Having got into a groove with some stories translated from the Russian for #WITMonth, I was a bit tempted to continue in that vein. I’ve had a major reshuffle of the Russian shelves, incorporating all the piles of books lying around the house so they were all in one place (and making careful note of unread titles whilst doing so!) And in the middle of this, I decided that instead of popping “The Girl from the Metropol Hotel” by Ludmilla Petrushevskaya (translated by Anna Summers) onto the shelf with her fictions, now would be a good time to start reading her!
Petrushevskaya is probably best known for her collections of short stories, with provocative titles like “There Once Lived a Woman Who Tried to Kill Her Neighbour’s Baby”; and her reputation has continued to grow in recent years. “Metropol…” however is a memoir; and the subtitle ‘Growing up in Communist Russia’ gives a hint of what can be expected. Although short, this is no light read…
Petrushevksaya was born in Moscow in 1938, in the titular Metropol Hotel, and lived there until 1941. At that point her father, a Bolshevik intellectual, was named as an enemy of the state. Petrushevskaya and her mother fled to Kuibyshev and from then on her childhood was one of suffering and constant change. As un-persons, Ludmilla and her mother lived on the poverty line, and the young girl was shuffled between relatives and homes, scrabbling to survive. Becoming feral, she often survived by scavenging and begging, and later attempts to teach her or ‘civilise’ her met mostly with failure – Petrushevskaya was a real wild child.
That feeling of coziness, of home, when a match strikes and a tiny circle of light appears, always returned when I had to settle in a new place. Never have I been frightened by circumstances. A little warmth, a little bread, my little ones with me, and life begins, happiness begins.
The book follows her life and travels until she finally grows up enough to become educated and get a break on Soviet radio. However, there are times during the story where it’s touch and go if she’ll make it. Yet, despite this grim subject matter, Petrushevksaya tells her story with a light touch, and it’s never less than readable. Told mainly in calm tones and often through a child’s eye, Ludmilla somehow travels through life avoiding the really bad stuff and makes it to adulthood – a true survivor.
As I said, this is grim stuff in places; and at times, when there are particularly threatening events (she finds herself potential prey of boys and men), Petrushevskaya switches to the third person, as if she can only relate her story by considering it as having happened to someone else. However, despite this, the book is incredibly compelling, and Petrushevkaya never indulges in self-pity; whether sleeping under a table in a communal apartment or in the Officers’ Club (where she finds shelter by breaking in), queuing in the bread line and getting served last, or pretending to be an orphan, she’s matter-of-fact and intent on survival. It’s this element, I think, that makes the book and its content less crushing than it could have been in someone else’s hands.
Back in Kuibyshev, her mother and sister accepted her disappearance without much joy. Her name was never mentioned again. On the other hand, so many people had vanished from their lives. At that time it was common – people disappeared without a trace, like the character in Daniil Kharms’s famous poem about a man who walked out of his house and was never seen again. Later the poet himself vanished. (On her mother’s disappearance)
One aspect of the book which was perhaps a little shocking was the willingness of Ludmilla’s mother to leave her with relatives or in homes and just go off; I guess needs must, and I’ve no idea how hard it was to live through the War and then post-War in Soviet Russia. However, it’s clear how much Petrushevskaya misses her mother and I did find this very moving. The daughter did, of course, survive and went on to have a fascinating life and a career, moving into the limelight after Perestroika and the fall of Communist Russia; and she’s now a multi-faceted artist, producing visual art and embarking upon a singing career as well as her writing.
There is nothing more beautiful than the steppe. Nothing. Even the ocean is smaller and ends sooner. For the rest of my days I will remember the sunrise over the steppe: a recently ploughed purple earth and an orange sun trembling over the horizon like an enormous egg yolk.
“Metropol…” is a gripping and enthralling read from start to finish, and the book is enhanced by the images included; some are personal photos from the author, and some photos to illustrate places and times. These add much to the narrative, and as an aside, I was really impressed with the quality of reproduction. I’ve read a number of paperbacks in recent months which have photos inserted into the main body of the narrative, and these are often muddy and of poor quality. I don’t know if it’s because my copy of the book is a US Penguin edition and the paper quality is better, but the images are really clear and well reproduced, which definitely enhanced the reading experience.
