Nagasaki by Eric Faye
Translated by Emily Boyce
The trouble with following as many book blogs I do is, frankly, the number of recommendations and book ideas you get. On top of this, my memory is shocking and I tend to forget who it was who wrote about a particular book. However, in this case I’ve managed to remember that it was Karen at Booker Talk who wrote about “Nagasaki”; and I was so intrigued that I picked up a copy and read it recently when the need to read something short and actually *finish* it took hold of me!
French author Eric Faye has written numerous novels and short stories; interestingly, he’s also a journalist, and “Nagasaki” draws on a real-life news story. Set in the titular Japanese city, it tells the story of meteorologist Kobo Shimura who lives quietly on his own in an ordinary suburban street. A creature of routine, he lives an isolated life, rarely mixing with his younger colleagues and his life proceeds undisturbed until one day he notices something strange. It appears that food and drink are going missing from his fridge; and as he lives in a neighbourhood where residents don’t lock their doors the natural assumption is that there has been an intruder. However, a locked door doesn’t stop the disappearances, and so Shimura installs a webcam to find out what is going on. The results are unsettling, to say the least, and the consequences fairly explosive for both Shimura and the visitor who’s been helping themself to his supplies.
And here I hit a dilemma of how much to reveal about this book. It’s probably fair to acknowledge that the blurb gives away that someone has been living secretly in Shimura’s house; a homeless woman who’s hidden herself in a spare room cupboard. Her actions, taken out of necessity, have a destabilising effect on Shimura and his sense of security in his own home; and the women herself faces an uncertain future.
I don’t want to say too much more about the plot, as the book retains surprises up to the end. What I do want to mention is the clever use of point-of-view in the writing. The book is initially told entirely from Shimura’s viewpoint, and we see things only from his perspective and sympathise with his outrage about having his privacy violated. However, midway through the narrative shifts and we have parts told by an omnicient narrator and parts from the woman herself which radically change our view of events. That shift of perspective opens up the story, allowing it to take in much more than just the narrow view of Shimura’s life; and we realise that the woman is just as alienated in relation to the modern world as is Shimura concerning his violated territory.
“Nagasaki” is a short novella of 109 pages yet produces so much food for thought. There’s the worrying subject of a nation’s duty to take care of its population; our individual duty to help our fellow humans; our need for solitude and privacy versus our need for companionship; and oddly enough, our wish for resolution. Without giving anything away, the end of the book *is* unresolved and I wasn’t sure (and still am not) whether that was the ending I wanted and needed to this story. There are hints, too, of Nagasaki’s tragic past woven into the narrative and I perhaps would have liked this element to be drawn out more.
Nevertheless, this *is* a novella and such as it is very effective and moving. Despite the ambiguous and perhaps unfinished nature of the ending, I kept thinking about the story long after I’d finished it; and I certainly think in this modern world we need to do more to look after the lonely and the homeless, as well as trying to get back some sense of community and compassion. “Nagasaki” was a thoughtful read and I do recommend you give it a look if you come across it.
Jacqui has also reviewed the book here!
Mar 05, 2020 @ 07:18:52
It’s interesting to read your reflection on this…Yes, a very thought-provoking novella, one that raises so many questions about the broader society and duty of care. The fact that it’s based on a real-life incident makes it all the more unsettling…
Mar 05, 2020 @ 09:03:27
Ah! I had forgotten you reviewed it too, and I’ve linked to your post!
And yes – a strangely haunting book which really does raise so many questions about our modern world. Subtly disturbing in many ways…
Mar 05, 2020 @ 19:39:09
No worries at all! It was years ago, possibly before we started following one another, so you may not have seen it at the time. Many thanks for the link, very kind.
Mar 05, 2020 @ 20:25:27
Could well be! A very interesting read though, and always happy to link to your posts! 😀
Mar 05, 2020 @ 10:00:26
The shift in perspective sounds very clever. I had a bit of that in “The 24-hour Cafe” (I think I’m reviewing that tomorrow, I’ve got ahead in my reading and trying to space out the reviews!) where we saw a friendship from one half’s perspective then the other’s. Certainly seems to be a powerful novella.
Mar 05, 2020 @ 11:22:21
It’s certainly very affecting, and the shift halfway through makes you think quite deeply about who’s telling the story and whose perspective you’re looking at things from. A thoughtful book.
Mar 05, 2020 @ 11:57:45
I wonder what the Japanese think of this book and whether it has been translated into Japanese. They are still quite reluctant to address the homeless people issue…
Mar 05, 2020 @ 13:49:25
That’s a really good thought. And it’s interesting that it was a Frenchman who wrote this novel, not a Japanese author. If there is a cultural issue here, it may be something they don’t like to acknowledge…
Mar 05, 2020 @ 20:21:59
This sounds very intriguing indeed. Especially with it being based on real life events.
Mar 05, 2020 @ 20:24:14
It was, and I wasn’t quite sure where the book would go as I hadn’t heard about the real life case before. A really interesting read!
Mar 06, 2020 @ 04:11:44
Like you I read Karen’s review some time ago and decided Nagasaki sounded very promising. Was very pleased when I found a copy on Better World Books – and was so disappointed when it arrived to find it was all in French!!! Drat! Will continue to search.
Mar 06, 2020 @ 09:27:33
Oh dear…! I would have struggled with a French edition too – so disappointing!!! ;D
Mar 07, 2020 @ 13:41:51
I really like the sound of this, the shift in perspective sounds clever and well handled. And I do love a novella!
Mar 07, 2020 @ 15:40:51
Yes, I’m fond of the form too. It’s quite an art to make an impact in such a limited number of pages, and this certainly did.
Mar 07, 2020 @ 15:56:54
So glad you found this interesting. I keep wanting to know what happened to the woman but haven’t found any news articles that tell me.
I don’t care for short stories but am finding novellas fascinating
Mar 07, 2020 @ 18:57:37
It really was, although I still think I would like a little more resolution – and like you, want to know what happened to the real woman!
Mar 08, 2020 @ 14:19:44
I’m quite intrigued and will look for it, in the original, of course.
He got the Grand Prix de l’Académie française for this one in 2010.
Mar 08, 2020 @ 15:42:41
I can understand why; it really is a fascinating read and lingers in the mind.
Mar 10, 2020 @ 20:01:59
You have certainly piqued my interest with this – in fact, I think it was piqued before by Jacqui’s review as I have a copy on Kindle which I’d completely forgotten about!
Mar 11, 2020 @ 13:22:15
It’s an intriguing read, that’s for sure. I *still* am undecided about the ending, but it certainly is a book that lingers.
Jul 06, 2020 @ 04:45:40
Thank you for reviewing this book, it just moved up on our wishlist 🙂
Jul 06, 2020 @ 06:53:41
It’s a great read!