Perhaps that’s a slightly trite heading to choose for a section of “War and Peace” so packed with action, but it *is* something pivotal to this part of the epic journey I’m on with the book; which also contains one of the iconic scenes of Tolstoy’s great works.
This section opens with the fragile peace between Napoleon and Alexander still in place, and meanwhile life goes on as normal for the majority of people. Andrei is still living in the country, running his estate very competently and emancipating his serfs; in fact, he achieves everything that Pierre sets out to do but cannot, simply because he is so able and Pierre is totally impractical. However, Andrei is cold and emotionally locked away, and it’s only an encounter with the young and beautiful Natasha that draws him back to society and the more practical world of the court. For a while, Andrei comes back to life a bit whilst mixing in these circles again, but a re-encounter with Natasha at her first ball changes his outlook again quite dramatically.
Pierre, meanwhile, is as troubled and lugubrious as ever, spending most of this section in a haze of moral and spiritual soul-searching. The Masons are proving to be a little too worldly for him, most definitely not what he thought; and despite having agreed to live under the same roof as his estranged wife, there is no proper marriage. He is not ‘being a husband’ to her, and that seems to suit Helen perfectly, leaving her free to flirt and spend time with young men such as Boris. The latter seems to have changed for the worse as he’s matured, and despite his young infatuation with Natasha, it’s clear that neither wish to carry that relationship on as they grow up.
In the eyes of the world Pierre was a fine gentleman, the rather blind and ridiculous husband of a distinguished wife, a clever eccentric who did nothing but was no trouble to anyone, a good-natured, capital fellow – while all the time in the depths of Pierre’s soul a complex and arduous process of inner development was going on, revealing much to him and bringing him many spiritual doubts and joys.
Natasha Rostov herself comes much more into the fore in these chapters; at 16 she attends her first ball, and becomes the belle of it, spending much time danced with Andrei, who is completely smitten – just a bit of an age difference there, though…. She’s a vibrant character, injecting life into the story and her surroundings, although still very immature. She responds strongly to Andrei’s declaration of love, although she sees the good in Pierre too; and an engagement is agreed between Andrei and Natasha, although with the stipulation they must wait a year, leaving Andrei free to swan off abroad for his health.
In fact, the Rostovs and their fortunes are a troubling element here; through mismanagement they are lurching towards genteel poverty and it’s in the interests of the Count and Countess to match their children off to rich spouses. Eldest sister Vera has married a lowly soldier and so hopes now lie on Natasha. Interestingly, the inability of the nobles to deal with business and sort out their issues is a strong thread in the book; old Count Rostov is being systematically cheated, Pierre is totally fuddled by it all and only Andrei seems to have a business head.
Nikolai makes a lengthy reappearance and reconnects with his sister, spending happy hours hunting with her and celebrating Christmas. I’ll confess here that I skimmed some of the hunting pages, because I really *don’t* want to read them; but after the hunt, the group visits a local eccentric known as “Uncle” and it’s here that the famed dance of Natasha takes place. As a balalaika is played, Natasha taps into her unconscious heritage and performs a native Russian dance from who knows where, and it’s a powerful moment.
Tolstoy introduces another interesting aspect in the form of Pierre’s diary; he takes up the writing habit and Tolstoy treats us to regular extracts which plot the tortuous state of Pierre’s mind. It’s clear the poor man needs to be loved, but there seems to be no prospect of that on the horizon. Instead, he frets about his friends, uncertain for example whether the engagement of Andrei and Natasha is a good thing. Actually, no-one feels she is right for Andrei, and I felt a little uncomfortable about an old widower marrying a 16-year-old, particularly when she’s portrayed here as so childlike. However, towards the end of these chapters I felt that the cracks were showing slightly, with Andrei showing no inclination to rush back from abroad and visit his betrothed, and so I’m not sure whether this marriage will go ahead. By the end of this section, Nikolai had rekindled his childhood love for Sonya, but I feel a little trepidation about that too – Tolstoy doesn’t seem to want to portray happy relationships!
So another cracking couple of sections, packed full of action and an absolutely wonderful read. I’m constantly impressed by how well Tolstoy handles his material and keeps you involved at all times; and also by his powers of description. I felt I was actually living alongside the characters at times, racing through the snow in sledges, watching Natasha sing or dance, laughing at the mummers entertaining local children – the narrative was so vivid, and I’m absolutely hooked and desperate to find out what happens next!
Aug 07, 2017 @ 06:47:21
You’re making me want to read it all over again 🙂 Although admittedly I skipped the hunting description too – war is fine, but hunting, no!
Aug 07, 2017 @ 08:52:49
No- I can deal with what humans do to themselves but not what they do to animals.
Aug 07, 2017 @ 09:58:27
It’s wonderful to see you getting so much out of this and look how far you’ve got!! I fully understand you skimming the hunting scenes, knowing how you feel about that.
Aug 07, 2017 @ 16:08:14
I’m even further than this now….. 😉
Aug 07, 2017 @ 10:31:39
Thank you for a another lovely overview. I skimmed the hunting scenes too, but otherwise I’m captivated and very eager keep reading.
Aug 07, 2017 @ 16:07:40
Thank you! I’m becoming very invested in the whole thing, and I doubt I can hold off reading the whole thing to the end now.
Aug 07, 2017 @ 11:26:49
It only gets more exciting!
By the way, as an interesting side note: there is a movie by director Alesksandr Rogozhkin called “Peculiarities of the National Hunt” in which the main character engages in lengthy fantasies about the hunting scenes from W&P, which contrast with the farcical drinking bouts of the actual hunt he’s on. He also goes out and scythes grass like Levin in AK. No one ever manages to catch and kill any actual animals, FYI, so it’s okay for non-hunters to watch.