So my first experience of reading Ludmilla Petrushevskaya was a really powerful and memorable one. Her prose is excellent, her experiences unforgettable and her vivid portrait of life in Soviet Russia quite unparalleled. I loved making the acquaintance of Petrushevskaya for #WITMonth and really must get to her fictions soon! 😀
Aug 20, 2021 @ 07:10:26
This sounds very compelling. What a hard life but what a triumph over adversity…
Aug 20, 2021 @ 17:31:10
It is – although her life was a struggle, I couldn’t put the book down, and the matter of fact tone did help to deal with the difficulties.
Aug 20, 2021 @ 07:25:55
I think your observation re: mother-daughter relationship is spot on. Soviet Union and its practices did a lot to undermine mother-daughter relationships — mothers were under a lot of pressure to enter the workforce, and Petrushevskaya doesn’t blame her mother at all, but in her writing shows how necessary her mother had been to her. The mother-daughter theme is huge in her work, and I think she often shows the gruesome aftermath of the break in that relationship. Her novella Time: Night really takes that to the limit. That little book is not for the feint of heat….
Aug 20, 2021 @ 07:29:50
I think your observation re: mother-daughter relationship is spot on. Soviet Union and its practices did a lot to undermine mother-daughter relationships — mothers were under a lot of pressure to enter the workforce, and Petrushevskaya doesn’t blame her mother at all, but in her writing shows how necessary her mother had been to her. The mother-daughter theme is huge in her work, and I think she often shows the gruesome aftermath of the break in that relationship. Her novella Time: Night really takes that to the limit. That little book is not for the feint of heat….
(sorry for embedding issues again!)
Aug 20, 2021 @ 17:30:40
Thanks Olga! It’s certainly something which struck me, and also when reading Klotsvog recently. The expectations of Soviet women and normal motherly behaviour is strikingly different from Western countries – it must have been very hard to deal with.As for Time: Night, I do have that – will just have to make sure I’m feeling strong when I read it….
Aug 20, 2021 @ 09:04:06
This sounds such a compelling read, what an incredible life. I can’t imagine having to survive like that at such a young age.
Aug 20, 2021 @ 17:29:04
It is – and it’s something of a mirable that she did survive. I imagine many other youngsters fell by the wayside… 😦
Aug 20, 2021 @ 10:37:14
This sounds a tough read but well worth the effort. I share your annoyance about photos set into the text. Muddy’s a good word for the images that often result. I know it’s expensive to include them but I sometimes feel they’re best omitted.
Aug 20, 2021 @ 17:28:36
It *is* tough, but somehow uplifting in the end because she survives and makes a life for herself. As for the images, I often wonder why some publishers bother when you can make out absolutely nothing of what’s there. Here, they were really clear which was lovely!
Aug 20, 2021 @ 11:34:30
I think I would find this memoir really tough to read due to the bleakness you’ve described, but I am interested in trying this author’s fiction at some point. (The titles of her short stories are very striking, and the Penguin reissues look particularly tempting.) As an aside, I’ve just been watching Beanpole, a film by the Russian director Kantemir Balagov, which was inspired by Svetlana Alexievich’s Unwomanly Face of War. You might find it of interest, particularly given the setting.
Aug 20, 2021 @ 17:27:32
It’s bleak, yes, but somehow she manages not to bring you down – and the fact that she survived and created a life for herself is a real achievement. I’m now most keen to read her fictions. As for Alexievich, I do own her Chernobyl book, though I’m a little nervous of how harsh *her* work will be!
Aug 20, 2021 @ 12:25:42
That sounds great; I’ll have to read it. I’ve only read a few of her stories but they’re all excellent and make me want to read more. She’s incredibly popular in Russia — I don’t think an author with such a grim outlook would be so popular in the US! (Grim about daily life, I mean; people love stories about slashers and vampires and what have you…)
Aug 20, 2021 @ 17:26:06
It’s a really absorbing read, despite the grimness, and she’s so resilient. I’m really keen to read her fiction now, and yes – I think readers from countries other than Russia would have a different mindset! 😀
Aug 20, 2021 @ 12:46:12
Thank you so much. I wish I had time for it. I am tempted to buy it — I will share the blog with the people on my WomenWriters listserv.
