I really am maintaining the reputation of being Shiny New Books’ unofficial Russian correspondent! So it was a given that I would be the obvious choice to review a fat new volume from Helen Rappaport which takes a look at the fate of the last Russian royal family – in particular, the various plots that were hatched to rescue the hapless Romanovs and save them from the hands of the Bolsheviks.
It’s an intriguing book, although I did have some reservations. If I’m honest, I’ve struggled with previous attempts to read Rappaport’s books as I sensed a bias – which is something I don’t like to see in a historian; I prefer an objective look at things. Also, this is one of a series of books she’s written on the subject and I did feel that it didn’t warrant a whole big volume; her research (which actually seemed to be undertaken by numerous people all over the world on her behalf) would have been better presented in a scholarly journal rather than a work of popular history. And the way that the new discoveries are signposted in the text by an italicised paragraph *did* jar a lot.
Nevertheless, this is a pretty and well presented volume, with some fascinating photos. I think you need to know a reasonable amount about the historical period to really get the most out of the book, and you can read my full review here on Shiny!
Nov 15, 2018 @ 17:53:19
That is a beautiful, sumptuous looking volume. The Romanovs are a fascinating family, so it is a shame that the book let you down a bit.
Nov 15, 2018 @ 18:37:13
It *is* a shame. I’ve been reading about the Romanovs since my teens, so I’ve covered a fair amount of ground with them. But I found myself doubting that the material warranted a whole big book, particularly when it assumes the reader has a lot of pre-knowledge. A shame, because it *is* beautifully produced. Maybe I’m not the best reader for ‘popular’ history!