It’s probably fairly clear to anyone who reads my ramblings regularly that I’m an utter failure when it comes to reading challenges – either joining in with those run by others, or with the self-imposed ones I set myself in a flurry of enthusiasm and then allow to fall by the wayside… In fact, the only reading event I usually manage to stick to is the bi-annual reading clubs I co-host with Simon at Stuck-in-a-Book; and that’s with a lot of organisation and forward planning… And I was reminded recently that I devised (back in 2015!!) the project of reading all 27 books in the Penguin Modern Poets series, released between 1962 and 1979. In fact, I even have a page on the blog for it…
However, if you have a look you will see I stalled early, at book no. 6, which was back in 2016 – which is pretty feeble. However, despite that utter failure, I am still fighting the urge to approach another reading project; it was this which reminded me of the Poets, and it came about when I saw (on Twitter, I think) that Penguin are releasing set 6 of their Penguin Great Ideas series in September – and it includes Perec and Calvino and Camus amongst many other rather wonderful authors!
A quick hop onto Wikipedia revealed details of the 5 earlier sets, and I hadn’t quite realised how many there were; but I knew I had the whole first set and assorted volumes from the later ones. So of course I had to make a list, which is fatal for any book addict; because immediately you want to start collecting the whole lot, ticking them off merrily as you acquire them (well, I do, anyway…) Looking down the checklist, there is a fantastic range of titles, all of which I’d be happy to read. And a lightbulb ping moment in my head said “You could read them as a project, you know…” Of course, we know how badly I do with these things, and so it really *isn’t* a great idea (ha!). Still. I’m tempted – and trying to fight against it. You can see from the image above that although I have all the first set, I only have a few of the later ones, so that would be a lot of purchasing and a lot more shelf space needed. No, it really isn’t a good idea…
This also reminded me, of course, that I still have the Penguin Moderns box to make my way through, and I had been doing quite well, getting up to book 26 a year ago; and then I stalled… I *have* been galvanised to pick these up again, and have some reviews coming up next month of later volumes. However, as you can see from the picture, there are also the Penguin Little Black Classics, and I haven’t read all of them either. Yikes!
Anyway, I am going to try to take up the Poets Project again, and so I dug them out on Sunday to see what I had, where I was and generally take stock. This kind of necessitated a shuffle of the general poetry shelves which were slightly in disarray, and looked even worse when I started moving things about:
It was a useful exercise though; after having a bit of a crisis, I decided to shelve them alphabetically and put anthologies at the beginning, and after removing the Russians they fitted in quite nicely. Here’s the back row:
And here’s the front row:
This is, of course, not all the poetry in the house. The Russians are mostly on the shelf below; Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes are upstairs; and there are various Bloodaxe/Morden Tower anthologies lurking on other shelves. And probably others if I looked properly. Anyway, this is the next Penguin Modern Poets volume in the series:
Watch this space to see if I finish it! As for the Penguin Great Ideas – I think I’m going to be battling the concept of a project for a while; I’ve already sent off for one of the ones I don’t have, and will definitely be investing in more in September. Oh dear, oh dear….
Jun 29, 2020 @ 07:06:28
No comment. (I’ve been hit or miss with reading challenges myself. And my poetry books really do need some rearranging.)
Jun 29, 2020 @ 07:29:45
🤣🤣 Well, could be a nice soothing project for a Monday morning!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 07:49:52
I am not too successful with reading challenges (even the personal goals I keep to myself), but they are a useful prompt to consider one’s gaps. However, poetry has been one area in which my reading has greatly increased. Interestingly, although I own many anthologies and larger volumes of selected works and they have their place, my real growth as a poetry reader has come from engaging with shorter, single author collections by contemporary, mostly living poets. It is always encouraging to hear from poets (some of whom have become friends) who deeply appreciate a sensitive, personal reading. It reminds me that there is no one right way to read a poem.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 08:18:15
That’s a good point about the prompts, Joe – because I read in a fairly random manner, it’s nice to have something to help me focus and consider where I want to go with my reading.
And I so agree about the poetry – I’m always tempted by the chunky collected volumes, but the slim original collections are the thing to read – I’ve definitely found that out from my experiences with Larkin. I probably don’t read enough modern poetry, and there is a *lot* of it. But I have some contemporary collections lurking and I shall try to get to them sooner rather than later.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 08:42:06
Ha! As my wise old mother used to say, “Many a little bird sang in the morning and the cat had him before night!”
