A Gentleman in Moscow by Amor Towles
I don’t normally pay a lot of attention to newly written novels coming out, preferring mostly to check out reprints or fresh translations of lost gems. However, one title which kept slipping into my line of vision and demanded attention was “A Gentleman in Moscow” by Amor Towles. I was a little uncertain about this, wondering if it would be a case of emperor’s new clothes and whether the author could capture properly the setting of Soviet Russia. However, I read so many good things about the book that I finally succumbed; and the publishers were kind enough to provide a review copy.
The book opens with the gentleman of the title, one Count Alexander Ilyich Rostov, appearing before a Bolshevik tribunal in 1922. Normally, an ex-member of the aristocracy would be up against the wall and shot before you could say Lenin, but in this case Rostov’s life is spared, owing to a pre-revolutionary poem he wrote in support of the cause. Instead, the Count is sentenced to house arrest in the Metropol Hotel where he’d been staying until summoned. Escorted back to the building, he finds that instead of returning to his luxurious suite, he’s instead moved to a tiny garret room with as many of his belongings as he can squeeze in. Thus begins the new life of Sasha Rostov.
The Count tends to treat everything that comes at him with equanimity, and so he initially attempts to make the best of things by reading his father’s volume of Montaigne essays and settling into his new dwellings. And he finds a novel way to extend his room to give a little more space and comfort, as well as continuing with many of his routines – as he has a secret stash of gold to enable him to send out for whatever he wants, he can continue to dine in the restaurant, visit the bar and have his hair seen to at the barbers. It is the shaving off of his moustache after an encounter with a worker waiting at the barbers which in turn causes a pivotal meeting in his life – with Nina, a 9-year-old also confined to the hotel while her parents are in Moscow. Nina opens up the secrets of the hotel to the Count, showing him the below-stairs view, and his life will never be the same again.
… we come to hold our dearest possessions more closely than we hold our friends. We carry them from place to place, often at considerable expense and inconvenience; we dust and polish their surfaces and reprimand children for playing too roughly in their vicinity – all the while, allowing memories to invest them with greater and greater importance … until we imagine that these carefully preserved possessions might give us genuine solace in the face of a lost companion.
But, of course, a thing is just a thing.
The book spans several decades from the time that Rostov is sentenced to house arrest in the Metropol, becoming a Former Person, and cleverly Towles doesn’t attempt to cover each and every part of that period in one continuous narrative. Instead, he drops us into the Count’s life at strategic points where we can find out how his life has changed and developed, as well as observing what has been happening in the wider world and how it impinges on life in the Metropol. Each section of the book brilliantly captures the flavour of the times whilst never losing sight of the fact that the main focus is on Rostov’s story. I don’t want to give away specifics, but suffice to say that the Count manages to have a love life, a kind of family life, friends and a career, all within the confines of the Metropol Hotel. Rostov may be confined, but the hotel is a microcosm of the world, and life comes to him.
If it sounds like the plot has the potential to be a little restricted be assured it isn’t, for a number of reasons. Firstly, Towles’ writing is elegant and absorbing, drawing you into the story and keeping you firmly involved from the start. Secondly, the Count himself is a wonderfully realised character about whom you can’t help but care. Then there’s the constant changes taking place around him – despite his confinement he has numerous experiences and adventures proving that you can lead a rich and full life even if you are stuck in a hotel forever. He encounters during his life two small female children and, interestingly, his response is different in both cases owing to the circumstances in which he finds himself and the changes in the world around him. He also develops strong friendships with fellow hotel workers, as well as an unexpected romantic attachment, all of which are a joy to behold.
As the story develops, the Count’s past is gradually revealed, most often through encounters with his old pre-revolutionary friend Mishka; the latter is also a poet and has embraced the revolution with fervour, worshipping the quartet of Akhmatova, Mayakovsky, Mandelstam and Bulgakov. There is also the story of Sasha’s beloved lost sister Helena, and her story shows that the aristocracy had plenty to feel guilty about.
