Mount TBR since 2014, when I picked it up hot on the heels of reading and reviewing “The Legs of Izolda Morgan” for Shiny New Books (you can read that post here). Both of Jasienski’s books are published in beautiful hardback editions by Twisted Spoon, an independent publisher based in Prague, and in fact I read and enjoyed another of their releases, “Severin’s Journey Into the Dark” by Paul Leppin, back in 2016.
As I said about Jasienski at the time, “born in Poland in 1901, his family moved to Russia in 1914 (before returning to Poland in 1918). He was old enough to be affected by the First World War, the Russian Revolution and Civil War, as well as the Polish-Russian war, and this coloured many of his writings. During his peripatetic life Jasieński moved about between Paris (from where he was expelled for writing the subversive novel, “I Burn Paris”), Poland and finally Russia, accepting Soviet citizenship.” Sadly, he was executed in 1938, a fact which was only confirmed in the 1990s.
However, it certainly seems that “Paris” is his best-known novel, so why has it taken me so long to pick it up?? Well, to be truthful, this is at least the third time I’ve started the book, and I’ve always stalled at the sections where the protagonist, Pierre, starts to unravel mentally and imagine he’s seeing his erstwhile love, Jeanne, in the arms of every fat capitalist he comes across. However, this time I was determined to read to the end, because the writing is excellent and there’s no reason not to; although I rather ended up with more than I bargained for…
The book (which was published in 1928) opens with Pierre, a lowly and impoverished factory worker, finding himself out of work. It seems impossible for him to find another job, and his beloved Jeanne has expensive tastes. Pierre is soon on the streets, starving and struggling to survive, and then imprisoned. On his release, a piece of luck comes his way when an old friend finds him work in Paris’s water system; but this gives the disillusioned man, still suffering from what’s happened to him, access to a laboratory containing all manner of viruses. Before long, he’s released a deadly plague into the water of the city and the residents begin dropping like flies. The resultant chaos sees Paris disintegrate into a dystopian nightmare, with various characters coming to the fore. There is a Chinese communist, a group of rabbis, disillusioned scientists, a cynical American millionaire and all manner of different groups fighting for survival in a plague ridden place. The French authorities wall off the city, the various groups grab a section each, banding together on the basis of ideology, religion or race, and plots develop to escape the blockade and make it into the wider world. Will they succeed – and what’s the future for the City of Light?
One evening the tide chucked him from the Montmartre boulevards and thrust him against the glass frontage of a grand music hall. A gigantic fiery windmill slowly turned its blades on their axis, summoning the ludicrous Don Quixotes of pleasure from the endless avenues of the world. The windows of the surrounding houses glowed with the bright-red embers of the unquenchable fever burning within.
It was time for the show to begin. The lobby was glassed in like a lighthouse, and around it a furious wave of automobiles crashed onto the sidewalk, only to recede moments late, leaving the white foam of ermine capes and tuxedo mantles, shirtfronts and sleeves on the rocky shore of the pavement.
“I Burn Paris” is such a deep and multi-layered book that it’s hard to summarise, and what I’ve said above can only give a flavour. For a start, the writing is superb; Jasienski’s modernist montage techniques give a vivid visual impression of the action and settings, while the metaphorical desciptions he uses are just stunning, and he brilliantly captures a world which had certainly moved irrevocably into the machine age, with all the dehumanisation that came with that. His narrative ranges far and wide, too; the characters he introduces, most particularly P’an Tsiang-kuei, are given a lengthy backstory and have a real depth, so that their actions are always believable.
The clash of various belief systems allows Jasienski to explore these thoroughly too, and it’s quite clear he feels nothing but distaste for corruption, decadence and the bourgeois liberals in Paris. The working class are always his heroes, and in fact it will be those from the lower echelons of society who will have more chance of making it through the plague. However, Jasienski is not so shallow as to condemn all non-working class characters, and the thread of the story following the American millionaire, David Lingslay, is powerful and moving, allowing the man redemption for his past. The resolution of the story is dramatic and perhaps unexpected, but I shall reveal nothing because this book greets you with unexpected twists and turns all the way through and I would hate to spoil this for anyone.