But good luck anyway (and we shall enjoy your efforts, stalled or otherwise).
Jun 29, 2020 @ 08:50:07
Your mother was right… But I shall definitely try to get on board with the poetry again, even if I manage to control my urges with the Great Ideas! ;D
Jun 29, 2020 @ 11:54:04
I have never heard of that saying Lisa but it is so true.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 12:51:28
It’s a good one…
Jun 29, 2020 @ 08:52:06
I was just wondering about your Penguin Moderns project when I read about your short stories reading from last week, but I couldn’t remember which series it was!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 11:24:14
Yes, the Penguin Moderns are very similar in size and length to the Faber Stories (and indeed the Little Black Classics.) Nicely bite sized for when you want a quick reading fix you can finish. I’m happy to report I’ve read four lovely Penguin Moderns recently (though the reviews won’t be until next month) so I’m well and truly inspired to get on with them! 😀 Might even have to give them a page of their own on the blog!!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 09:34:07
Having started multiple reading challenges in a real flush of early-blogger enthusiasm I can sympathise. I got frustrated for a while because I never seemed to finish any of them. And then came the day when I decided there was a difference between a reading challenge and a reading project. A challenge has a deadline usually or a numeric target. A project is more a case of general intent rather than a specific goal. So why not do a project – no-one is driving you to accomplish it by any date. Take your time and enjoy it.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 11:22:33
You know, that’s a good way of thinking about it. If I regard these things as projects to be fitted in when the mood is right I won’t feel pressured. I certainly can’t do the time-limited challenges, but projects may well be the way forward. Of course, you realise I *may* now have to seriously consider a Penguin Great Ideas project… ;D
Jun 29, 2020 @ 19:38:16
Open-ended reading projects are definitely the way to go. They’re about enjoyment, whereas challlenges smack of work …
Jun 29, 2020 @ 20:10:12
Yeah, definitely. I never want to make reading a chore!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 11:40:59
It’s the thought that counts in reading challenges! I rarely finish any either. 😀
Jun 29, 2020 @ 12:54:34
It is! I shall reassure myself with that thought. I do mean well and intend to finish challenges and projects, it’s just there are so many books and they all get in the way… ;D
Jun 29, 2020 @ 11:44:08
Oh dear reading challenges can be a problem. It’s so much fun putting together lists or piling up books to photograph, then we get distracted. At the moment I can cope with week long challenges or things I can dip in and out of, like #WITMonth. I love your club weeks too of course. Good luck. 😉
Jun 29, 2020 @ 12:53:56
Thank you! The fun of lists and gathering piles of books is immense – but as a rule, once I’ve done that I want to go straight off and read something else! ;D Dipping in and out is the thing, and the club weeks are fun because of the variety of books you can choose. Likewise with WIT – lots of flexibility! 😀
Jun 29, 2020 @ 11:57:21
OH ho ho, Penguin just should not release another set. I am such a pushover for their sets. I have several beautiful sets, lists made, good intentions and then I go and watch something on Netflix. We must have a common ancestor way back when or were just separated at birth. You do make me laugh. I think the idea of a project instead of a challenge is good too but then all the shelves of books I have are a project. (sigh). Just be happy reading whatever you feel like in the moment. 😍
Jun 29, 2020 @ 12:51:19
I am too. I have their Great Loves and English Journeys sets as well, which could well be another project – oh dear… I don’t make as many lists and plans as I used to but it’s very tempting – we definitely have some shared ancestry somewhere! Project is the word I shall stick with, and I’ll definitely just keep reading what I want!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 14:02:08
That’s a *lot* of poetry! I just have a few scattered books of translated poetry here and there…
Jun 29, 2020 @ 16:12:44
It *is*! I’m very fond of poetry although I don’t read nearly enough of it, and I also struggle sometimes with how to review it. But it does speak to me very directly on an emotional level in a way prose usually doesn’t.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 14:02:14
Karen, as someone who always fails at reading challenges I am full of fellow-feeling with you, but also impressed at your tenaciousness because you have not yet failed you are merely strrrrrrretching them out.