Yes, those were Elysian days, thought Mishka. But like Elysium they belonged to the past. They belonged with waistcoats and corsets, with quadrilles and bezique, with the ownership of souls, the payment of tribute, and the stacking of icons in the corner. They belonged in an age of elaborate artifice and base superstition – when a lucky few dined on cutlets of veal and the majority endured in ignorance.
Of course there is an undercurrent of threat at all times – despite the apparent flippancy of the Count and the seemingly lightness of the story, Towles never lets us forget that there is a totalitarian regime in control and that life hangs by a slender thread. KGB agents stalk the city, Communist leaders attend banquets in private rooms, one functionary relies on Rostov to educate him on the ways of other countries, people are shipped off to Siberia (or worse) and when a particular dramatic event occurs it becomes clear how closely the Count is being watched. The story builds to an exciting and perhaps unexpected climax, with the author and the Count saving plenty of twists until the end.
“A Gentleman in Moscow” turned out to be a wonderfully rich and involving novel; Towles’ writing is just excellent, full of clever touches and metafictional aspects. He often breaks the fourth wall with digressions and footnotes and occasional direct dialogue with the reader, all of which is entertaining and adds to the joy of the book. I found myself constantly appreciating the skill of the author with such little details as the fact that each chapter title consists of a word, or a number of words, that start with the letter A. And his description of the Count trying to read the worthy Montaigne and being unable to stay focused on it struck many chords with me! Towles also very convincingly stirs into the mix real historical figures, from the Communist leaders through to legendary American foreign correspondent Harrison Salisbury, which adds further to the authenticity of the narrative.
However, there *is* much more to the book than just high jinks and adventures in a hotel. There is a regular dialogue on the pros and cons of the revolution, the role of the aristocracy and whether the revolution was a good thing. Although many of the new people in power are seen to be insensitive and unintelligent, so are many of the aristocracy. The book is surprisingly even-handed and the Count is not condemnatory or judgemental of the regime; much like Yuri Zhivago, he accepts that the change is for the best and although he rues his lost way of life, he’s clear-eyed enough to see its flaws, and Towles allows one character to give an interesting viewpoint on the changes the revolution brought:
The Bolsheviks are not Visigoths, Alexander. We are not the barbarian hordes descending upon Rome and destroying all that is fine out of ignorance and envy. It is the opposite. In 1916, Russia was a barbarian state. It was the most illiterate state in Europe, with the majority of its population living in modified serfdom: tilling the fields with wooden ploughs, beating their wives by candlelight, collapsing on their benches drunk with vodka, and then waking at dawn to humble themselves before their icons. That is, living exactly as their forefathers had lived five hundred years before. Is it not possible that our reverence for all the statues and cathedrals and ancient institutions was precisely what was holding us back?
In fact, Rostov goes through a series of symbolic transformations, most significantly the shedding of his moustache early in the book, and the radical shift from aristocrat to worker halfway through. A late statement in the book that he has not had to access his gold hoard for some time is significant, and it seems that the Count has found life, work and fulfilment all within the confines of a hotel, which is obviously intended as a metaphor for the wider world. No doubt Towles intends that we should reflect on the adaptability of human beings, and certainly we can learn to survive in most situations.
It is a well-known face that of all the species on earth Homo sapiens is among the most adaptable. Settle a tribe of them in a desert and they will wrap themselves in cotton, sleep in tents, and travel on the backs of camels; settle them in the Arctic and they will wrap themselves in sealskin, sleep in igloos, and travel by dog-drawn sled. And if you settle them in a Soviet climate? They will learn to make friendly conversation with strangers while waiting in line; they will learn to neatly stack their clothing in their half of the bureau drawer; and they will learn to draw imaginary buildings in their sketchbooks. That is, they will adapt.
As you can probably tell, I absolutely loved this book. Ideal for reading in the anniversary year of the 1917 revolution, it’s a winning combination of good writing, clever plotting, wonderful characterisation and a fascinating subtext – would that more modern novels aspired to such quality. The blurb on the dustjacket states “He can’t leave. You won’t want to”, and while I try to resist most advertising, I have to say that I didn’t want this book to end and I was really sad to leave the company of the Count and his friends!
