I spent some time over the summer revisiting the work of Katherine Mansfield, which was pure joy and came about because of two unrelated sources! Firstly, my OH rather cleverly presented me with the DVD which you can see in the picture: a wonderful 6-part BBC series on KM from 1973. With Vanessa Redgrave perfectly cast as Mansfield and the gorgeous Jeremy Brett as a very buttoned-up and intense John Middleton Murry, it made for compelling viewing. Now as you might have picked up, I’m not one for TV, especially not modern rubbish (!) – although I adore a decent documentary as I’ve often made plain. But this is TV from when I was growing up, which often looked more like filmed plays and had what I would call Proper Acting, and it was just brilliant and moving. Annette Crosbie was perfect as Mansfield’s BFF, LM, and the series featured episodes from her life interspersed with dramatizations of her work.
The show was a real treat, and made even better by the fact I had a lovely copy of a new selection of her stories which has just been brought out by Alma Classics. “The Garden Party and Selected Short Stories” is a handsome little volume, and contains some classic KM. The title story is possibly her most famous, but it also contains myriad treats from her other collections too. There’s “Je ne parle pas francais”, where Mansfield slips into the voice of a young French roué; “The Daughters of the Late Colonel”, a sharp dissection of two maiden sisters who’ve wasted their life looking after their bullying father; and several stories from “In a German Pension”, which cast a cynical eye on the snobbery and pettiness of boarding house life. And that’s just a few of the treats – the Alma book is a really nice collection and a good way to start to explore her work if you’re interested.
Mansfield only ever wrote short stories (and poems and letters and journals, of course!) and that format seems so perfectly suited to her. I’ve seen her stories compared to Chekhov (another master of the form) and I don’t think that’s such a wild pairing. Many of the stories in the book draw on Mansfield’s childhood in New Zealand and they’re moving and evocative; she has a particular talent for capturing the child’s eye view, and revisiting her prose reminded me of why Virginia Woolf stated KM’s was the only writing she had even been jealous of.
I finished both book and TV series in a fairly emotional state. I had quite an obsession with Mansfield in my early 20s but hadn’t read her for ages; and of course her life was such a short and tragic one, dying at an early age from TB. The end of the TV show was desperately moving, although it did send me off to check the facts, as I had forgotten that her husband Murry had been present when she died. I dug out my old Alpers biography and found that the TV show had been remarkably faithful to the truth, which set me off again. I have volumes of Mansfield’s letters and diaries on the shelf and I may have to make some return visits to those, as well as exploring the ones I’ve not read yet. Mansfield was a brilliant writer; both Redgrave and Brett are/were fine actors; and all of this added up to a marvellously emotional experience over the summer break.
However, despite him having bought me the DVD, I did actually have to explain to OH who Katherine Mansfield was…. 😀
Review book kindly provided by Alma Classics, for which many thanks!
Sep 12, 2018 @ 07:42:03
LOL Karen, methinks we might be twin souls. I like Proper Acting too, and find most of what’s on offer today sadly shallow.
(A friend and I just watched the entire series of The Pallisers (1974, BBC, reissued on DVD) week by week over some months and it was bliss.)
But I did not know about this KM series and will now have to Have a Hunt for it. BTW Katherine Mansfield the Storyteller is a brilliant bio which you might also enjoy: see https://anzlitlovers.com/2011/07/01/katherine-mansfield-the-storyteller-by-kathleen-jones-bookreview/
Sep 12, 2018 @ 15:54:50
🙂 LOL indeed. The sets may be a bit cardboard and shaky in places but the acting is top notch. Interestingly, the adaptations of her stories are shot on location and on film, whereas the life parts are done on video and in the studio – almost play-like, with simple sets. It makes for a very interesting distinction between the two parts of the show. And I’ll check out The Storyteller, although it’s not as if I need any more books, is it???? 😉
Sep 12, 2018 @ 23:24:07
Moi? Tempt you to acquire more books? Surely not, *chuckle* it’s not as if you don’t do it to me!!
Sep 13, 2018 @ 06:05:55
LOL! We’ll just think of ourselves as book enablers…
Sep 12, 2018 @ 07:53:17
Those Alma Classics editions are lovely, aren’t they? Very pretty. I’m ashamed to say that I haven’t read very much Katherine Mansfield, only the occasional story or two. This book sounds as if it would make a good introduction to her work.
Sep 12, 2018 @ 15:53:09
They really are – Alma do produce some very pretty books. And this would definitely give you a flavour of her stories, very much a good place to start.
Sep 12, 2018 @ 08:40:07
I haven’t read KM for years; my copy of the complete stories was read back then, but I remember only fragments from them. I do recall thinking of their Chekhovian tone.
Sep 12, 2018 @ 15:52:32
She’s certainly got that Chekhovian art of capturing a life in a short story. Such a good writer.
Sep 12, 2018 @ 08:55:21
Sounds like a great series to watch. I read In A German Pension last summer – love the poignant views of different cultures and characters in those stories.
Sep 12, 2018 @ 15:52:01
It’s a wonderful show, not only because of the sections with Redgrave and Brett, but the adaptations of the stories are great too.