As an example of my enduring crapness and also a self-interested spot of blog promotion, I have just started off Sylvia Townsend Warner Reading Week and have not finished reading two of the books I plan to write about. And work-wise this is a heavy week. Bother.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 16:09:41
Yes! That’s my excuse and I’m sticking to it! 😀 If I can make a project last for years that’s a good thing, surely??
I really wanted to read something for the STW reading week, because she *is* rather wonderful, but I don’t think I shall manage. as I’m having a stinker of a work week too. I’m keen to get hold of the new Persephone collection, thought – so tempting….
Jun 29, 2020 @ 16:44:33
Exactly! You are prolonging the pleasure, and taking the time to really appreciate what you’re reading… That’s the sort of thing I like to tell myself, anyway…
It’s so distressing when work interferes with reading, don’t you think? 😉 Hope your week passes painlessly.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 17:18:36
I’ll tell myself anything when it comes to books…. ;D
And you too – I hope the reading week goes really well and work doesn’t get in the way too much!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 14:14:21
I start quite a few books of poetry but don’t finish them. Even with the best poets, there seems to be a lot of filler between the gems. I really like Randall Jarrell’s comment:
“A good poet is someone who manages, in a lifetime of standing out in thunderstorms, to be struck by lightning five or six times; a dozen or two dozen times and he is great”.
By the way, I really loved Randall Jarrell’s comic novel ‘Pictures from an Institution, but can’t get into his poetry at all.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 16:07:45
That’s a wonderful quote, although I think some poets manage to get struck continually! My favourites, for example Larkin, never seem to produce a weak poem. I always think it’s best to stick to the original collections, though – those chunky collected ones can be a bit offputting!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 16:16:49
I usually lean more to ‘Selected Poems’ rather than ‘Collected Poems’. With Philip Larkin I do have his ‘Collected Poems’, but even some of his don’t hit home for me.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 16:18:57
The problem with the collected Larkin is that the poems are arranged chronologically, so you lose the narrative sense that he was trying to get across when he sequenced the poems for the individual collections. I actually have bought the individual collections so I can read them as Larkin intended and the impact is wonderful and very different.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 16:20:28
Wow, You are a Philip Larkin fan!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 16:21:59
Very much so! I first read his poetry as a teenager at Grammar School and I’ve loved his work ever since!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 14:48:41
I am not very good at reading challenges either – but I’ve long since decided that the pleasure of coming up with a list and setting a goal is enough to make it worthwhile, even if I don’t tick off every book that I plan to read.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 16:04:46
You’re right – the prep is a good proportion of the fun, so I think I’ll look at it like that. List and book piles are most enjoyable! 😀
Jun 29, 2020 @ 15:30:20
Was that project really four whole years ago? I remember it well! Good luck picking it up again, I’ve been making an effort to read more poetry this year and I’m loving having more of it in my reading life.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 16:04:04
Scary, isn’t it? I couldn’t quite believe it was that long since I read one of these, but I *have* got going again with vol 7 so that’s good! I do love poetry.
Jun 29, 2020 @ 15:41:44
It’s great to know that I’m not the only one who falls behind at their own challenges! Still, I feel my Muriel Spark reading is nearing a conclusion (this year?) and I’m optimistic about my missing IFFP reading starting soon. And I do always take part in your bi-annual reading clubs! (I’m not going to list all the others which have led nowhere…)
Jun 29, 2020 @ 16:03:18
I must admit I set myself less challenges nowadays because I know what I’m like! But if we get there eventually that’s the main thing, and reading Spark is a good porject. As for the Clubs, hopefully they’re quite low maintenance and fun!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 16:58:11
You just brought back a memory for me; my dad had many of the Penguin Modern Poets series, and when I needed to pick a poem for a school project, he recommended a Roger McGough poem from Volume 10 (can no longer remember which one or why). In doing research on it, I found an audio recording of Adrian Henri reading his poem, “Tonight at Noon” and fell in love with that poem instead. Still have the recording on a cassette tape around here somewhere…
Jun 29, 2020 @ 17:17:59
How lovely! It’s wonderful when a book or books can connected us with our past or parents. My late dad and I both read The Lord of the Rings sequence at the same time, when I was in my early teens, so I always connect it with him. I’m looking forward to volume 10 as I do love the Mersey Poets!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 19:45:51
Coincidentally, I associate the Lord of the Rings with my dad as well, since he read the trilogy aloud to me when I was a kid. I’ll be interested to hear what you have to say about Volume 10, especially since I can’t seem to remember anything at all about Roger McGough, despite working on that school project about him!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 20:09:56
How lovely! And as for vol 10, I haven’t read McGough for years but my BFF is a huge fan so will probably tell me off if I get anything wrong about him! 😀
Jun 29, 2020 @ 17:32:37
well your shelves got a tidy up which is also just a lovely thing to do isn’t it? and now I think I must go and look at all these penguin sets because I feel I’m missing out!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 17:35:52
LOL, it is – I do love tidying up the bookshelves. As for all the Penguin sets – they’re sooooo tempting!!