(Review copy kindly provided by the publishers, for which many thanks!)
JacquiWine
Feb 26, 2017 @ 07:22:31
He’s an interesting writer. I really enjoyed another of his books – Rules of Civility – when I read it a few years ago. This new one sounds excellent too – glad to hear you loved it so much.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 26, 2017 @ 13:57:57
I did indeed – and I’m certainly going to keep a look out for Rules of Civility!
anneharrison
Feb 26, 2017 @ 07:43:13
An excellent review, thank you. I haven’t trread anything by this author, so thanks for bringing him to my attention.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 26, 2017 @ 13:57:31
Thank you, and very welcome! It’s a most enjoyable book!
Resh Susan @ The Book Satchel
Feb 26, 2017 @ 07:47:52
I have heard everyone who read this book rave about it. I am glad you loved it too. I hope to read it in April. The way people praise the book, I think I will surely check out Amor Towle’s previous book too if I end up enjoying Gentleman in Moscow
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 26, 2017 @ 13:56:44
His previous book got a lot of high praise too, and on the strength of this I certainly need to check it out!
heavenali
Feb 26, 2017 @ 09:08:57
This sounds utterly brilliant. You know I am not a big Russian lit fan as you are but this sounds so good, a worthy companion to the classic Russian literature you read. I might have to seek out a copy of this for myself. Superb review.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 26, 2017 @ 13:56:08
Thanks Ali! It’s a wonderful book – and I don’t think you need a huge knowledge of Russia to read it, especially as Towles pops in some footnotes here and there for the general reader! 🙂
MarinaSofia
Feb 26, 2017 @ 09:53:32
Mmmm, errrrr, I rather like the sound of this one and I was hoping I wouldn’t. Well, only a month or so to go on my book buying ban. I’m fascinated of course with everything to do with life under totalitarian regimes…
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 26, 2017 @ 13:55:18
I admit I kept telling myself that it probably wouldn’t be as good as everyone said. But I loved it in the end – I think it will be one of my top reads of the year (and we’re still in February!)
madamebibilophile
Feb 26, 2017 @ 10:09:14
I’ve heard so many good things about this and you’ve absolutely cemented my need to read this very soon! I do love the cover too, beautiful.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 26, 2017 @ 13:54:22
I heard good things too, and I was a little scared it wouldn’t live up to the hype – but it did!
Elle
Feb 26, 2017 @ 11:24:31
We’ve been championing this one at the bookshop! Towles is a lovely guy too, and I’m seriously thinking of getting it as a Mother’s Day present for my historian mother (who teaches a Russian history course!)
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 26, 2017 @ 13:52:48
If I’d got the books as Mother’s Day gift I’d have been very happy too! I really need to investigate Towles’ first book!
pigeonel15
Feb 26, 2017 @ 13:56:16
I tried reading Rules of Civility but found it vacuous. Although it seemed to be well-written, I felt it kept drawing attention to itself, which annoyed me. I couldn’t finish it.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 26, 2017 @ 13:58:59
Interesting! I quite like meta aspects to a book (and there are several here) so I might like “Rules” – who knows?
BookerTalk
Feb 26, 2017 @ 14:05:34
I kept hearing good things about this so added to my wishlist. Then yesterday when I was listening to the Readers podcast, Simon (one of the presenters) said he gave up on this book because it was repetitive. I don’t get that impression at all fro your review – in fact you make it sound astonishingly varied
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 26, 2017 @ 15:57:25
Gosh! I know all books are not for all readers, but I certainly didn’t find it dull. It’s long, yes, but that’s the joy of it – you can get involved with the charactes, watch the Count’s life evolve and the world change. Nope – I certainly didn’t find it dull! 🙂
BookerTalk
Feb 27, 2017 @ 14:57:58
I’m keeping it on my wishlist in that case
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 27, 2017 @ 15:07:52
Excellent! 🙂
Helen
Feb 26, 2017 @ 18:58:58
As you know, I’ve just read this and loved it too, so I agree with everything you’ve said about it here! I thought it was inspiring that the Count managed to lead such a fulfilling life despite being confined in one place for so long.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 26, 2017 @ 19:36:55
It was! Just proves that you can live a full and happy life under the most unlikely circumstances!