Like a shoddy machine, the world destroys more than it produces. This cannot go on. You have to strip everything down to the screws, throw away whatever’s useless, and after taking it apart, build it all over again, once and for all! The plans are ready, the builders’ fingers are itching, but the old, corroded scrap iron won’t give away. It has taken root, a coat of rust has formed in its seams, they’d have to yank out every screw with their teeth.
Had I known quite what I was getting into, I suspect I wouldn’t have chosen a dystopian plague novel to read right in the middle of a pandemic, although it’s reassuring to be living in a time when there are proper medical procedures and vaccines to help deal with such things… But having committed to the book, I carried on to the end and it was an exhilarating, often very moving, read. Despite the darkness he portrays, Jasienski *does* offer hope at the end, and the chance for humanity to move into a better, fairer phase. And stylistically, the book is stunning – Jasienski’s descriptions of the city, his use of metaphor, his characterisation are all unforgettable and the book really did get under my skin. There *were* minor flaws; a book written in 1928 does at times use character descriptions that might be a little unacceptable nowadays; and the influence of communist beliefs is perhaps a little naive, knowing what we do about the Soviet regime now. These elements didn’t detract for me, however, and I found “I Burn Paris” compelling reading all the way through.
So more than seven years after I bought it, “I Burn Paris” found its time, jumped off the TBR, and actually turned out to be an absolutely unforgettable book. I said in my (much) earlier reviews of Twisted Spoon books that they were a publisher I wanted to explore more, and of course I’ve completely failed to do that. However, I’m really, really glad I chose to read this brilliant, dark and haunting work just now; not always an easy read, but certainly one which will stay with me. Yes, I know I’m meant to be denting the TBR this year – but I may have to take another sneaky look at Twisted Spoon’s website… 😉
Jan 10, 2022 @ 09:58:52
Coincidentally I published a review of another Twisted Spoon book tonight. I haven’t read this one yet, but their books are always interesting and unique.
Jan 10, 2022 @ 15:47:06
I’ve only read a few of their books but I agree – fascinating stuff!
Jan 10, 2022 @ 10:43:58
Wow, just wow. And interesting it has contemporary echoes — but then all the best novels will, sooner or later!
Jan 10, 2022 @ 15:46:18
Definitely deserves a wow, and it’s one of those reads that mark you a bit. Thought I wish our pandemic had been so easily contained as Paris’s plague…
Jan 10, 2022 @ 12:02:41
‘Compelling’ is exactly the word I was thinking as I was reading your review. It sounds as though there’s so much in the book to unpack, that I completely understand why it took you some time to really get through it. I’ve found that multilayered books can take me a few reads before I really finish and absorb them. It sounds as though there’s plenty to reflect on here.
Jan 10, 2022 @ 15:44:37
You’re right, Margot – so much to think about, and it’s definitely one of those books which would benefit from a re-read I think. Part of me was reading to find out what happened and part was taking in the stunning writing and yet another part was considering the philosophies being explored. A really unforgettable book!
Jan 10, 2022 @ 18:31:50
Great review as always! This book and writer are not for me at this precise moment, but they’re now on my my radar and I’ll get to them (I’m very encouraged by the fact that you moved this off your TBR stack).
Twisted Spoon Press sounds fascinating; I’ll definitely look at their offerings, although it’s possible these may be hard to come by in the U.S.
Jan 10, 2022 @ 19:01:24
Thank you! I do understand that the timing for this one would be important, but I do hope you get to Jasienski at some point, As for TS, I don’t know what their distribution is like outside Europe but I hope you can track them down!
Jan 10, 2022 @ 18:34:46
Twisted Spoon publish some very interesting and little-known books.
I don’t know whether Jasienski took his plot from him, but an early H.G. Wells story, The Stolen Bacillus, features an anarchist releasing cholera – or so he imagines – in a London reservoir.
Jan 11, 2022 @ 14:28:07
Oh that’s interesting – I’ve not read the Wells so I wonder if it informed the Jasienski? As for TS – the call of their website is almost too much to resist!!!!
Jan 10, 2022 @ 18:51:41
I had a wry smile at your first paragraph. I have often bought a book thinking how I’ll read it soon then there it sits for years. I don’t think I could face a dystopian plague novel at the moment, so well done for persevering. It does sound fascinating.
