Yes, I’m afraid there’s been *more* dipping going on at the Ramblings! I think it must be a necessary counterpoint to all the Big Review Books I’m reading at the moment; I’ve obviously felt the need to also read something I can actually *finish* fairly quickly…
“Great Tales of Detection”, an unassuming looking collection (the cover is a bit dull, isn’t it?) from 1936, which was reprinted in 1976, came from a charity shop trawl recently; and I picked it up a) because it was edited by Dorothy L. Sayers and b) because the contents were by lots of lovely favourite crime authors and I think several are stories by them I haven’t read! So it was definitely one to come home with me. From the Oxfam if I recall correctly, and not too pricey (they seem to have had a bit of an overhaul since and the cost of some of their books seems to have suddenly spiked – which is a bit daft, because this has made me put several back on the shelves…)
Anyway, I have dipped, reading a short extract entitled “Was it Murder?” by Robert Louis Stevenson with a very entertaining take on how you actually define murder if the murderer wasn’t present and nothing can be proved! But the other story I found myself glued to was “The Yellow Slugs” a very dark little tale by H.C. Bailey, whom I’ve read before. Bailey’s detective was Reggie Fortune, a doctor with a strong hatred of cruelty, and I first made his acquaintance in the wonderful British Library Crime Classics collection “Capital Crimes” back in 2015. The stories there impressed me, and I did say how keen I was to read more about Reggie. Now, I know there is an e-book lurking somewhere on my tablet, but I always forget about those, so this was the first story I turned to in this anthology.
“The Yellow Slugs” opens with a tragic-sounding case; a teenage boy apparently going off the rails and accused of trying to drown his younger sister. Is the boy insane or just a nasty piece of work? Reggie is called into the case in his role as a doctor, but he soon sees there is more to things than meets the eye and of course starts to investigate.
It’s not a straightforward crime; all the evidence supports the boy being a bad lot, and the pious and upset parents, as well as their genteel lodger, seem blameless. However, an actual murder is discovered and it takes all Reggie’s persistence and ingenuity to get to the truth of the matter – which is clever, chilling and quite fiendish.
I was just as impressed with Bailey’s storytelling as when I first read his Reggie Fortune stories and I really *can’t* understand why his work is out of fashion. The plotting and characterisation are excellent, the scenario dark and compelling and it’s edge of the seat stuff while you desperately will Reggie on to sort things out. Bring back Reggie Fortune stories, I say!
The rest of the book looks to have plenty of treasures too: there are a number of authors here who have been picked up and celebrated by the British Library Crime Classics imprint, including John Rhode, Anthony Berkeley, Freeman Wills Crofts and R. Austin Freeman. A number of other familiar names are here, too, from my readings of Detection Club composite works, such as Father Ronald Knox and Milward Kennedy. And of course, there are Agatha and Dorothy…
So a positive cornucopia of delights into which to dip as an alternative to Big and Intense Books: you can look forward to hearing more about the stories in this volume when I need a quick crime break! 🙂
Mar 29, 2018 @ 07:25:44
The Yellow Slug story sounds excellent. What a great Oxfam find, and it sounds as if there’s lots more in the book to look forward to.
Mar 29, 2018 @ 11:46:54
It’s an excellent story, and I must say I’m looking forward to the rest of the book!
Mar 29, 2018 @ 09:20:02
This collection sounds so familiar to me but can’t for the life of me remember who, what, when or why? But great find and great post 🙂
Mar 29, 2018 @ 11:46:37
Thanks! I was quite pleased to stumble across it – the cover doesn’t really seem to do the contents justice!
Mar 30, 2018 @ 03:05:11
It sounds delightful! I love to curl up with a Dorothy Sayers, so the fact that she edited it…and I must admit I haven’t heard of many of the writers you mention. A great find!
Mar 30, 2018 @ 17:39:18
Sayers is one of my favourites too, so this was a double treat, because there are some great authors in it. Ideal reading therapy when I’m feeling stressed…
Mar 31, 2018 @ 09:07:25
What a find! I’ll definitely look out for HC Bailey too. I often find Oxfam overpriced compared to other charity bookshops. They should revisit their pricing policy,or maybe not, as it does mean I exercise some restraint!
Mar 31, 2018 @ 14:44:05
I really like the Bailey stories I’ve read A LOT – they seem to stand out amongst all the lovely GAC I read. And yes – I’m having to be selective about the Oxfam, particulary as I’ve just spent any book allowance I give myself on a Very Expensive Academic Book…. (oo-er…..)
Jul 23, 2021 @ 07:00:28