Jonathan
Feb 26, 2017 @ 20:59:32
I’ve read several reviews of this book and each one makes it sound appealing and the concept of the book is attractive anyway. I’m going to have to read it.
I disagree about the UK cover though as I prefer the other one with the gentleman looking out of the window.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 27, 2017 @ 09:19:19
It’s a readable book, and a clever one, and since writing my review I’ve read that there are clever things in the way it’s structured too. I can see what you mean about the US cover, but I *do* like the UK one a lot!
travellinpenguin
Feb 26, 2017 @ 22:28:54
I have recently purchased this book because I heard so much good about it and the cover is gorgeous. I am looking forward to reading it and now having read your review I think it may move closer to the top of the pile. (gosh, the pile is so high).
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 27, 2017 @ 09:18:17
It’s a wonderful book – very readable and engrossing. I hope you get to it soon!
Cynthia
Feb 27, 2017 @ 02:46:03
Loved the he book. Loved the Count. I truly didn’t want it to end.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 27, 2017 @ 09:17:53
Me too! 🙂
Liz Dexter
Feb 27, 2017 @ 08:48:47
How wonderful – I can imagine your fear that this wouldn’t live up to the older books, written closer to the time, that you love so much, and how brilliant to find that it did!
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 27, 2017 @ 09:17:39
It was a real treat – and I’m so glad I ended up loving it!
Sarah
Feb 27, 2017 @ 09:03:52
This does sound good Karen. I love the idea of reading something to mark the centenary of the revolution – you may well have tempted me away from icy crime!
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 27, 2017 @ 09:17:18
I’ve no doubt I shall be reading *many* Russians to celebrate the centenary!
Max Cairnduff
Feb 28, 2017 @ 17:31:00
Very nice. It sounds excellent. I had noted the cover. Who’s the publisher?
Reading War and Peace recently the treatment of the serfs really struck me. We use serfs rather than slaves, but they were slaves. They were owned. They were bought and sold. W&P draws some pretty clear parallels between serfs and a pack of hunting dogs, most interchangeable, some notable and so particularly valuable. It’s made very explicit.
The Russian Revolution led to slaughter and barbarism, there’s no question, but it came out of misery and barbarism. That penultimate quote really brings that aspect back – one of my thoughts reading W&P was that I could see why people rose up against these characters and their system, however likable they might individually be.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Feb 28, 2017 @ 17:37:24
It is! Published by Hutchinson and a lovely edition regardless of the content. Yes, agreed on all points – serfdom *was* slavery and the violence of everyday life in Russia beget the violence that followed. Like you, I do love to read pre-revolutionary Russian Lit, but I can understand why what happened did happen. What I liked about this book was its even handed look at things – Towles has criticisms for both regimes rather than using his book to just take a pop at Soviet Russia.
Caroline
Mar 01, 2017 @ 17:51:34
I absolutely loved Rules of Civility and want to read this too.
I’m so glad you enjoyed it so much. I’m pretty certain I will too. It sounds marvelous. He really is such an elegant writer.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Mar 01, 2017 @ 20:37:53
He is – I loved his writing and I’m keen to read Rules of Civility after enjoying this one so much!
anna amundsen
Mar 13, 2017 @ 11:46:52
I’ve read a lot of good things about ‘A Gentleman in Moscow’ and I noted it down on my reading list. This review just whetted my appetite. Especially the detail about breaking the fourth wall. Love that!
And the dust jacket is a thing of beauty!
Caught between two worlds | Kaggsy's Bookish Ramblings
May 06, 2017 @ 06:57:19
2017 – or, Distracted by Documentaries… | Kaggsy's Bookish Ramblings
Jan 01, 2018 @ 06:57:13
A Gentleman in Moscow by Amor Towles #bookreview | BookerTalk
Feb 13, 2018 @ 21:46:40