Jan 10, 2022 @ 19:00:16
Yes, I’ve done that so many times with books – very naughty of me! It wasn’t the subject matter I would have consciously chosen, but nevertheless I did love the book!
Jan 10, 2022 @ 18:51:47
That does sound like a complex book and not one I’d want to read in These Times, either, but thank you for bringing it and the publisher to our attention!
Jan 10, 2022 @ 18:59:32
Had I realised how much of plague and the like, I might not have started it at the moment, but the writing was so good that it swept me up in the end. And Twisted Spoon have such a tempting catalogue of other titles that I really am trying hard to restrain myself!!
Jan 10, 2022 @ 20:33:24
So ashamed I never heard about that one, not even in French…
Looks quite unique, and in the 1920s!
Jan 10, 2022 @ 20:34:35
It’s such a fascinating read, and one which really gets under your skin and stays with you, despite the darkness of the subject matter. I do recommend it when you feel strong enough!
Jan 10, 2022 @ 22:15:20
It is interesting how much horrible stuff one can read about in a book if it is written well. I don’t think I’d cope with this story now though but it does sound fascinating.
Jan 11, 2022 @ 14:25:46
You’re right – the quality of the prose really makes a difference here, which must be why I could copy with the book in the middle of pandemic!!
Jan 11, 2022 @ 00:48:06
A terrific review and a very interesting sounding book. Somehow it reminds me a little of the work of Victor Serge or maybe it has to do with the author’s life. Twisted Spoon came on my radar recently, they are the publishers of Olga Tokarczuk’s ‘Primeval and Other Times’ which I posted about not too long ago. Taking a look at their book list, there are an awful lot of them that appeal…😬
Jan 11, 2022 @ 14:25:05
Thank you, and that’s an interesting comparison you make! I’ve read a lot of Serge and wouldn’t necessarily have connected the two as Jasienski’s writing is very modernistic. However, they both write stunning prose so they do have that in common, although Serge’s books are often based on polemics, he really can’t stop the prose master in him coming through. As for Twisted Spoon – well. I’m scared to look at their catalogue!!!
Jan 11, 2022 @ 16:50:20
Just to let you know, I am ignoring how much I want to read this novel following your review. 😂
Jan 11, 2022 @ 18:53:22
🤣🤣🤣🤣😆 Well Twisted Spoon count as an indie, don’t they?????
Jan 11, 2022 @ 19:21:15
It has not gone unnoticed …
Jan 11, 2022 @ 19:22:34
🤣🤣🤣🤣 Good!!
Jan 13, 2022 @ 18:42:47
This has been on my radar for a while but I think I’ve never quite got to the point of buying it for the same reasons you have taken so long to read it – wonderful as it sounds it also feels a little threatening!
Jan 13, 2022 @ 18:49:39
It has lots that’s very scary at the moment, but the writing is so good that I continued with it where I might have abandoned another book. I do recommend and I think it’s one you might love, Grant!
Jan 15, 2022 @ 13:58:41
I always get confused between this book and another similarly titled book called ‘Is Paris Burning?’, which focuses on the liberation of Paris by the French Resistance in WW2. (The film adaptation sometimes pops up on Talking Pictures, so I ought to try to catch it one day.) Your Jasienski sounds layered and complex, although probably not for me given the real world events of recent years. Nevertheless, it’s interesting to see your perspective on it here — almost as a way of experiencing elements of it vicariously from a relatively safe distance!
Jan 15, 2022 @ 16:53:53
Yes, it *is* confusing with those titles, isn’t it? And this is not a book to be undertaken lightly, I would say, but it is excellent. Quite a bit too close for comfort at times, but so thought provoking and really wonderfully written. I’m actually glad I read it and also glad it didn’t realise what it would be about because if I had, I most likely wouldn’t have read it just now!!
Jan 21, 2022 @ 21:40:55
Heheh I’m catching up: did you manage to just LOOK at the website? Or…
Never mind.
Jan 22, 2022 @ 10:49:13
I’ve actually managed to restrain myself so far – not sure how long that will last though!