Aug 20, 2021 @ 17:25:03
Thank you!
Aug 20, 2021 @ 13:36:55
Excellent review as always! I had almost forgotten that many years ago I read a glowing NY Times review of a story collection by Petrushevskaya (the name of the story you mentioned, about the woman trying to kill her neighbor’s baby, brought it back. How could you forget a title like that?). https://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/22/books/review/Schillinger-t.html?smid=em-share I passed on the collection at the time, as I didn’t think I was quite ready for it. Now, however, I think it’s time to sample this very intriguing writer!
Aug 20, 2021 @ 17:24:53
Thank you and thanks for the link! She’s a fascinating author and fortunately I do have other books by her!
Aug 20, 2021 @ 19:09:22
I really get a sense of Petrushevskaya’s life from your review, and I appreciated the probable reason you mention of her swapping from first person narrative to third when she’s describing difficult or traumatic occasions—that makes absolute sense.
Aug 20, 2021 @ 20:53:02
It’s a surprisingly evocative book, given its short length and Petrushevskaya’s economic narrative. Yet she gets so much across, and the switch from first to third person is really effective.
Aug 20, 2021 @ 20:53:47
This sounds like a fascinating memoir, what a harrowing childhood Petrushevskaya had. I can completely understand that device of switching to third person to narrate those really difficult sections. It does sound like a tough read. So it’s good to hear she overcame such a terrible early life. On a lighter note, I really love the title.
Aug 20, 2021 @ 20:56:12
It really is a fascinating book, Ali – and although her life is so difficult, the narrative is never oppressive because of the way she tells her story. I must admit to holding my breath a few times in the really difficult bits, but she did make it through safely!
Aug 21, 2021 @ 00:53:53
This is a wonderful book isn’t it? When I read it last year one of things that fascinated me was the history of the family and by the end I wished we had their stories too, especially her mother’s. The fraught issue of residence permits only added to her mother’s difficulties in trying to live with her own daughter.
Aug 21, 2021 @ 13:01:15
It really is, and I know what you mean about the other family members’ stories. It must have been incredibly difficulty negotiation the complexities of life in the Soviet Union, especially when you were outcasts.
Aug 22, 2021 @ 00:45:29
This sounds such an interesting read. 🐧🤠🎈
Aug 22, 2021 @ 12:44:43
It’s fascinating – so much packed into such a short book, and despite the grim subject matter it’s told with a light touch so you can get through it. An intriguing author.
Aug 22, 2021 @ 18:56:27
That sounds very compelling. And the abandonment by her mother reminds me of Maya Angelou and then her son being farmed out to near-strangers and relatives, so a thing of economic necessity more accepted then than now, I’m surmising. Well done for organising your shelves, too!
Aug 22, 2021 @ 19:56:02
It is really hard to put down, yes. And the necessity of farming out your child is so often based on survival or economy, and in the Soviet Union was very prevalent, as I’ve seen from another book I’ve just finished… ;D
Aug 23, 2021 @ 20:15:03
I love Petrushevskaya’s work. You’re right that, however bleak, there is a dark humour at work – this is true of her fiction as well.
Aug 24, 2021 @ 11:38:02
That’s good to know – I can deal with the dark if it’s balance with humour and I do love her writing here.
Aug 28, 2021 @ 07:00:41
Sep 09, 2021 @ 19:10:45
It’s so interesting how, with some authors, we postpone beginning their work, even when we have a bunch of reasons to believe it will be a rewarding experience and, then, in an instant, simply out of a change in resolve, we can have the opposite response to the same situation. Well, it bodes well, not only when it comes to stacks of books, that we CAN be very adaptable…if only we choose to be so!
Dec 17, 2021 @ 07:01:47