Aug 07, 2017 @ 16:07:06
Thanks! I haven’t heard of the film but I’ll keep an eye out for it!
Aug 07, 2017 @ 11:37:14
You are making steady progress in War and Peace. I have seen the BBC adaptation. Not sure if I would read the book now.
Aug 07, 2017 @ 16:06:39
I’m glad I *haven’t* seen any of the adaptations, actually, because I have some lovely images of the characters myself!
Aug 07, 2017 @ 16:16:00
That is seriously a good thing. Especially for a classic, it is always better to read and then see. I loved the adaptation of North and South but I was also glad I read the novel first and it turned out to be a favourite
Aug 07, 2017 @ 20:17:34
Definitely – but then I’m an advocate of the book always being better! 🙂
Aug 07, 2017 @ 12:11:01
This is one of my favourite parts of the book: Natasha growing up is a joy to behold. I simply can’t fathom how Tolstoy could put himself so completely and perfectly into a young girl’s shoes…
Aug 07, 2017 @ 16:06:04
No, he’s spot on, isn’t he? Really captures the confusion and emotions she goes through.
Aug 07, 2017 @ 13:45:07
So glad you’re getting so much from this read-a-long. I think it must have been Natasha’s story that I engaged with particularly when I read W&P all those years ago.
Aug 07, 2017 @ 16:05:40
I’m loving it! And yes, Natasha’s story is one of the strongest threads in the book, definitely.
Aug 07, 2017 @ 18:34:41
natasha is such a wonderful character. the book came alive for me every time she was on stage as it were
Aug 07, 2017 @ 20:17:11
She is – there’s a vivacity which really stands out and lights up the book.
Aug 08, 2017 @ 11:41:14
Enjoyed your post. I am giving it a rest. I am struggling with a down mood with my mum so bad and my brother’s family going through a dramatic time. Winter blues on top of it. The hunting did me in. Might pick it up as I kind of want to know what happens s but must admit I am not as keen on the characters are you are. I am enjoying your posts though very much. At least I know who these people are. 🐧🐧🐧
Aug 08, 2017 @ 17:01:06
I can understand that – if the book and the characters are not speaking to you, there’s no point in persevering. I hope things on the personal side pick up for you! 🙂
Aug 08, 2017 @ 15:57:24
I’m glad you are enjoying your read so much. Since it hasn’t been all that long since I read W&P, I am reading Anna Karenina, and I am struck by how “un-Russian” it feels, aside from the scenes with serfs. There are a few sleds and lots of beards and a little bit of Vodka, but otherwise, the story could take place anywhere. But that’s not a complaint; just an observation.
Aug 08, 2017 @ 16:55:31
I’m loving W&P and I did AK too – but I take your point with the latter – certainly W&P is more rooted in Russianness!
Aug 08, 2017 @ 19:33:58
The sledge ride is one of my favourite scenes, how wel does Tolstoy convey that exhilarating feeling! But you’re underestimating Tolstoy by not reading the hunting scene, it’s a key scene. Good luck!
Aug 08, 2017 @ 19:41:35
The sledge ride is brilliant. But as a vegan and anti-hunt person, I can’t read the detail, so I simply had to skim over that section. There was no other option for me.
Aug 08, 2017 @ 19:44:07
Understandable. Luckily there is only one hunting scene in War and Peace 😉
Aug 08, 2017 @ 19:46:00
Yes, so I’ve found out… 😉
Aug 08, 2017 @ 22:02:12
I hated the hunting scene on first read, but when I went back to it (looking for quotes and such, for the post I still haven’t done!) I liked it a lot more. You can see how Nikolai is trying to replace the structure and certainty of military life with the hunt – where the outcome is uncertain, but all the steps, and people role’s, and outfits, etc are rigid.
Aug 09, 2017 @ 06:59:31
Yes, Nikolai likes a rigid and structured life, doesn’t he – quite an inflexible man though I’m happy about the way his life turns out…
Aug 09, 2017 @ 03:07:54
I read “War and Peace” decades ago. Thank you for the detailed analysis of the sections. I feel like I’m re-reading the book through your posts. 🙂
Aug 09, 2017 @ 06:58:16
Thank you! I’m not sure if I will keep these kind of posts up though – it’s not the way I normally read…
Aug 09, 2017 @ 10:47:36
I see you’re very much enjoying your journey – this overview sparkles with excitement. It’s wonderful!
Aug 09, 2017 @ 10:51:54
I very much am enjoying it – such a wonderful and absorbing read! 🙂
Aug 09, 2017 @ 19:31:35
Aug 20, 2017 @ 18:47:07
A lovely post on this wonderful book! Natasha is charming, I love PIerre but aren’t the Masons boring? and I read the hunt but completely understand your reluctance. As I’ve said before, you make me want to reread this.
Aug 20, 2017 @ 18:49:44
Thank you! Yes, the Masons are dreafully tedious but I do love Pierre. It’s a really amazing book and I definitely intend to re-read it one day.
Aug 20, 2017 @ 19:12:33
I’m always hoping to find a new Colette, so thank you for telling me it’s The Shackle. I do sometimes buy books that are published under different titles…
Aug 20, 2017 @ 19:16:37
No probs – I’ve done exactly the same…. 🙂
Sep 11, 2017 @ 14:05:41
I liked your in depth research on war and peace novel by Leo Tolstoy.
Sep 11, 2017 @ 14:35:38
Many thanks! 🙂
Sep 17, 2017 @ 09:52:10
Great writing. Keep it up.
Sep 17, 2017 @ 11:03:54
Thank you!
Dec 16, 2021 @ 20:12:23
Congratulations on reading War and Peace, and blogging it too!
Dec 17, 2021 @ 11:53:43
Thanks! 😀