Jun 29, 2020 @ 20:44:16
Didn’t think one could die of envy but very nearly did looking at all your photos.My main project is to read only women writers and novels more than 300 pages long.Emphasis on ageing women,and Irish authors.Mini challenge..working my way through all the sci-fi anthologies published since I “went off “sci first,forty years ago.
As well as book club ..we work on themes or “ways of reading”.,This month it’s fiction/nonfiction pairing.
Jun 30, 2020 @ 05:44:47
Projects are obviously a Good Thing and the way to go. It should make a project of actually reading all of the TBR then I might get a bit focused and read all my unread books. I like the sound of your projects though – which reminds me of all the unread sci fi I have lurking…
Jun 29, 2020 @ 20:45:27
Science Fiction!
Jun 30, 2020 @ 05:44:57
😁😁😁
Jun 29, 2020 @ 23:15:26
Oh, go for it Kaggsy! You’ll get lots of wonderful new books, more reasons to tidy the shelves and some great reading, regardless of whether you finish or not! The rest of us will get some lovely photos and fun, insightful reviews. A total win-win, for all concerned!
Jun 30, 2020 @ 05:42:39
Noooo! Don’t tempt me even more!!! But you do make it sound like a reasonable idea…. 🤣🤣
Jul 01, 2020 @ 21:06:45
I like the distinction made by BookerTalk between challenges and projects – I did that myself when I called “reading all around the world” a project and didn’t set a time limit. There was a while when it languished but now I’ve gotten into it again. So maybe one day you will dive into a lot of those wonderful little books and then ignore them again for a long time. And that’s okay.
I wish you luck in navigating your shelves!
Jul 02, 2020 @ 11:01:04
Yes, I do too. I think that a challenge implies difficulty, A project can be picked up and put down as it feels right, and I’m going to think of my reading like that going forward. As for the shelves – they *do* need some serious organisation….
Jul 02, 2020 @ 07:42:16
Once upon a time when the earth was young, I used to be supremely good at Reading Challenges! But lately, it has gone to well, so I understand completely! I also understand the need to make a list and then start collecting everything you don’t own but will get to eventually *******ahem! ahem********* all the best with your Poetry project! The Shelves look awesome!
Jul 02, 2020 @ 10:56:47
LOL. I have the collecting gene, that’s for sure! I have been good so far, and only acquired one new Great Ideas book – but the temptation is strong. I’m trying to focus on the books I actually own at the moment, but it’s not easy…
Jul 06, 2020 @ 19:37:23
If it’s any consolation, it doesn’t seem ALL that long, 2016 and 2019, apparently, since you last updated us on these challenges. You know what would probably reignite your enthusiasm? Starting a new reading project! *ahem* And I’m terrible about this very thing, but I just amble along, still being excited, occasionally picking up a baton dropped along the way, still excited and still ambling, and on and on, so maybe I just need to believe that it’s all just as it should be.
Jul 06, 2020 @ 20:10:55
Oh, don’t! I’m constantly having to resist these projects! But I *have* got back on board with the two ongoing ones, which will be seen this month and next. As for new ones – I’m still tempted….
Jul 31, 2020 @ 06:37:33
Aug 01, 2020 @ 06:52:03
Aug 05, 2020 @ 21:48:27
How are you getting on with the challenge, two months on?
Aug 08, 2020 @ 11:22:39
Ah, well if you look at recent posts you’ll see I’ve got back on the wagon with the poetry and the Penguin Moderns…
Sep 04, 2020 @ 06:23:37