Sep 12, 2018 @ 09:34:44
I have to find a copy of that DVD. I studied Mansfield as part of my degree and loved her work but not until around a decade later so wouldn’t have noticed the series at the time. Her letters and journals are among the 20% of my books that made the cut and came with me when I moved, my favourite entry being that from June 10th 1919. “I have discovered that I cannot burn the candle at one end and write a book with the other.” I’ve put an exclamation mark next to it and substituted the word essay for book!
Sep 12, 2018 @ 15:51:24
It’s just wonderful. And I’m pretty sure her books will be ones that stay with me wherever I go in the long term!
Sep 12, 2018 @ 13:39:23
What a nice collection. I haven’t read Mansfield yet although I have The Montana Stories TBR. I’m inspired read this and to look for more of her work.
Sep 12, 2018 @ 15:50:50
I must admit I’m tempted by the Montana Stories. Her writing is just wonderful and definitely worth you spending time with.
Sep 12, 2018 @ 14:04:45
How I love Mansfield! Reading her for the first time, around about 18, was a transforming experience. But I did not know about this series – and with VANESSA REDGRAVE! Goodness, how exciting!
Sep 12, 2018 @ 15:50:26
I love Mansfield too – and yes, VANESSA REDGRAVE, who is actually perfect in the part. Do track it down, Simon – I think you’ll love it! (if you can ignore creaky sets and focus on the wonderful acting!)
Sep 12, 2018 @ 17:29:58
Oh I love Katherine Mansfield, though l haven’t read all her work yet. I read The Montana Stories (Persephone edition) earlier this year which contains The Garden Party (quite brilliant). What a lovely new edition.
Sep 12, 2018 @ 18:56:51
She was such a wonderful writer. I do think I’d like to pick up Montana Stories, but this edition is just lovely too! 🙂
Sep 12, 2018 @ 20:53:10
I’ve been meaning to read some Mansfield stories for a while because she is considered such a master.
Sep 12, 2018 @ 20:57:56
She is, and her prose is wonderful, but she’s also very readable too. This might well be a good place to start! 😉
Sep 12, 2018 @ 21:20:54
I think I saw just one part of this series many years ago and it piqued my interest in Mansfield, or else it was a shortened version of the series somehow (who knows how things get altered as they cross the pond). Another volume that you might enjoy, depending how much of a view of the process you enjoy, is the Notebooks edited by Margaret Scott. Not that you need any help adding to your TBR or your shelves: I know you don’t!
Sep 13, 2018 @ 06:07:27
It’s definitely worth seeking out – very faithful to Mansfield’s life and so beautifully done. As for the bookish hint – well, it’s a good thing I’m currently compiling some Christmas suggestions for the Offspring….
Sep 13, 2018 @ 09:56:22
Oh, my ears – eyes? – pricked up at the mention of notebooks, thank you buriedinprint, I shall check that out too.
Like so many others, I first read Mansfield when I was a teenager and I think her tragic story was quite appealing to me then as well as her wonderful writing. But I’ve read very few of her letters. And who was LM?
Sep 13, 2018 @ 20:31:46
🙂 The notebooks sound irresisitible don’t they? As for LM, she was KM’s BFF of sorts – or doormat or emotional support or whatever. Her real name was Ida Baker, but KM nicknamed her Lesley Moore or LM. Theirs was a complex dynamic as I recall from my readings of Mansfield many decades ago, and Annette Crosbie brilliantly caught the doormat aspect of LM in their relationship! 🙂
Sep 15, 2018 @ 14:32:49
Yes I definitely feel a Mansfield reading project coming on (I also eyed your volumes of letters enviously) to distract me from the horrors of school paperwork…
Lesley Moore is quite an odd nickname for someone called Ida Baker, I wonder where that came from? (Maybe I’ll have to get hold of a biography too.) It doesn’t suggest a very balanced friendship at all!
Sep 15, 2018 @ 16:21:27
I don’t think it was a balanced friendship at all, but yes – a biography is always worth seeking out,
Sep 13, 2018 @ 19:04:42
I didn’t know about this DVD and must get it! I know mostly about KM through VW, and have only just started reading her short stories. Who is LM?
Sep 13, 2018 @ 20:32:40
It’s a great series and definitely worth checking out. For LM see my reply to Helen above – KM’s devotated female sidekick.
Sep 14, 2018 @ 11:32:22
I loved this post, Karen! Coincidentally, I’ve been reading KM’s letters this year, and they’ve been really illuminating to me. I don’t think I’ve read all her short-story collections, but I love everything I read from her. 🙂
Sep 14, 2018 @ 13:49:50
Thanks Juliana! Her writing is marvellous and like you I rather want to read everything… 😉
Sep 15, 2018 @ 14:20:20
I’m not sure Mr Liz would know who she was. I do have a book of her stories but horrendously enough remember not enjoying them very much. Sacrilege! I may have to revisit …
Sep 15, 2018 @ 16:22:55
LOL! These non-literary OHs…. And not a Mansfield fan? I shan’t shout about it – it would be dull if we all liked the same and I’m probably never going to get over my issues with Lawrence and Hardy!
Sep 16, 2018 @ 20:39:26
Lovely post Kaggsy. I’ve got The Montana Stories in the TBR, I’m hoping to get to it for the Persephone readathon. I had no idea about that TV series – definitely one to watch!
Sep 16, 2018 @ 21:25:28
Look forward to your thoughts on the Montana Stories! And yes – the TV show was very special!
Apr 14, 2020 @ 06:33:39